MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Scanning Software # 1 Silverfast versus Vuescan
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I am comparing Vuescan and Silverfast Ai software on a flatbed scanner.

I did these tests using the same 35mm negative on an Epson 4870, the flatbed that I have used since it came out in 2004. Epson has some proprietary software called Epsonscan but I didn’t put Epsonscan in the tests as both Silverfast Ai and Vuescan are in my opinion far better.

The shot is taken with Kodak Gold 200, (I don’t know what generation but fairly new). Unfortunately I had to do the scans on separate days so the dust and hair on the negatives are different but I hope this is forgiven.

I scanned these with both softwares at default settings with no sharpening, color adjustments or anything else. The scan is at 2400 DPI., taken by my wife with a Canon AE1-P, 50mm 1.4 lens, wide open in some shade

This is my late friend Pat Colecchio, peace be with him (Yes he’s of the Colecchio family from Colecchio, Italy near Parma), that’s me in the bokeh.



Immediately you can see an issue that is color. These are the default settings in both softwares. Silverfast Ai is obviously much more saturated, Vuescan looks more “real” and is actually more representative of the real colors than Silverfast Ai.. Vuescan also has 24 options for versions of Kodak Gold film, Silverfast Ai has 4.

This next shot is “cleaned up” scans, the Silverfast Ai version using digital ICE and the Vuescan version done by hand. Silverfast Ai’s version of ICE saturates the picture even farther. This is unacceptable to me.



4 hours was mentioned about cleaning up the scans by hand. The Vuescan version took me 16 minutes which is about 10 minutes less than what it took to use digital ICE, adjusting the setting, doing a test version and finally scanning. As you can see, digital Ice only got about 2/3 of the problems with the negative and then there were still problems that I would have to do by hand anyway.

I must admit that I’m fast at hand cleaning negatives as I don’t usually use digital ICE and I’ve been doing it for some time so I have an advantage there. I much prefer hand cleaning to Silverfast Ai’s Digital ice. It does take time to learn how to use Vuescan but like many things, it’s worth it for a flatbed scanner in my opinion.

Jules


Reply

hi Jules,
thanks for the very interesting comparison.
I have no experience with these software, but I have ICE in the Epson interface for the 4490, and I share your opinion, I don't like it at all - it takes away life and detail. I prefer much to have some grain than to use it.
I too, when necessary, do hand edit the scans, although most of the times I am just lazy and leave them unretouched Rolling Eyes

Nice photo this one with your friend, also Smile

I live some 20-25 km away from Collecchio (double L), Parma.
The name of the little town has a meaning and a Latin origin (collicchius = small hill). I never heard of a family with the same name as the town, and in fact the map of Italian last names confirms that there is 0 entries with Collecchio as last name:

http://www.gens.labo.net/en/cognomi/genera.html?cognome=COLLECCHIO&t=cognomi

Colecchio, instead (with just one L), has two entries in the last names map, one in the north of Emilia, the other one in Naples:

http://www.gens.labo.net/en/cognomi/genera.html?cognome=COLECCHIO&t=cognomi

Colecchio, however, sounds decidedly not Emilian as last name, but southern Italian. So my guess is that the Colecchio last name is of Neapolitan origin.


Reply

Orio wrote:
hi Jules,
thanks for the very interesting comparison.
I have no experience with these software, but I have ICE in the Epson interface for the 4490, and I share your opinion, I don't like it at all - it takes away life and detail. I prefer much to have some grain than to use it.
I too, when necessary, do hand edit the scans, although most of the times I am just lazy and leave them unretouched Rolling Eyes

Nice photo this one with your friend, also Smile

I live some 20-25 km away from Collecchio (double L), Parma.
The name of the little town has a meaning and a Latin origin (collicchius = small hill). I never heard of a family with the same name as the town, and in fact the map of Italian last names confirms that there is 0 entries with Collecchio as last name:

http://www.gens.labo.net/en/cognomi/genera.html?cognome=COLLECCHIO&t=cognomi

Colecchio, instead (with just one L), has two entries in the last names map, one in the north of Emilia, the other one in Naples:

http://www.gens.labo.net/en/cognomi/genera.html?cognome=COLECCHIO&t=cognomi

Colecchio, however, sounds decidedly not Emilian as last name, but southern Italian. So my guess is that the Colecchio last name is of Neapolitan origin.


Thank you Orio.

His real name is Pasquali, but he went by Pat. The spelling of his name is in some doubt as his Father emigrated in about 1915 or so and I don't know how much they anglicized his name.

Thanks so much for the research as I would like to go there when I visit you sometime in the future Smile. Pasquali and I were friends for 40 years.

Jules


Reply

lulalake wrote:

His real name is Pasquali, but he went by Pat. The spelling of his name is in some doubt as his Father emigrated in about 1915 or so and I don't know how much they anglicized his name.


The name was certainly anglicized from Pasquale (typical neapolitan first name).
And you know what? The last name also was, I bet.
Look here:

http://www.gens.labo.net/en/cognomi/genera.html?cognome=COLICCHIO&t=cognomi

The above is the map for the last name Colicchio, which is a typical last name of Campania (the region of Naples). As you can see, there are three big clusters of Colicchio last name in Campania, plus one in Milan and one in Turin, but the last two have been certainly generated by internal immigration from south to north (in Milan and Turin there are industries, while in the south there is little work available).

Now, it sounds perfectly plausible that the name Colicchio was changed into Colecchio in the USA, because you pronounce the letter "e" the same way we pronounce the letter "i" Smile

So I bet that your dear friend full name was originally meant to be Pasquale Colicchio. Very Happy

lulalake wrote:
Thanks so much for the research as I would like to go there when I visit you sometime in the future Smile. Pasquali and I were friends for 40 years.
Jules


If you ever come to Italy, don't forget to make a stop here! It will be nice to meet you!


Reply

Jules, very interesting thread, both the scanning software comparisons, and
your friend's family background/origins. The Silverfast gives you a nice
tan, Jules! But you're right the Vuescan (to me) looks far more realistic.

Would be interesting to see a comparison of other films, tho this would be
labor intensive.

Thanks for sharing this!

Bill


Reply

In Silverfast you have to choose the grey point and use the levels and curves to get good colors. And the preview is pretty real instead on Vuescan, as I said, it's more a hit and miss.
Which setting of ICE did you use? Speed or Quality one?
I never had those artifacts using Quality setting nor I had IQ drop, it's just boring long to complete.
And about the 4 hours, try to clean a medium format 50 MP image, 35 mm is a lot smaller Wink


Reply

A G Photography wrote:
In Silverfast you have to choose the grey point and use the levels and curves to get good colors. And the preview is pretty real instead on Vuescan, as I said, it's more a hit and miss.
Which setting of ICE did you use? Speed or Quality one?
I never had those artifacts using Quality setting nor I had IQ drop, it's just boring long to complete.
And about the 4 hours, try to clean a medium format 50 MP image, 35 mm is a lot smaller Wink


Hi Alessandro,

These colors were obtained using the default settings of both softwares. In Vuescan I chose Kodak Gold GEN-4.

The ICE settings were pretty aggressive but I don't remember what they were.

Could you suggest some settings I can try in Silverfast to get a better result? Thanks. (I do print a lot and quite large so high Quality settings are important to me)

I pretty regularly clean 122+ meg MF negs and Slides (48 bit color 2400 DPI). I've quite honestly never had it take more than 40-45 minutes but actually . . I like doing it (I know, I'm a geek he he).

Cheers

Jules


Reply

lulalake wrote:
A G Photography wrote:
In Silverfast you have to choose the grey point and use the levels and curves to get good colors. And the preview is pretty real instead on Vuescan, as I said, it's more a hit and miss.
Which setting of ICE did you use? Speed or Quality one?
I never had those artifacts using Quality setting nor I had IQ drop, it's just boring long to complete.
And about the 4 hours, try to clean a medium format 50 MP image, 35 mm is a lot smaller Wink


Hi Alessandro,

These colors were obtained using the default settings of both softwares. In Vuescan I chose Kodak Gold GEN-4.

The ICE settings were pretty aggressive but I don't remember what they were.

Could you suggest some settings I can try in Silverfast to get a better result? Thanks. (I do print a lot and quite large so high Quality settings are important to me)

I pretty regularly clean 122+ meg MF negs and Slides (48 bit color 2400 DPI). I've quite honestly never had it take more than 40-45 minutes but actually . . I like doing it (I know, I'm a geek he he).

Cheers

Jules


In Silverscan you have levels and curves just like in Photoshop. Another little important thing is the tool at the very right that let you set white, grey and black point. I always set black point using the black film and about 90% of color cast problems are solved this way. If you have good neutral gray zone in your shot you can also set a grey point for further refinement.
Then you can set the levels, I always try to acquire ALL the dymamic image range. I rarely use the curve tool unless I missed the exposition in the shot and I need to recover some burned or too black areas.
I sometimes also increase or decrease exposition in those cases too.

This way I get the basic image, further post processing is done in Photoshop because it's more powerful and 16 bit.


Reply

Many, many thanks for this review ! Nice to see you!

I like silvers fast better, more warm colors


Reply

This is interesting as I'm using the Epson software that comes with, and have been curious about these two.

Color aside, which do you think is the better software?

I agree about ice also, though sometimes I leave it on.


Reply

A G Photography wrote:
lulalake wrote:
A G Photography wrote:
In Silverfast you have to choose the grey point and use the levels and curves to get good colors. And the preview is pretty real instead on Vuescan, as I said, it's more a hit and miss.
Which setting of ICE did you use? Speed or Quality one?
I never had those artifacts using Quality setting nor I had IQ drop, it's just boring long to complete.
And about the 4 hours, try to clean a medium format 50 MP image, 35 mm is a lot smaller Wink


Hi Alessandro,

These colors were obtained using the default settings of both softwares. In Vuescan I chose Kodak Gold GEN-4.

The ICE settings were pretty aggressive but I don't remember what they were.

Could you suggest some settings I can try in Silverfast to get a better result? Thanks. (I do print a lot and quite large so high Quality settings are important to me)

I pretty regularly clean 122+ meg MF negs and Slides (48 bit color 2400 DPI). I've quite honestly never had it take more than 40-45 minutes but actually . . I like doing it (I know, I'm a geek he he).

Cheers

Jules


In Silverscan you have levels and curves just like in Photoshop. Another little important thing is the tool at the very right that let you set white, grey and black point. I always set black point using the black film and about 90% of color cast problems are solved this way. If you have good neutral gray zone in your shot you can also set a grey point for further refinement.
Then you can set the levels, I always try to acquire ALL the dymamic image range. I rarely use the curve tool unless I missed the exposition in the shot and I need to recover some burned or too black areas.
I sometimes also increase or decrease exposition in those cases too.

This way I get the basic image, further post processing is done in Photoshop because it's more powerful and 16 bit.


Thank you Alessandro,

I will try this. I agree that the Vuescan preview is not good.

Jules


Reply

lulalake wrote:

Thank you Alessandro,

I will try this. I agree that the Vuescan preview is not good.

Jules


You're welcome.

Using defaults in this kind of software is like using AUTO program on a modern SLR Wink Unfortunately you have need to spend some time to learn by mistakes. In this I prefer Silverscan, less options and more real preview, I also used Vuescan or some MF rolls but sincerely the gazillion options never helped me to improve the poor "default" scans I got from it. Maybe is better and more powerful than Silverfast, but I found it less reliable and consistent. Maybe it's me Very Happy


Reply

lulalake wrote:
This is my late friend Pat Colecchio, peace be with him (Yes he’s of the Colecchio family from Colecchio, Italy near Parma), that’s me in the bokeh.


Jules,

I am Pat's nephew Gary. I've been a big fan of your work since I was 12 and you were Gary.

Dubuque Blues is on my phone.

Anyway thanks for the photo. I didn't get to see my uncle in his last few years.

His passing was very sad and empty.


Reply

Comparing different results with different software is quite misleading, unless you have profiled your software/scanner/film combination for correct scan results.

In other words: buy an IT8 target slide, insert profiling test slide in your scanner, run the Vuescan profile film process. Save settings as a film profile and make sure you use that profile when scanning same type of film next time.

Repeat process for every different film you use/scan to get correct results.

More on the subject here

http://www.hamrick.com/vuescan/html/vuesc16.htm
http://www.computer-darkroom.com/it8cal/it8_page_1.htm
http://www.targets.coloraid.de/