MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
logovectorizer.com
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Several 50/55 mm primes compared in the field.
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Today I decided to test several of my 50/55 mm primes in the field.
The lenses are:
1. Auto Revuenon 55mm f/1.4 which arrived today, I'm very happy Smile
2. SMC Takumar 55mm f/1.8
3. Super-Takumar 55mm f/2.0
4. Vivitar 55mm F/2.8 Macro
5. Rikenon XR 50mm f/2.0 (this is the only 50mm in the test).

For all the images I used a heavy tripod, and put the timer at 2 sec. Pictures are unaltered jpegs, made with an Olympus E-P1. Enjoy the test!


First a comparison at long distance.
Crops come from this picture:


Here are the crops:






Conclusions:
Wide open:
The Revuenon is very soft wide open. The comparison is unfair however, because the Revuenon is much faster than the Tak's and the Rikenon. When we compare the two Takumars and the Rikenon we see that the Rikenon is slightly sharper. When you look at the top of the tree (see magnification), you'll see that the Rikenon shows less chromatic aberration than the 2 Takumars.

@2.8:
The sharpest pictures come from the Revuenon 55/1.4 and the Rikenon XR 50/2.0. Also, less chromatic aberration than both Takumars and the Vivitar 55/2.8 macro. The Rikenon seems to be more contrasty than the Revuenon. In general, it seems the Revuenon is very sharp, but not that contrasty (looks like the brightness is slightly increased).

@5.6
I would say that the Revuenon's picture is the sharpest, followed by the Rikenon. The Super Takumar 55/2 is very close. The softest image comes from the SMC Takumar 55/1.8.


Then a comparison at closer distance (about 2 meters @ f/2.Cool:


Conslusions:
I find it hard to decide which lens has the nicest bokeh. In fact, IMO they are all pretty nice. In the 100% crop, the Revuenon and Rikenon show to be the best performers. This surprised me quite a bit (I expected the Vivitar to excel at this distance). IMO the SMC Takumar 55/1.8 renders the best colors, probably because of it's superior coating.

I decided to the test also @ f/5.6:



Conclusions: @5.6 the Vivitar is better than the Rikenon. Still, the Revuenon is the winner here. Keep in mind that the Vivitar is a macro-lens. 2 meters is still not that close. At shorter distance, the Vivitar will probably show to be superior to normal primes (this shows in tests I did earlier).

(note: the picture made with the SMC Tak 55/1.8 might have suffered from some vibration, for it's less sharp than the one made @2.Cool.


This is a test picture I made with the Vivitar at closer distance @ f/8:


Feel free to add your own comments.


Reply

Thanks.

Very ilustrative comparison.

Consistents results along the test.

Diferences among the SMC and ST takumars is the expected. Better contrast in the SMC and colder colors in the ST.

In the 1,4/55, somethin soft at 1,4 and the best aperture is 5,6 alike in others 1,4/55 lenses.

The rikenon seems to have a similar rendering than the takumars.

The vivitar has less elements in the formula, so is expected a bit more contrast than the other lenses.

I think that the word is consistent.

Thanks again. Rino.


Reply

The colours of the Tak 55 / 1.8 wide open are altered by the magenta chromatic aberration diffused over the object. To a lesser extent, the same happens with the Tak 55 / 2
In both taks, and in the Vivitar too, you can also see the green CA in the back edge of trunk
The Rikenon and Revuenon appear to be better lenses with regards to chromatic aberration, and not by a small margin. I would call them much better.
Dfifficult to judge the sharpness because even a small focusing inconsistency may influence the judgement.


Reply

@Orio
I agree, claims in terms of sharpness are always hard to make. On the other hand, I found similar results in an indoor test I did last week (although the Revuenon was not included). These results can also be found on the forum. Still, there is always a chance of inaccurate focus.
I also agree with your comments about CA: the Revuenon and Rikenon seem much better. On a m4/3 camera (lots of pixels on a small sensor) these differences are probably a bit more prominent than on most cameras with an APS-size sensor.