MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Using auto fix in windows live-Soligor 90-230mm
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I like this photo but as you can see it is lacking and not straight Embarassed

#1


So I have made a copy and used the auto fix feature on windows live gallery and this is the result.
#2


I just want some opinions on which one is better and for someone who does not have the expensive Photoshop or other post processing software's, by letting this program auto fix the photo is it cheating? and
does it hurt to change what comes out of the camera?
I want to improve in my techniques and understanding on how things work with cameras & lenses and film, so I find I want to show where I am at as a photographer more so than show a photo that has been changed in any way.


Reply

I usually try the Auto Fix function in whatever software I'm using; sometimes results are better than original, sometimes not. Depends on how good the auto algorithms are and how close image is to 'standard image' algorithms were written to correct. If auto-correct doesn't produce good results, then I use software 'levels and curves' adjustment and sharpening to adjust to my tastes -- I prefer image look as close to actual scene, colors & contrast, as possible.

For lens comparisons I believe no processing at all is important.

GIMP is freeware image processing software, actually quite good -- versions are available for Win, Linux, & Mac OS: http://www.gimp.org/

I don't consider it 'cheating', no. I will turn your question around and ask you: which image do you think is better, which is closest to what you see? For example, is the grass really as green as the auto-correct made it?


Last edited by visualopsins on Tue Apr 27, 2010 3:26 am; edited 1 time in total


Reply

In my opinion, post-processing is definitely not "cheating". In the past, it was quite common to make adjustments & minor corrections in the darkroom, both during the developing step and when making the print. Certainly your photo above would have been leveled for the final print - you just wouldn't have thought anything of it.

It is only with the modern automation and the hands-off unification of the developing and printing stages that we have adjusted to the notion that the photographic process ends when the shutter release is pressed. Sad While it did much to bring economical photography to the masses, it was also a great loss for the hobby as well. Sad

So that being said, I also believe that how much PP you apply depends on your intentions for the photo. If you are a photojournalist, sure, you may want to keep it as "accurate" as possible and minimize the processing. However, if you think of yourself as an artist, or if you are trying to capture a memory, then by all means process away until the photo either "looks right", or looks the way you would like to remember it. Wink

---------

Switching gears back to PP in the digital age, don't feel like you have to spend a fortune or practice techniques for hours to get what you want. I did this in about 5 minutes in GIMP, a free open-source photo editing package. It isn't perfect, and it might not be realistic to what you saw, but it should show what is possible.



I'd be happy to write down the step-by-step instructions if you would like. Wink


Reply

GIMP is freeware image processing software, actually quite good -- versions are available for Win, Linux, & Mac OS: http://www.gimp.org/

There is also a modified version of gimp, which is closer to Photoshop.
It's called gimpshop.
http://www.gimpshop.com/

Just started playing around with it, so I can't tell you how good it is.


Reply

I have gimp but have no idea how to use it,I have been slowly working through it's manual.
Scheimpflug
Wow, the fact you straightened it! It is a little too intense with the colors but you have shown me the what gimp can do.
I do Like the 2nd photo I posted as it removes that whiteness on the original,you have to forgive me as I have to get up to date with the technical terms,I think it is the contrast?.
Thanks I would like to keep my photos as close to what I see when taking the photo.It looks like I am on the right track with already having gimp on hand.I just have to put more time into using it....I really appreciate all your comments Very Happy


Reply

mo wrote:
I just want some opinions on which one is better and for someone who does not have the expensive Photoshop or other post processing software's, by letting this program auto fix the photo is it cheating? and
does it hurt to change what comes out of the camera?
I want to improve in my techniques and understanding on how things work with cameras & lenses and film, so I find I want to show where I am at as a photographer more so than show a photo that has been changed in any way.

-Objectively the second one looks a bit colder than the first. I don't see particular dominants of color in the original either. Subjectively the second one looks maybe more natural to me, but that's just a matter of taste.
-If the "auto fix" makes the photo look the way you want it's fine. Period. No one will know anyway if you don't tell.
-Altering a photograph to improve it is a normal practice, has always been. The means are different if one works in a darkroom, but always altering is.
-We're here to discuss and sharing advice. Either if you're post a photograph straight out of the camera or an improved version of it what you'll get here will be the same: an honest opinion, good tips, or possibly even congrats Smile.
Cheers, M.-


Reply

Quote:
-Altering a photograph to improve it is a normal practice, has always been. The means are different if one works in a darkroom, but always altering is.

This has been the biggest revelation to me since I have started to learn more about photography.


Reply

nice landscape, the original have better colors than the other 2


Reply

I am surprised as I think the original looks faded? Could it be because it is winter and the brown bare trees dominate the picture?


Reply

mo wrote:
Could it be because it is winter...

Probably has a lot to do with that. If you watch carefully the same spot in different seasons you'll possibly notice great differences, to the point it will eventually look almost unrecognizable. I'll tell you more. At different hours on the same day it will look totally different. Think about cool colors in the morning and warmer ones at sunset. The shadows, then. Towards noon they'll be almost nil, and everything will look flatter. The shadows are important because they give "shape", three-dimensionality, depth to a picture. Don't take anything for granted, always watch carefully, when you "see" grab the camera Smile. That said sometimes we happen to be in particular place at a particular time that may not be photographically the best at all and we have to take what we find and be content with that Smile.

Cheers, M.-


Reply

Cheers Marty for your insights...I understand fully about the later sun and the 3D depth you see on the landscapes.I find myself looking every where I go and say I must "see" what this looks like at this time or that time (computers can't do that)... Very Happy


Reply

Hello mo, what a lovely green scene, it looks like England! Smile

I like the balance of colours of the original picture better myself, but I think it might be slightly overexposed or the lens is lacking a little contrast possibly. I wonder if a lens hood would improve things?


Reply

marty wrote:
sometimes we happen to be in particular place at a particular time that may not be photographically the best at all and we have to take what we find and be content with that Smile.

Words of wisdom Marty! So many times I have thought, "Oh, if only I could here at a different time" Smile


Reply

The church is my test subject for all my long lenses so I will try it with a hood.
This is because we have had good rain it used to be brown and brown dead grass! Very Happy


Reply

You really need to practice with your GIMP or what ever software, it can make a big difference. Its a nice picture and I believe a small adjustment in curves would bring out what you are looking for.

I don't have GIMP but I could do a small adjustment in curves in PS to show you what I mean if you like.


Reply

Yes that would be nice...Thanks
Quote:
I don't have GIMP but I could do a small adjustment in curves in PS to show you what I mean if you like.


Reply

I turned down the exposure a little, gave it an S curve and added just a TINY amount of sharpening.



Reply

A big difference and not as intense as Scheimpflugs ,can I ask what an S curve is in layman terms?


Reply

mo wrote:
A big difference and not as intense as Scheimpflugs


Haha. Yeah, I just cranked it up to show what was possible... it is completely up to you though, you can adjust it to any level in between the extremes. Wink

Levels & Curves are probably the two most useful adjustments in modern image editors. Here are a few good tutorials, with a lot of before/after comparisons:
http://www.cambridgeincolour.com/tutorials/levels.htm
http://www.cambridgeincolour.com/tutorials/photoshop-curves.htm


Reply

I hope you were not offended,it did sound bad...sorry.
Thanks for the tutorials...I need them Very Happy


Reply

Not at all. Wink

Oh, also make sure you keep in mind that when working digitally, the process is somewhat destructive. Any time you make an adjustment, some information will be lost.

This isn't the end of the world, but it has some implications. In particular, you would want to avoid making the same or similar adjustments twice. So it would be best to make all of your changes (contrast, color balance, exposure, etc) in one shot with one set of curves, rather than multiple separate applications of curves or other tools (contrast, saturation, etc).

Once you get a little further, you will also have to be mindful of the order of operations, especially when you start mixing lens corrections (CA & distortion), geometry adjustments (rotation/skew/crop/scale/etc), and color adjustments.


Reply

I think for the most part I will stick to the basics and hopefully not get sucked into to much technical stuff and loose the whole reason I love my photos... Laughing Curves and Levels for now... Wink


Reply

Ahh, see, I enjoy the technical part. Very Happy

Regardless - best of luck, and let us know if you get stuck anywhere. Cool