MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

what do i need in a new laptop for photo work?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

i am not even sure of how to frame the question, or if this is the correct forum. anyhow, my bride and i are looking into a new laptop. what do you guys suggest for hard drive storage, software, screen size, brand, stuff i don't even know how to ask about?
at some point i'll get a 35mm scanner, too. but right now, i just want to efficiently handle scanned negs on disks ...


Reply

This is a very subjective question and it not only depends on your personal taste, but also heavily on your budget.

I love my setup. 15" Macbook Pro. I would suggest at least 4gb ram and a dual core 2x ghz cpu. You can go a long way with a few hundred gigabytes of disk space and I would recommend getting a faster disk over a larger disk if you have to make the choice (7200+ RPM).

The Macbooks are a lot more expensive than most PC laptops but you get great quality with semantic innovations. And the new touch pads are simply amazing.

As far as PP goes I use lightroom and occasionally a little photoshop.


Reply

As a netbook user, I would say this: Don't get a netbook. Very Happy


Reply

no netbook. that's what i use for my 'net socializing, such as posting here. it's just time to replace the laptop that my bride uses at night. i'd use it during the day for uploading photos and editing them ...


Reply

Hi!

I'm using a 13" MacBook Pro 2.26GHz with 4GB of Ram, running Aperture for my photowork! It's absolutely fast enough and at Home there is a second screen for the big things!

I had a 15" MacBook Pro before and liked it very much but the 13" doesn't show much less but is much easier to carry! If you are getting a 15" MacBook Pro take the one with the new high resolution!

So this makes 1900$ min for a 15" MacBook Pro, versus 1199€ for a 13" MacBook Pro!!!! For 700$ you get a really nice second screen and a big external hard drive!

So bottom line, take the 13" (standard 1199€) and buy a second screen if you need it!

Oh and don't take the 7200 R/min Hard Drive!!! It's getting hotter and the advantage in image processing is as good as non existent (own experience!!!).

Oh, by the way, I sell these things and tried Aperture and photoshop on many different machines, before deciding to go for the smallest!

Cheers,

Karhallarn


Reply

Karhallarn wrote:
So bottom line, take the 13" (standard 1199€)


I agree. Get the bride a 13" Macbook. She will love it.

Karhallarn wrote:
Oh and don't take the 7200 R/min Hard Drive!!! It's getting hotter and the advantage in image processing is as good as non existent (own experience!!!).


If you use Lightroom it uses the hard drive for caching 1:1 views and will definitely benefit from the 7200rpm. I've been working on systems and networks for a long time now and the HD speed always makes a significant difference in overall system performance.


Also Mac runs on a Linux operating system and will forever be more efficient than any version of Windows.


Reply

I had a 7200 R/min Seagate in my MacBook and now I'm using a Samsung 5400 R/min, because of more space and less heat and there is no remarkable difference between them in Aperture!

In the Mac Pro with it's big 3.5" drives there is a remarkable difference between 5400, 7200 and 10000 but on the Notebook it seems that anything above 4200 in 2.5" is fine!

That's a completely different story for movies though! So maybe it's because of Lightrooms structure!

Thanks for the advice! Very Happy

Karhallarn


Reply

natebarnz wrote:
Karhallarn wrote:
Oh and don't take the 7200 R/min Hard Drive!!! It's getting hotter and the advantage in image processing is as good as non existent (own experience!!!).

If you use Lightroom it uses the hard drive for caching 1:1 views and will definitely benefit from the 7200rpm. I've been working on systems and networks for a long time now and the HD speed always makes a significant difference in overall system performance.


You have to be just a bit careful with the 5400 vs 7200 rpm decision, as the spindle speed is only one factor in the equation. The number of platters, the platter density, the cache size, the firmware design, etc, etc, all factor in to the overall performance. Some of the newer 5400 rpm drives are really wiping the floor with the older 7200 rpm models. Shocked

Not to mention that sometimes manufacturers just "get it right", and sometimes manufacturers produce real duds. For example, the 500GB 7200 rpm Seagate 7200.4 was infamous for being slower in general use than the 500GB 5400 rpm Western Digital WD5000BEVT. It turns out that the Seagate was optimized for a few benchmarks (data transfer rates of very large files), and just wasn't consistently fast for normal tasks. There were also many firmware problems with the drive, and Apple, Dell, and others who had used the drive were issuing patches while complaints in the user forums reached hundreds of pages. It was the first 2.5" 500GB 7200RPM drive on the market, and they just didn't have all of the kinks worked out yet.

So yeah, don't get too caught up by the spindle speed... the benchmark tests are where the real comparisons can be made. Wink


natebarnz wrote:
Also Mac runs on a Linux operating system and will forever be more efficient than any version of Windows.


OSX is actually UNIX based, not Linux based. A small, but somewhat important technicality. Wink


Reply

External drives or virtual hosting will take care of your file archives, I wouldn't sweat too much about the laptop hard drive choice. Just see that you don't buy yourself and MB/MBP with the glossy screen! Lots of memory, 8GB isn't really a lot when you RAW to JPEG files. 17" screen I could not live without, this is my 4th year and 2nd MBP with the larger screen.


Reply

Look at glossy yourself!

I love my glossy screen!

Calibration is a must with or without gloss!

13" and external Screen rock the road and the studio!


Reply

Karhallarn wrote:
Look at glossy yourself!


Yes, I have looked and used a glossy Mac screen. Glare, reflection, you need the perfect viewing angle to get the right contrast & brightness for editing work. Sure it looks good but it is not suitable for a color management environment. It punches up the contrast and vibrance of photos - looks good but is a nightmare if you need true color management from RAW to print or magazine delivery.

For an amateur photographer who rarely prints anything, glossy is a great choice as it gives extra punch and vibrance to photos.

For anyone who needs a color management environment and does editing for magazines and stock - forget the glossy.

I use a matte Macbook Pro 17" for photo editing in the field, and an Eizo ColorEdge CG222W at my studio. Yes, calibrated of course.


Reply

@Esox lucius: I bow to the master! Very Happy

For my needs my MacBook 13" Glossy, Formac Gallery 2010 IPS Panel screen and spyder 3 Elite calibration make anything I need!

Thr proffed and ordered prints I did worked out really good too!


Reply

Laughing Embarassed

A calibrated Macbook screen is good enough for normal work - I also print straight from edit done on an MBP calibrated when I'm travelling. In fact, the prints look better than on the laptop; if it's a good print vendor you will see that the paper version shows more detail and color shades than your laptop screen can.

The only thing you need a really good monitor is for proofing and color management, it's nice to be able to see on screen what the final result will look like as opposed to guessing how good it's going to be.


Reply

That's what my Formac is for!


Reply

Esox lucius wrote:
Karhallarn wrote:
Look at glossy yourself!


Yes, I have looked and used a glossy Mac screen. Glare, reflection, you need the perfect viewing angle to get the right contrast & brightness for editing work.


+1 Don't buy the glossy one.
More than that : don't buy a Mac.
Buy a Dell or HP with the same features, half the price but having a 15" or 17" screen. The difference in price is the premium for the name.
I have a Compaq, 15", I use it when I shoot tethered.
I don't even bother to edit on it.


Reply

MBP for me.
Life after Microsoft is such a nice place.

You and wifey would likely never need to buy another computer.


Reply

We just couldn't justify cost of the Mac. We got a Toshiba L555 laptop, 17-inch screen, dual processors, 4gb hard drive, blah, blah, blah. Boy, was it easy to download some photos - quickly. This is a whole new cyber world for me ... Very Happy