MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

If i had it my way
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

If i had my own dslr factorythen i will build a cam with
1 no mirror
with today's technology i see no use for the mirror, if you can build a 12mp sensor , surely a 5mp ev must be possible!
this will give real time info in the viewfinder (a histogram after the shot is like mustard after the meal)
I dont want to see a perfect image through the viewfinder, i want to see al the information that will aid me in taking the perfect shot in the viewfinder

2 sealed sensor system

Why not seal the system to just behind the lens mount, easy to clean, i think the SD 14 is like that ?

no more digging deep inside te camera to take out one little spot

3 removable pop up flash with lead ,

That woud be so nice for macro. just clip out the popup atach difuser and clip to the front of lens for ettl macro
or atache a twin head to the wire or just a ringflash head

and last but not the least a 10mp per colour foveon at the business end

and it takes normal aa batteries

and you can move the sensor assembly forwards and backwards according to the register distance you prefer
and......and....and I can go on forever

Then i will call it the Canon 50P..for perfect Very Happy

But we have to live in the real world.....where the first motorized cars looked like horsedrawn carriages for years before technology replaced habit and they started designing from "scratch" again

i think the reflex mirror will eventually go the same way

Any other points of view ? please hit me with it ! Laughing

edit and a liquid crystal solid state shutter with no moving parts with flash sync at 8000/th Shocked


Reply

I've been wondering for some time how I would design a digital, interchangeable lens camera if I had free rein. Here are some thoughts:

Viewfinder: Rusty - I think I like your idea of replacing the slr viewfinder with an electronic viewfinder display (by definition it then wouldn't be an slr). However, I would only appreciate this change once it is possible to have such a viewfinder at very high resolution and a VERY low time delay. Perhaps with present technology it would be better to combine this with a traditional rangefinder (so two viewfinders - a rangefinder and through-the-viewfinder live-view.)

Controls: -dedicated dial for ISO
- dial on lens for aperture with an automatic setting (I think Pentax did their automatic-aperture lenses like this for a while).
- dedicated dial for shutter speed.

Stabilized sensor which tilts and shifts (would that have the same effect as a tilt-shift lens, provided the image circle was big enough?)

Multi-mount camera. Have a register distance so large that adapters could be made with full electrical (perhaps even mechanical?) connections, so that any modern lens could be mounted natively (Canon and Nikon wouldn't make this camera, I think!).


Reply

On a related note, I wonder what innovations camera manufacturers will make to keep their sales going into the future. In the not-too-distant future, we'll have to get to the point where it's not possible to increase pixel densities in dslrs any more without increasing noise. I'm not sure when this will happen, and innovations might increase what's possible, but there must be physical limits. So, once everyone (who wants one) has got a 20 or 40 MP dslr, what might manufacturers do to encourage people to upgrade?

They could:
-encourage everyone to buy a full-35mm frame slr to replace their crop-dslrs.
-HD movie's the latest thing in dslrs - presumably in a couple of years all new dslrs will have it. Ditto (=same goes for) GPS.
-Start selling non-slr interchangeable-lens digital cameras, either with electronic viewfinders, traditional rangefinders, or both.
-Start making digital panorama cameras
-another approach would be to market new must-have lenses. Nikon and Canon's slow implementation of stabilised lenses would be an example (they could speed it up if their camera body sales started to drop).

Another possibility is that a new camera manufacturer could come up with something completely different. With all the electronics made in China, presumably someone in China start making dslrs in their own right (not under license from another company).

Any other thoughts?


Reply

Well, for sure

- no mirror
- moveable sensor plane and
- very large body aperture

would make the camera compatible with practically 100% of manual focus reflex and rangefinder lenses... how could anyone of us not vote for a camera like this? Very Happy


Reply

I think the next revolution in sensor design will not be an increase in pixel density (as said above this is unnecessary) but an increase in exposure latitude. With current sensors (which still have a latitude smaller than that of modern films) the blown whites and crushed blacks are still a problem. You don't need a large imagination to realize that this is where sensors will be improved.


Reply

Carl , the idea of the tilt sensor would be great for improving dof for macro if it will have the same reaction as tilt/shift lens
and not to name the architectual possibilities every lens you own would be t/s Very Happy


Reply

Quote:
I know there are digital backs for medium format cameras, but I would like to see somebody make a series of digital backs for 35mm film cameras that are essentially digital cameras which use the host camera's shutter and aperture settings. Frankly, if I could mount a digital back to an old Canon F-1 or Nikon F-2 (or an EOS-1n or Nikon F5, far as that goes), I wouldn't care if I had to set the back separately exposure-wise whenever I changed settings on the camera (or vice versa).

I recall the hoohaa and fanfare relating to Digital Film, which turned out to be vapourware in the end. Pity really, as I'd have bought it to keep on using my Oly kit of the time. Now, it's too late - too many cheap used digibodies out there for anyone to make a buck selling digital backs.

Edit: Sorry cooltouch, I replied to your post but the forum software has dumped your original post and made it look as though you posted this. For the record, this post is my reply to your post. - Farside


Reply

Given current technology I'd keep the mirror (a big sensor overheats if used too long for live view), give the camera the viewfinder of a Leicaflex SL and ditch every automated function ever put on a camera except the aperture.

RAW only, a simple manual spot meter, manual focus, no AE whatsoever, a 24mm x 36mm Kodak CCD with a 16-bit ADC, a histogram display for review, and a Leica-R lens mount. Nirvana.


Reply

Let's not forget that, as well as providing the viewfinder image, the mirror in a DSLR is also needed for the auto-focus sensors. If you removed the mirror you'd need to change the AF sensing technology too.

I agree pixel density has reached its useful peak and improvements in dynamic sensitivity are more important. But I'd also like to see APS-size sensors (and viewfinders) become outdated by development of full-frame sensors at consumer prices.


Last edited by peterqd on Fri Apr 10, 2009 3:27 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

peterqd wrote:
... at consumer prices.

And this is the most important part! For me that means under €1000,-!


Reply

LucisPictor wrote:
peterqd wrote:
... at consumer prices.

And this is the most important part! For me that means under €1000,-!

I was thinking half that amount or even less! Smile


Reply

peterqd wrote:
Let's not forget that, as well as providing the viewfinder image, the mirror in a DSLR is also needed for the auto-focus sensors. If you removed the mirror you'd need to change the AF sensing technology too.

I agree pixel density has reached its useful peak and improvements in dynamic sensitivity are more important. But I'd also like to see APS-size sensors (and viewfinders) become outdated by development of full-frame sensors at consumer prices.


There is one little drawback there with fullframe, the diminished DOF for macro work
I have seen work done with the little panasonic lumix sensor at 100iso that is hard to beat with aps c and almost impossible with full frame in my mind
Maybe the answer will be the same pixeldensity on the fullframe as the aps and then just use portion of the sensor when doing macro?
Does this make sense? Shocked


Reply

I'll add a couple of my ideas (I agree with most of the above):

(1) Since the image circle is a circle, I want a circular sensor. I don't want to waste a single photon's worth of data that passes through my expensive glass. Captured image can be cropped to whatever format we like (I'll likely choose squre most of the time)

(2) Higher density of pixels in the center of the sensor for telephoto/macro work. Sure higher density of pixels all-around would be better, but that would make it prohibitively expensive, not just ridiculously expensive (but... *doable*)


Reply

Still this "sensor disk" would have to be smaller than the cast image, because the outer rim edges are really bad.

My perfect DSLR? The "LucisPictor CS12"

- 12 MPix Sensor, 1.2x crop*, dust sealed
- fast twin algorithmic chip and huge internal cache memory
- takes CF- and SD-cards
- perfect (adjustable) noise reduction for high ISO shots, noise red. can be deactivated
- Traditional mirror, but also a constant-flip-up-mirror feature with LiveView on a high resolution 3" display that makes it possible to use lenses "inside" the body
and some of the nice features that you have mentioned!

*Why 1.2x crop? Well, it still uses the better part of an image and does not cut away too much. It will turn a lens into the typical next focal length. Have you ever started at 14mm and muliplied it with 1.2?

14mm - 17mm (16.8 ) - 20/21mm (20.4) - 24mm (24.0) - 28mm (28.8 ) - 35mm (33.6) - [43mm film hypotenuse (42)] - 50mm (51.6) ... 85mm (86.4) - 105mm (102) ...

So a 17mm lens will work as a 20/21mm one.
A 20mm lens as a 24mm one.
A 24mm lens as a 28mm one. And so on...


Reply

cooltouch wrote:
Quote:
I know there are digital backs for medium format cameras, but I would like to see somebody make a series of digital backs for 35mm film cameras that are essentially digital cameras which use the host camera's shutter and aperture settings. Frankly, if I could mount a digital back to an old Canon F-1 or Nikon F-2 (or an EOS-1n or Nikon F5, far as that goes), I wouldn't care if I had to set the back separately exposure-wise whenever I changed settings on the camera (or vice versa).

I recall the hoohaa and fanfare relating to Digital Film, which turned out to be vapourware in the end. Pity really, as I'd have bought it to keep on using my Oly kit of the time. Now, it's too late - too many cheap used digibodies out there for anyone to make a buck selling digital backs.

Edit: Sorry cooltouch, I replied to your post but the forum software has dumped your original post and made it look as though you posted this. For the record, this post is my reply to your post. - Farside


Weird! Unfortunately, that was only a portion of my "brilliant" post, now forever lost in the vapor, as it were.

And I know what you mean about vaporware regarding Digital Film. I actually invested in a company back before the stock market bubble burst that was touting such a product that never materialized. Lost a fair chunk on that investment too.

I, however, don't see the bargain prices of digibodies being a drawback to this concept. There are lots of pro-quality mechanical SLRs out there that have been going strong since the 70s, and will likely outlast the latest and greatest DSLRs. Prices for these old cameras have been firming up, and I suspect that some brave enterprising soul who chooses to exploit this untapped resource could do well. You wouldn't have to discard or retire the camera (or lenses), once the tech became dated -- just the back.

Best,

Michael


Reply

peterqd wrote:
Let's not forget that, as well as providing the viewfinder image, the mirror in a DSLR is also needed for the auto-focus sensors.


In a perfect world I'd do away with AF entirely. Send all the light to the viewfinder, none of this semi-silvered mirror stuff.

LucisPictor wrote:
Still this "sensor disk" would have to be smaller than the cast image, because the outer rim edges are really bad...


Or use better lenses. There are lenses that are good to the edges of the circle that the 24mm x 36mm rectangle fits in. They're just more expensive.


Reply

Why not a camera which allow us to add whichever "modules" we want. Customisable. Let say if a person wants 10M, will get 10M, 30M will get 30M. If want liveview then add liveview module. Laughing


Reply

I need a smile detector, a best frame selector, a laser sensor who shot when the flying bee is at correct distance, a ir sensor to detect hot chick, a freezing ray to immobilize movement of flowers when windy, a more powerful usb to warm my coffee (for the usb coffee warmer and colder), it would be nice if the dslr could fly so I could reach better viewpoint, the dslr should fit in a small watch and be controlled by mind, or as a implant on my optical nerve so no need of Zeiss optics, and...


Reply

poilu wrote:
I need a ir sensor to detect hot chick

LaughingLaughing

Quote:
it would be nice if the dslr could fly so I could reach better viewpoint

Have you heard about kite photography poilu? I haven't tried it yet but I'm going to one day soon. Seems like a lot of fun Smile
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kite_aerial_photography


Reply

Peter wrote:
Have you heard about kite photography?

No, and it's impressive it is used from 1888

Today, helicopter with radio command are the new tech fashion
many video samples can be found on the net

here is one from Cinema5D, a forum dedicated to movie on the 5DII


check the resulting video clip
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EpQbnmO4b3U
Helicam 5D shots are at:
2:05
2:44
3:06
reference from Cinema5D


Reply

The helicam looks great but you need a fairly big helicopter to carry something that heavy. I have a much smaller one and you can even notice you're flying light when you remove the plastic cover (which weighs almost nothing).


Reply

All I want is a cousin of the Canon F1 that uses digital imaging - a large damped mirror, a glass pentaprism with a condenser base in an interchangeable mount so it can be swopped for other finders, and - last but by no means least - removeable focusing screens. Built-in stabilisation is progress, so I'll have that as a bonus extra, please. I'm not bothered if comes from Canon, Nikon, Pentax, Sony, or the Acme Camera Resurrection Corp, as long as it's reliable and can be used easily as a photographic tool

Somewhere back up the road, photgraphers must all have been thrown out of the design departments at the camera makers. Can ANYONE truthfully say any DSLR handles as well as film models did? The only digital system-cameras that are really enjoyable to handle are the Leica M8 and the Epson/Voigtlander coupled rangefinder designs, but they aren't what most of us actually want.

Time for us to stop being "grateful" for increasingly complex specifications and start criticising the manufacturers for what they've taken from us.


Reply

scsambrook wrote:
... The only digital system-cameras that are really enjoyable to handle are the Leica M8 and the Epson/Voigtlander coupled rangefinder designs, but they aren't what most of us actually want.

There is a difference between "want" and "can afford". Laughing


Reply

LucisPictor wrote:
scsambrook wrote:
... The only digital system-cameras that are really enjoyable to handle are the Leica M8 and the Epson/Voigtlander coupled rangefinder designs, but they aren't what most of us actually want.

There is a difference between "want" and "can afford". Laughing


That is indeed true - !