MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Cuillins from Elgol.
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

EOS 5D MkII + EF17-40L @ 17mm & Lee Coral 2 grad, Lee ProGlass 0.9 ND and Heliopan SH-PMC CPL.



Reply

Great photo and landscape.


Reply

A beautiful landscape picture, but maybe too many filters. Why 09 ND? Water is the time for calm so that it does not really "move". Clear weather might ND 100 would work better if you want to blur the water.


Reply

Thanks guys.

@ Muddus: The water is blurred - I'm not a fan of cliched (IMO) 'milky' water and further blurring didn't add to the image as the water itself doesn't stand out that much, so I left it with some texture and movement.

Thanks for the comment though. Smile


Reply

I use very rarely three filters on wide angles, often becomes difficult to vignetting and the corners are soft. I wonder how I can use up to two of the filter. Especially FF does not last many filters. Of course, Lee filters are high quality but the 17mm is pretty hard to get sharp images


Reply

Hi Bob! Up to your same old tricks then? Smile
Beautiful as usual.


Reply

muddus wrote:
I use very rarely three filters on wide angles, often becomes difficult to vignetting and the corners are soft. I wonder how I can use up to two of the filter. Especially FF does not last many filters. Of course, Lee filters are high quality but the 17mm is pretty hard to get sharp images


The setup I use is a Lee filter holder with two slots and the 105mm filter ring - the CPL is a slim MC Heliopan and I use the WA adapter ring for the filter holder so it sits further back on the lens. This setup gives minimal vignetting and I sit a boonie hat on top of the rig as a lens hood. My 17-40 is a good copy - it does have slightly soft extreme corners but is otherwise sharp enough where it counts. I generally top and tail my extreme WA landscape shots to letterbox anyway so any corner issues should they exist are removed.

Cheers Peter - some new tricks in the shape of a 5D2 and moving from Cokin P to Lee filters. Laughing


Reply

Congrats on upgrading to the Lee system Smile

It's a very nice shot: you have the contrasting blue of the sky and the yellows of the rocks, and the polariser really helps with those clouds. However, I have a few suggestions. As it is I think the composition is a little confused; there isn't a strong foreground interest, and the headland of rock cuts off the view of the water between the shore and the distant hills, which robs the shot of some depth IMO. I don't know if this would have been possible, but perhaps you could have moved further left and swung the view right to use the shoreline as a stronger leading line and capture more of the water, along with more of the cliff face?

Also, I would remove those two little blips in the water at the left edge as they're distracting IMO, and you have a dust spot in the sky which needs cleaning up.

The Isle of Skye is definitely on my list of places to visit one day...


Reply

atomstitcher wrote:
Congrats on upgrading to the Lee system Smile

It's a very nice shot: you have the contrasting blue of the sky and the yellows of the rocks, and the polariser really helps with those clouds. However, I have a few suggestions. As it is I think the composition is a little confused; there isn't a strong foreground interest, and the headland of rock cuts off the view of the water between the shore and the distant hills, which robs the shot of some depth IMO. I don't know if this would have been possible, but perhaps you could have moved further left and swung the view right to use the shoreline as a stronger leading line and capture more of the water, along with more of the cliff face?

Also, I would remove those two little blips in the water at the left edge as they're distracting IMO, and you have a dust spot in the sky which needs cleaning up.

The Isle of Skye is definitely on my list of places to visit one day...


You make some interesting points however the area topography precludes most of them...

This beach doesn't really lend itself to foreground interest too much as although it is rocky, there is nothing that particularly stands out IMO so I go more for texture and colour.

The topography is such that the beach ascends towards the headland as can be seen, but there is a further outcrop just beyond that's just out of sight and I'd need to be at least 30' off the ground to see the sea beyond the slope - not feasible.

The tides come in fast in the area and I was already at the water's edge with it lapping my feet so moving further left meant I would have been up to my neck in the sea. Laughing

When I post images on a board, I always leave a small error or two for newer peeps to hunt down... Wink Laughing

All that aside, I can certainly recommend Skye to you as you've not visited it before.

Thanks for the comments. Smile


Last edited by bob955i on Sun Dec 11, 2011 6:14 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

Shocked ŰWOW! Such a great picture!


Reply

Attila wrote:
Shocked ŰWOW! Such a great picture!

+1


Reply

Bob, I like it well enough, you're usual excellent 'scape, but a suggestion:
approach this area quietly next time, you scared all the naked sirens off
the rocks. Wink


Reply

Nice shot. I've just ordered a set of ND grads. Looking forward to using them now.


Reply

Beautiful as usual Bob.

How did the EOS 3 work out for you?