MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Same scene, two cameras
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply






Although this isn't the best possible quality - my cable release didn't work! - and only one camera (as far as I recall) was on the tripod (the ES-II I leaned on a rock)... this is an interesting comparison relative to film size.

One photo is with the Bessa 1 / Vaskar, Tri-X developed in D76 1:1. The other is with the Pentax ES-II, S-M-C Takumar 3.5 / 28mm, HP5+ developed in Ilfosol-S 1:9. Both scanned via Epson 4490.


Reply

Here's another from the Bessa, I thought this one came out very well Smile



Reply

Very nice, I have a softspot for REAL B&W (film).


Reply

Interesting comparison. I would not know which one to choose from the 2 shots.

The 3rd shot is really fantastic.

Cheers
Tobias


Reply

I second Tobias full heartedly!!!


Reply

Very nice. BTW there is a stray hair on the second scan. Wink


Reply

Older stuff , vintage rendition, i like the first one kinda "lith" compared to the second one, bith are great.

But pic 3 Shocked one of the best shots i've seen lately. congratz


Reply

The first picture is more pictorial (poetic).
The second picture resolves much better the details, especially in the shadows.
Photographically speaking the second picture wins hands down I think.
However there can be room for the first picture also if the viewer is more oriented to the romantic side.


Reply

#2 for me as well, but I also love #3. A wonderful B+W series


patrickh


Reply

Number three is the one for me. I thought at first it was my tinnitus playing up, but I really can hear the falling water.


Reply

All thre are outstanding. I like very much the #1.
The waterfall is superb, thanks for sharing!.

Jes.


Reply

I must be a romantic, I like both the Bessa shots, especially No 3 which is superb.


Reply

Why thank you folks- I'm liking both cameras/lenses, and see the latitude in processing makes for a very large area of variability. The thing that excites me is that the Bessa with its Vaskar, with the 6x9 negative, manages to resolve so much. The larger negative seems more forgiving, with 35mm everything has to be just right to get optimal sharpness.

(In case it isn't clear, #1 is the Pentax, the other two are Bessa)

Here's one more with the 28mm... I haven't yet finished developing and scanning all the film Wink



Reply

Seems the Bessa is far better at capturing the motion in the image. The pentax is really well detailed, but also.. perhaps too precise.


Reply

That's an astute observation!

I stopped down the Vaskar to f/11-f/16, with resulting shutter speeds of 1 sec to 1/8 or so. With the 28, I figured I did not need (or want) such a small aperture, so these were f/8, or sometimes f/11. Faster shutter speeds are the result.

#3 is my favorite as well, things came together on that shot.

Here's another same scene comparison - first Bessa then Pentax: