MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

SONY NEX3/NEX5 -> poor man's M8?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

So the cat is almost out of the bag. Info on the NEX is flying left and right:

http://digital-photography-school.com/sony-nex-3-review

Out of the chaos, I'm hearing that the flange focal distance is going to be 18mm.

An APS-C cam with an 18mm register would be really cool to play around with, with all the rangefinder lenses that are out there.

Not to mention the possibilities of a tilt/shift adapter that can take 135 (full frame coverage) lens! :-DDDD


This Sony is turning out to be pretty much what I wanted Samsung's NX to be.


Reply

Sadly, body not enough deep to take most RF wide lenses as Orio pointed out in other thread. So not much benefits from 18mm register distance.


Reply

Attila wrote:
Sadly, body not enough deep to take most RF wide lenses as Orio pointed out in other thread. So not much benefits from 18mm register distance.


I don't quite get the logic. Can you point me to the thread in question?

Will the NEX not be able to take lenses that micro-4/3 can?


Reply

rawhead wrote:
Will the NEX not be able to take lenses that micro-4/3 can?


Yes, if the adapters appear on the market. However, the adapters need to add thickness to the camera body to obtain correct register and to physically fit the lens, so being thinner is not in itself (much) of an advantage over µ4/3. The larger sensor is, though.


Reply

Arkku wrote:
rawhead wrote:
Will the NEX not be able to take lenses that micro-4/3 can?


Yes, if the adapters appear on the market. However, the adapters need to add thickness to the camera body to obtain correct register and to physically fit the lens, so being thinner is not in itself (much) of an advantage over µ4/3. The larger sensor is, though.


Yes, obviously I understand that. Again, I fail to see the disadvantage of APS-C and 2mm shorter register distance.

What's to stop all the Chinese/Japanese/German makers to make the full range of adapters available for m4/3 for the NEX?


Reply

Regarding tilt adapters; there's already a couple of makers that make 135->m4/3 tilt adapters:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/rawhead/4314531498/

The problem is the usual one, in that the crop factor is 2x. Also, perhaps due to flange issues, they only currently make available 135 mounts with the longest registers (M42, OM, PK, F, etc.). Since M42 and EF are about 2mm difference, these same guys could probably just take what they have, change the male end mount, and make their tilt adapters available for almost all 135 mounts -> Sony E mount.


The only drawback I can see with NEX is, ironically, the large size of the sensor, which would make all C-mount lenses useless. Conversely, I don't see why anybody would want to continue using m4/3 + adapters to use manual lenses with *except* C-mount lenses.

Indeed, that's how I envision I'll use my GF1: strictly a C-mount body (lol). The NEX could be my choice to use with all rangefinder lenses + 135->E tilt adapter.


Reply

rawhead wrote:

Yes, obviously I understand that. Again, I fail to see the disadvantage of APS-C and 2mm shorter register distance.


Me too. There is no such disadvantage—adapters can always make a thin body thicker, but the other way around is problematic. =)


Reply

rawhead wrote:
The only drawback I can see with NEX is, ironically, the large size of the sensor, which would make all C-mount lenses useless. Conversely, I don't see why anybody would want to continue using m4/3 + adapters to use manual lenses with *except* C-mount lenses.


Why does a larger sensor make the C-mount lenses useless?

You would still be exposing the same image circle on the same physical area of the sensor... just with more cropping in PP. Sounds like a no-loss situation to me. Wink


Reply

Scheimpflug wrote:
rawhead wrote:
The only drawback I can see with NEX is, ironically, the large size of the sensor, which would make all C-mount lenses useless. Conversely, I don't see why anybody would want to continue using m4/3 + adapters to use manual lenses with *except* C-mount lenses.


Why does a larger sensor make the C-mount lenses useless?

You would still be exposing the same image circle on the same physical area of the sensor... just with more cropping in PP. Sounds like a no-loss situation to me. Wink


Haha, I knew I might get a response like that Smile


Of course I went too far. There's is the definite disadvantage that the image circle will cover only a fraction of the total number of sensors, so all things equal, a cropped C-mount image on Sony NEX will have much fewer data than m4/3 + C-mount.


However, if there is a nice (near) step-less in-body crop feature in the NEX that will let the user see & frame at just the right crop factor, even before taking the shot, then yes, I can see the NEX be a very good C-mount body as well Smile


Reply

rawhead wrote:
Haha, I knew I might get a response like that Smile

Of course I went too far. There's is the definite disadvantage that the image circle will cover only a fraction of the total number of sensors, so all things equal, a cropped C-mount image on Sony NEX will have much fewer data than m4/3 + C-mount.


Very Happy

It all depends on your definition of "fewer data". The NEX3/5's sensor is higher resolution, but also larger... ending up being just a bit less dense in terms of pixels-per-mm. However, resolution isn't everything - the sensitivity and dynamic range of a sensor are relative to how many photons the sensor can capture at each pixel.

So while the m4/3 cameras may give just a touch more resolution with C-mount lenses, the Sony with its larger photosites will likely have less noise, higher sensitivity, and better dynamic range. Cool


Reply

Scheimpflug wrote:

So while the m4/3 cameras may give just a touch more resolution with C-mount lenses, the Sony with its larger photosites will likely have less noise, higher sensitivity, and better dynamic range. Cool



Perhaps. We'll see Smile

In the mean time, being able to frame at the cropped level I think is also important; hopefully the NEX will have such a feature.


Reply

rawhead wrote:

In the mean time, being able to frame at the cropped level I think is also important; hopefully the NEX will have such a feature.


As it's aimed for former P&S users, down to the menu-based “helpful” user interface, I seriously doubt there will be any extra support for adapted lenses. Seeing such options in the menu might seriously confuse soccer moms.


Reply

rawhead wrote:
Attila wrote:
Sadly, body not enough deep to take most RF wide lenses as Orio pointed out in other thread. So not much benefits from 18mm register distance.


I don't quite get the logic. Can you point me to the thread in question?

Will the NEX not be able to take lenses that micro-4/3 can?


Seek a Jupiter-12 picture for example it goes deep into camera body almost touch film plane. I think thin body can make problem this is true for m4/3 too. But RF wide lenses are almost unusable due 2x crop factor so I did hope next one like Sony allow to use excellent RF lenses like Jupiter-12.

Seems they not count it and they not made competitors for Leica Digital RF.


Reply

Arkku wrote:
rawhead wrote:

In the mean time, being able to frame at the cropped level I think is also important; hopefully the NEX will have such a feature.


As it's aimed for former P&S users, down to the menu-based “helpful” user interface, I seriously doubt there will be any extra support for adapted lenses. Seeing such options in the menu might seriously confuse soccer moms.


I agree we're unlikely to see much support from Sony regarding the use if manual lenses. Hence my original, somewhat hyperbolic comment that C-mount lenses will be useless Smile


Reply

[quote="Attila"][quote="rawhead"]
Attila wrote:

Seek a Jupiter-12 picture for example it goes deep into camera body almost touch film plane. I think thin body can make problem this is true for m4/3 too. But RF wide lenses are almost unusable due 2x crop factor so I did hope next one like Sony allow to use excellent RF lenses like Jupiter-12.

Seems they not count it and they not made competitors for Leica Digital RF.


well since the point of an adapter is to achieve the same distance from the back of the lens to the film/sensor plane across different systems, I still fail to see how this should be a problem. The only problem would be if the back part of a lens that needs to be inside the camera body is required to have a larger mount opening than the E mount. I guess some lenses could have that problem?


Reply

[quote="
Seems they not count it and they not made competitors for Leica Digital RF.[/quote]

well anybody who has the will and economic power to purchase an M9 isn't going to purchase any lowly Sony APS-C camera instead so of course it won't be a competitor. What I'm suggesting is that it could be a great substitute for a leica digital rf for lowly citizens like myself Smile


Reply

OK so I guess the issue isn't body thickness but the mount opening. With the gf1 etc the rectangular mask interferes with the rear elements of wideangle lense. That jut in.

In Japanese
http://m.kakaku.com/bbs/bbs_view.asp?pid=8709061&page=2



This guy says about 15mm is the maximum fir GF1


Which can't do Jupiter-12 but can do Ultra Heliar.


Still there's hope since the mount opening for the NEX is going to be much bigger since it has a bigger sensor.


Reply

Scheimpflug wrote:
rawhead wrote:
Haha, I knew I might get a response like that Smile

Of course I went too far. There's is the definite disadvantage that the image circle will cover only a fraction of the total number of sensors, so all things equal, a cropped C-mount image on Sony NEX will have much fewer data than m4/3 + C-mount.


Very Happy

It all depends on your definition of "fewer data". The NEX3/5's sensor is higher resolution, but also larger... ending up being just a bit less dense in terms of pixels-per-mm. However, resolution isn't everything - the sensitivity and dynamic range of a sensor are relative to how many photons the sensor can capture at each pixel.

So while the m4/3 cameras may give just a touch more resolution with C-mount lenses, the Sony with its larger photosites will likely have less noise, higher sensitivity, and better dynamic range. Cool


One should not really discuss noise etc. on the pixel level, but on the image level. Pixel size doesn't really influence much on noise - only the very deepest shadows become noisier, due to sensor/camera-related noise becoming the dominant source of noise instead of the photon shot noise. Also, even though the smaller pixels may increase the noise (or to be more precice, signal/noise may go down) in the deepest shadows, S/N will increase (thus "noise" will decrease) elsewhere.

Actually I dislike using the word "noise" when it comes to estimating/comparing/measuring camera performance, as it is such an abstract consept. Instead we should always use signal/noise, S/N, when discussing about the image quality instead. This way the discussion would more naturally be about the quality of the image, instead of pixels.

Now, whether the Sony or the m43-cameras create higher S/N for different kinds of images, I have no clue at the moment Smile


Reply

Attila wrote:

Seek a Jupiter-12 picture for example it goes deep into camera body almost touch film plane. I think thin body can make problem this is true for m4/3 too.


It's not a problem with a thin body, but rather the small sensor. If the camera had a full frame sensor, it wouldn't matter if the thickness was 10mm… As it is now, it may be the case that the opening made for 4/3 or APS-C sensor is not large enough for some of these lenses. Is the rear element of the J-12 larger than an APS-C sensor?


Reply

Arkku wrote:

It's not a problem with a thin body, but rather the small sensor. If the camera had a full frame sensor, it wouldn't matter if the thickness was 10mm… As it is now, it may be the case that the opening made for 4/3 or APS-C sensor is not large enough for some of these lenses. Is the rear element of the J-12 larger than an APS-C sensor?


I don't know, but for sure I know that while you can mount the J12 on the Kiev camera, you can not mount it on the Contax camera (and neither on any Leica M for that matter).
And note that Kiev and Contax have the same register distance.


Reply

Orio wrote:

I don't know, but for sure I know that while you can mount the J12 on the Kiev camera, you can not mount it on the Contax camera (and neither on any Leica M for that matter).
And note that Kiev and Contax have the same register distance.


Hmm, interesting. Do you know what prevents the J12 being mounted on the Contax and Leica M cameras? Since these are full frame film rangefinders, the only thing that comes to mind is that maybe the shutter curtain is closer to the flange than in the Kiev…


Reply

I don't know the reason why, only that the J12 can be mounted only on the prewar Contaxes. The post war Contaxes ( the large majority still available) can not.


Reply

Competition is good: we all benefit.
These are significantly smaller bodies, even than m4/3.

APS-c is also good as it will enable one lens used on this and (m)4/3 to have different effects.

They will not be of practical interest to me until the first adopters have sold and moved onto the next stage!


Reply

The excitement of the development of this camera is small registration distance and large lens mount opening, coupled with APS-C size sensor, it is especially true for those who wants to use old MF lenses on digital body.

The short registration distance would mean most film camera lenses, even RF lenses can be adapted, eg Leica, Contax RF and Contax G, there would be a thickness of about 10mm to work with the adapter. For the most difficult SLR, Alpa and Konica, with about 20mm to work on the adapter.

The large lens mount opening would open opportunity to lenses with large rear lens elements, particularly the symmetrical designed ones, like RF Biogons. The reason why pre-war II Biogons cannot be used on Contax IIa IIIa being the existence of large rear elements that the camera opening inside is not large enough to accommodate. The space inside the Nex camera seems to provide the freedom needed.

The APS-C size provides two distinct advantages, first to reduce the cropping factors to 1.5X ( compared with 35mm film ), let wide angles be wide angles, and with lower noise and better high ISO performance.

At this stage before the camera is readily available, some of the points could only be speculations, would have to be proven when adapters are made and real world experience is gained.

It has been reported that the Samsung offering EVIL camera cannot even be used with Leica RF lenses, because of the small opening inside the camera mount, the prospect of this camera does not seem very promising...

I am optimistic that one day there would be a FF EVIL camera available, by then all MF lenses could be revived without modification, let's keep our fingers crossed...


Reply

Welcome! Thank you for being an active member!