MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

duck with various raw developer
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

same pic with various converter in auto mode
contax 50 1.7

capture one 5

bibble 5 preview 3

jpg extract from canon cr2

camera raw 5.3

raw therapee 2.4.1

silkypix 3


Last edited by poilu on Wed Nov 18, 2009 4:13 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

I´m surprised how good Raw Therepee performs


Reply

And which one gets the closest to reality?

The "auto" mode often is not the best choice, BTW.


Reply

LucisPictor wrote:
And which one gets the closest to reality?


Poilu,
I was wondering exactly the same : which is closer to what you saw ?

Then, what camera ?


Reply

Olivier wrote:
I was wondering exactly the same : which is
closer to what you saw ?


I don't remember and I would say none of them
I like the warm balance of camera raw but taste is different for everyone

I took this one at the same time on negative fuji 200 with contax 50 1.7 then I switch to my 40D but the ducks go away, it is the reason why you see their back, I wanted to catch them and kitchen them Very Happy



Reply

Well, it seems to me that camera raw is the closest to your film picture.


Reply

but look at the detail in capture one. Colour is easily rectified, but you can't put detail back in.


patrickh


Reply

patrickh wrote:
but look at the detail in capture one. Colour is easily rectified, but you can't put detail back in.
patrickh


I'd like to see a comparison with Bibble, as Bibble says that they're outperforming capture one for resolution.


Reply

Raw Therapee has the best detail in the ducks. The rest have blown
highlights. I swear by Bibble and has the best color I've seen.


Reply

Bill wrote:
The rest have blown highlights

I tend to expose to the right and shot was probably over exposed
interesting that Raw Therapee is the only one who automatically bring back blown details
I have add the bibble version
I will make a comparison of resolution with another pic between bibble & capture


Reply

Orio wrote:
patrickh wrote:
but look at the detail in capture one. Colour is easily rectified, but you can't put detail back in.
patrickh


I'd like to see a comparison with Bibble, as Bibble says that they're outperforming capture one for resolution.


I have some doubt about their statement.

Anyway thanks Poilu who brings up this subject.
I will do some comparison(s) C1 vs Bibble for resolutions.


Reply

I have been using the latest version of Bibble (5) and I believe that they may well be right about the detail. Their new colour engine also produces the most natural and realistic (lifelike) colours I have seen


patrickh

I would love to see comparison with other converters.


Reply

Looks like I'll have to check out bibble - though I agree raw therapee in standard default mode fixed the duck backs best.

Were there big differences in jpeg file sizes that resulted?


Anyway, duck is best developed in a hoisin sauce Smile


Reply

I like much more the first, but use only the CS4. What think of it?