MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

What about White Balance ?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I find the WB auto selection of my 40d to be most of the times way off .
And i really dont know much about color temperture .
So what do you do with white balance ?
I know that the white ( or grey ) card may not always be easy to cary .
Have you ever tried http://photography.shop.ebay.com/i.html?_nkw=white+balance+lens+cap&_sacat=78997&_trksid=p3286.m270.l1311&_dmpt=Camera_Lenses&_odkw=mir+24&_osacat=78997 any of theese ?
Are they accurate ?
Excuse me if there is already such a thread i havet found it .
If there is please mods delete this one .

Thank you for reading ,

Panos .


Reply

I don't understand how one of these WB caps would work? If the cap is transmitting ambient light, how will it be a good indicator of true white?

As for what I do for WB, I usually try to handle it during PP. If I can find something in the image that should be 18% gray, it's usually an easy process. It gets tricky if there isn't anything gray in the image.


Last edited by cooltouch on Mon Oct 19, 2009 12:21 am; edited 1 time in total


Reply

Well i dont know either .
But even if they dont work they may make good caps Razz

Panos .


Reply

white cap fit in a pocket and are easy to use
It is not accurate as a gray card and give different value depending where you point it
the 40D give me good result and I don't use caps anymore
are you sure that you lcd is calibrated, do you print pics


Reply

cooltouch wrote:
I don't understand how one of these WB caps would work? If the cap is transmitting ambient light, how will it be a good indicator of true white?


I don't know for sure, but I suspect somebody found a market for old medecine bottle lids. Smile


Reply

I have a gossen sixtomat which cost me all of $5 and gives pretty accurate readings of color temperature. Bit bulky, but otherwise just set the camera for "sunny" and leave it there


patrickh


Reply

cooltouch wrote:
I don't understand how one of these WB caps would work? If the cap is transmitting ambient light, how will it be a good indicator of true white?


The cam can adjust the WB by aiming at a pure white sheet of paper and then calculating the actual difference to what it sees in the given surroundings. This is what all the pro cameramen do when they shoot indoors for television reportages. And it works well.

The cap does nothing else. You just need to aim at this part of the room that you want to shoot, esp. in mixed lighting siutaions.


Reply

LucisPictor wrote:
cooltouch wrote:
I don't understand how one of these WB caps would work? If the cap is transmitting ambient light, how will it be a good indicator of true white?


The cam can adjust the WB by aiming at a pure white sheet of paper and then calculating the actual difference to what it sees in the given surroundings. This is what all the pro cameramen do when they shoot indoors for television reportages. And it works well.

The cap does nothing else. You just need to aim at this part of the room that you want to shoot, esp. in mixed lighting siutaions.


That s what i usually do but i hate having all that curious people asking what are you doing and why do you do it etc .
Plus i must admit that i m a bit concerned with all i hear . I m affraid that one day when i m shooting on the street someone will call the police and claim that i m a terrorist a pedophil or god knows what . ..
The caps i think that wouldnt drive to much unwanted attention on me .
I believe you all know what i mean people have turned paranoid with all that media . . .

Thanks for your time ,

Panos .


Reply

panos wrote:

I believe you all know what i mean people have turned paranoid with all that media . . .


Very true.


Reply

Correct me if I'm wrong.

The autoWB with DSLRs is accurate, although it is more towards to the colder(blueish) tone in light, that's what I've noticed with Canon DSLRs.

AutoWB is it's best in bright daylight, perhaps in the noon, with blue sky etc.
Best thing to do is to experiment, take a picture with every WB setting from auto to flash. And compare the results. You'll notice that every time you change the WB the color tone of the photo changes.

Color temperature is Kelvin. With Canon the autoWB tries to calculate the average K within the limits of 2800-7000K, AFAIRC (as far as i remember correctly).
For the "custom" WB(daylight, shade, cloudy etc.) the color temperature is constant.
Daylight/Flash = 5200K (depending on the nominal color temprature of the flash it's either 5200K or 5500K) Usually daylight works fine, but the Flash is there for a reason. Smile
Shade = 7000K
Cloudy = 6500K
Lightbulb = 3200K
Tungsten = 4000K (With Canon this used whether the nominal color of the Tungsten is green, white or daylight) Of course, there's always the option to take a test shot and adjusting it towards the correct one.
And there's the K-mode and the real CustomWB. K-mode allows you to set the color temperature from 2000-9000(?)K and the CustomWB is set by taking a test shot with AutoWB from a 18% graycard or from a white paper. But that's only if you plan to shoot a single point, every time you change the location you need to do it again.

There's also the option to fine tune the WB in the menus, CMYK colors if I'm not totally wrong. The color circle[1][2] is the key in this one. The one with all the primary, secondary and complementary colors.

The thumbrule with color temperature is the lower the Kelvin the warmer the light. You can see it for yourself, ie. when the sun is setting down the color is more orange than in the noon. In the noon the light is more white.

The way I learned to compensate the WB was taking photos indoors and testing the WB setting one by one. With your 40D you could use the LiveView and change the WB while using it. That way you'll see instantly what the WB settings do to the color tone of your pictures.

Practice, practice and practice. Although, I'm a beginner too but lately I've found myself thinking in various situations the color temperature without really thinking of it.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_wheel
[2] http://www.worqx.com/color/color_wheel.htm

Am I making any sense here?


Reply

I always shoot raw so that I can "losslessly" change the white balance in post processing. The raw files have the raw data from the sensor before any white balance has been set, and the camera merely records a “suggestion” for the raw converter to set a white balance. This means that setting WB in post-processing with raw has "perfect" quality, i.e. same as though you had hit that perfect value in-camera. Meanwhile if you let the camera set it and it goes wrong, you will almost certainly have irrevocably lost some nuances that cannot be restored from the data and significant changes of WB may even be impossible due to clipped values…

So, one should either get it right in-camera or shoot raw. I find shooting raw saves time when it counts (i.e. when taking pictures)—one can then set WB leisurely on the computer as accurately or inaccurately as is required. Mostly I just set it for one image and copy the settings to all photos in “similar“ light. If there's something grey in the photo, I click the WB eyedropper tool on it to get a starting point and then eyeball the rest, also using the auto-set values as a point of reference.

Generally AWB is pretty good, but some vintage lenses have a noticeable colour cast and sometimes AWB is just plain confused, e.g. when shooting something of fairly uniform colour, like autumn leaves filling the entire frame.


I do actually have one of those WB lens caps (got a cheap deal on it when I ordered a bunch of other stuff from the seller, so I though what the heck). I don't often use it, but it is a lot more accurate in many situations than white paper, particularly with mixed light. I think that's because it is aimed specifically at the target area and it “blends in” all the light coming from that direction, while a paper is more prone to just reflecting the light near the photographer. The most useful function of the particular cap I have is that it doubles as a sturdy and very portable grey card, i.e. one that can be held by the subject in one photo and then clicked with the eyedropper tool to set white balance from. Mine even has some slightly off-grey patches to warm or cool skin tones. But as for a WB cap, it's mostly useful for events where you'll be taking lots of photos in the same conditions. (And you could probably take the cap of an old-style Pringles jar or tennis ball tube for the same purpose.)


Last edited by Arkku on Thu Oct 22, 2009 9:03 am; edited 1 time in total


Reply

Actually Jekku my experience with the Canon has been the same as the original quote in this thread. I would say my Canon 40D gets it wrong at least 30% of the time, and badly wrong. That is why I now set it by hand. Surprising how much better the colors are now!


patrickh


Reply

Jekku wrote:


The autoWB with DSLRs is accurate, although it is more towards to the colder(blueish) tone in light, that's what I've noticed with Canon DSLRs.


Depends on the sensor: problem is not always the capability of the WB sensor, it can also be the digital sensor inability to reproduce a particular color. Your eye (brain) can distinguish about 15 f-stops of difference, pro camera bodies can do about 12, other DSLRs less.

I think incandescent light is the greatest challenge for auto white balance systems on DSLRs. At 3000K and below almost any camera will tend to produce slightly too warm images.

I find auto white balance exaggerates the difference in color temperature for mixed sources. This applies to those who rely on WB sensor readings. Other DSLRs, like the D3, rely not only on sensor reading but also compare it with a memory bank of tens of thousands of common mixed light combos and then decide which to use.

From my limited experience of half a dozen DSLR bodies (Canon, Pentax, Nikon, Leica) color error of the auto WB system varies from one model to another. When my D70 misses the WB it tends to lean towards too cold images daylight, but incandescent is way too warm. The K20D gave a little too warm images in daylight. The Leica M8 has difficulty with blacks, but that's more due to sensor lacking an IR filter. D3 is by far the best auto WB of any I have tried, but in the 10% of situations where it fails I find it gives slightly too warm images. A colleague who shoots 5DMkII says my experience with the D3 is identical to his: in most cases it's spot on but when it fails it's a little too warm.

I carry a white piece of paper with me for walk-arounds, and if it's a prepared shoot I use this handy tool: http://www.lastolite.com/xpobalance.php


Last edited by Esox lucius on Thu Oct 22, 2009 1:24 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

I was going to write "somewhat accurate", but some how I did not.
But yes, RAW is more flexible when talking about changing the whitebalance in PP.