MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Film vs Digital video
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I'm not sure if someone posted this b4 Razz

http://fwd.five.tv/videos/challenge-blow-up-part-3

Quote:
The last part of the Blow Up challenge is a test between digital and film photography. Digital cameras have improved in leaps and bounds over the last few years but does film still produce the best results?


Reply

Srono wrote:
I'm not sure if someone posted this b4 Razz

http://fwd.five.tv/videos/challenge-blow-up-part-3

Quote:
The last part of the Blow Up challenge is a test between digital and film photography. Digital cameras have improved in leaps and bounds over the last few years but does film still produce the best results?


Interesting.
I knew the outcome before watching the video. Very Happy


Reply

They didn't compare like-with-like. As far as I recall they took the easy way and used 400 ISO on both cameras. To make it fairer they should have been using the best available film of the heyday of the film camera, put up against the finest setting of the digiSLR. I'm fairly sure if they'd been using (for example) ultra-fine ASA 25, Kodak TechPan (which is still available) for black and white; or for colour, Kodak claim Ektar 100 is the finest grained colour neg film today, they'd have had a different result.

It struck me as a typically biased piece of techo-geek reportage, in that the new is always better.


Reply

Farside wrote:
They didn't compare like-with-like. As far as I recall they took the easy way and used 400 ISO on both cameras. To make it fairer they should have been using the best available film of the heyday of the film camera, put up against the finest setting of the digiSLR. I'm fairly sure if they'd been using (for example) ultra-fine ASA 25, Kodak TechPan (which is still available) for black and white; or for colour, Kodak claim Ektar 100 is the finest grained colour neg film today, they'd have had a different result.

It struck me as a typically biased piece of techo-geek reportage, in that the new is always better.


The most interesting thing a about this video is that digital has come a long way and it will get much better with time.

I knew the outcome before watching the video for the same reasons you posted. This is a 'digital hype piece'.


Reply

spiralcity wrote:


The most interesting thing a about this video is that digital has come a long way and it will get much better with time.

I knew the outcome before watching the video for the same reasons you posted. This is a 'digital hype piece'.

The comparison was interesting enough and without a doubt digital has equalled /overtaken some film, but I got the impression they just couldn't wait to burst forth with the 'news' of that.
Digital is magic; I love it - but I prefer objectivity in reporting.


Reply

I'm still waiting to hear how they enlarged the film image. I assume they scanned it, so that adds an extra process. Not a fair test in my view.