MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Good red filter?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

All red filters I can find on the bay are very very cheap - but are they any good?

I wan't to use them for analog B/W potraits on my new Nokton 50/1.1 - may they cause any visible focus shift or is it only a issue above ~700nm


Reply

If you use a 'top-notch' lens like the Nocton 50/1.1 then it doesn't make sense (to my mind) to use a cheap red filter. A lens of this calibre deserves a quality filter like B&W, Hoya, Lee etc.


Reply

Red filters have a strong effect on skin that is not always pleasurable (at least for me).
Try yellow-orange instead.
Yellow-orange also compromises less the overall image quality.


Reply

I wouldn't use a red filter for portraits; yellow or green/yellow maybe on certain occasions.


Reply

I'll second the notes to get a B+W or Hoya. I switched my standard lens from a Tiffen 52mm UV filter to a B+W UV filter a neighbor gave me, and the amount of glare and edge distortion noticeably diminished. I have a BUNCH of Chinese filters. I bought a kit for $15 with all the main colors. They do the trick, but with noticeable degradation. The blue filter's dye job isn't even uniform. Literally -- no exaggeration -- there is a noticeable dark spot and a noticeable lighter spot. A lot of these Chinese-made off-brands are using low-grade glass, plexiglass, or other transparent materials. If you're shooting on a Holga, a $2 filter is fine. For a Nokton, get a good one. The light and image quality degradation of a low-end filter will make it a waste of money, make your images worse, and leave you unhappy.


Reply

Ok I will now clearly stay away from the el-cheapo chinese filters! Smile
And Orio convinced me to buy an orange or maybe yellow-orange filter first.

Are there any filters which are good without beeing as expensive as Hoya and B+W?
How about Cokin color filters for example?


Last edited by ForenSeil on Wed Jun 06, 2012 11:50 am; edited 1 time in total


Reply

If you use a lens hood, most filters will do, unless you point to strong lights.
(careful to vignetting though)


Reply

ForenSeil wrote:
Ok I will now clearly stay away from the el-cheapo chinese filters! Smile
And Orio convinced me to buy an orange or maybe yellow-orange filter first.

Are there any filters which are good without beeing as expensive as Hoya and B+W?
How about Cokin color filters for example?


Old East German made filters go for pennies and good ones.

http://forum.mflenses.com/werra-set-arrived-t50229,start,15.html

first sample made with east german yellow filter


Reply

Thanks! I will try to buy a used DDR- or modern branded filter Smile