MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
logovectorizer.com
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Pancolars : Zebra vs redMC
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Hello guys !

I've made the test betwen the two pancolars I own, the first is the red MC one and the second a zebra.

Tadam...




Concerning Image white balance, no adjustment has been done. As I said previously, the two suffer from about the same amount of yellowing (very few) as you can see above. (I already had into my hands a very strongly yellowed one)

Images where taken with a pentax K200d
Focusing where performed with a focusing screen.
Focus point is the viewfinder of the right camera.



Zebra 1.8



Zebra 2.8



Zebra 4



Zebra 5.6




red MC 1.8


red MC 2.8


red MC 4


red MC 5.6


PS all images are clickable for enlarging.


Reply

For me, MC version has better IQ but zebra version kinda suprise me. They are close.


Reply

djmike wrote:
For me, MC version has better IQ but zebra version kinda suprise me. They are close.


I used both in Zoo I never discover any significant difference between them.
Perhaps I am blind Laughing Laughing


Reply

The Zebra colours look warmer and richer to me.


Reply

Attila wrote:

I used both in Zoo I never discover any significant difference between them.
Perhaps I am blind Laughing Laughing


no-X were suggesting a very different bokeh due to different formula but I must confess I can't really separate them, according to Attila.


Reply

hi

are you sure you make same focus whith zebra lens than whith black MC ?
in zebra ,the back oof area is is softer than the black one ,even at f4

i m new in this forum ,my name is julien ,i come from the same french forum (HFR) than carbonR ,pich900 and fourmixK
and i m sorry for my poor english vocabulary


Reply

AMDBill wrote:
hi

are you sure you make same focus whith zebra lens than whith black MC ?
in zebra ,the back oof area is is softer than the black one ,even at f4

i m new in this forum ,my name is julien ,i come from the same french forum (HFR) than carbonR ,pich900 and fourmixK
and i m sorry for my poor english vocabulary


Welcome Julien!

This is an international forum , members come from all over the world. Naturally not everybody speaking well in English so don't say sorry about that.


Reply

i do not know how it is possible, but it seems the redmc images have more clarity-in-depth. does that make any sense? perhaps it is something the lens coating does. in any case, if i were to pick one, it would be the red mc, based only on these images.

merci beaucoup, mon ami ...


Reply

Looking at the 5.6 enlargements,the zebra is much sharper than the MC photo. Focussing seems to be an issue?


Reply

With the present test the "MC" makes a better job.

I own both lenses and with my comparisons the "Zebra" was better.

Maybe there is a big variance of quality with each copy.
This makes sense, because the lenses are very old and so in different conditions.


Reply

beachboy2 wrote:
Looking at the 5.6 enlargements,the zebra is much sharper than the MC photo. Focussing seems to be an issue?


You have the opposite results when looking at f1.8 and 2.8 where the red mc is much more sharper.
So, focusing from shot to shot should be an issue.


Reply

Perhaps focus is totally the same for the two lens. But in a on each lens serie, a tripod was used so I doubt focus has moved.

The point I wanted to arise, was the bokeh.
The assesment I read was that the two lenses hadn't the same formula.
(the both appears in no-X table there)

The bokeh is a direct consequence of lens formula so the two relvant pictures to consider are the wide open ones, wher the effect is the greatest.

Let's do it :
Zebra


MC


The shapes are nearly identical in both images !


PS : Hello AMDBill, one more frog. We are growing Very Happy


Reply

froggy's invade there cause of youth people and some forumer are stupid on french forum Evil or Very Mad
not the same mentality ,more criticism even for nothing


Reply

AMDBill wrote:
froggy's invade there cause of youth people and some forumer are stupid on french forum Evil or Very Mad
not the same mentality ,more criticism even for nothing

He, salut froggy AMDBill Very Happy .....

Over this pancolar, I'm afraid I'm also blind because I don't see so much difference between the two lenses Rolling Eyes ...except that the MC version looks sharper wide open but no difference at all with bokeh...but I like more the look of the zebra version Wink ...


Last edited by pich900 on Mon Apr 12, 2010 7:43 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

From ones, the zebra is the best, from others (me among them) the reed MC win.

The formulas are the same?

I read that the zebra scheme is the same than the F/2 zebre, this is a 6-4 (1-2/2-1). And the Mc version (red and white MC too) I saw that they are 6-5 (1-2/1-1-1) .

If that is true, the zebra and the MC are differebnt lenses, and the rendering must be different too.

All OK, but I can't see any differences between them, only a subtle one.

Rino.


Reply

pich900 wrote:
AMDBill wrote:
froggy's invade there cause of youth people and some forumer are stupid on french forum Evil or Very Mad
not the same mentality ,more criticism even for nothing

He, salut froggy AMDBill Very Happy .....

Over this pancolar, I'm afraid I'm also blind because I don't see so much difference between the two lenses Rolling Eyes ...except that the MC version looks sharper wide open but no difference at all with bokeh...but I like more the look of the cobra version Wink ...


Bill, salut la Grenouille !

Pich, I like very much the Zebra cars and the Cobra lenses ! Very Happy


Reply

Olivier wrote:

Pich, I like very much the Zebra cars and the Cobra lenses ! Very Happy

Laughing Laughing


Reply

estudleon wrote:
From ones, the zebra is the best, from others (me among them) the reed MC win.

The formulas are the same?

I read that the zebra scheme is the same than the F/2 zebre, this is a 6-4 (1-2/2-1). And the Mc version (red and white MC too) I saw that they are 6-5 (1-2/1-1-1) .

If that is true, the zebra and the MC are differebnt lenses, and the rendering must be different too.

All OK, but I can't see any differences between them, only a subtle one.

Rino.


I linked to the no-x post in my previous post which agreed with what you said : two different formula.
But one same result.

Interesting, isn't it ?

The most striking, it is that I read (somewhere, I don't remember) that they where different and so I felt the image taken with them different.
Until I made that little comparative study..

We are poor subjective creatures Very Happy


Reply

It's one of the things that do the forum so atractive. Here there are a lot guys that like to share their knowledge. And then our own opinion is formed by them.

Someone more practical people, others more theoreticians, but you will find here what you need.

It occur to me too.

Rino.


Reply

My version is the white MC electric. I can't compare it directly with your two lenses, but I doubt there would be any difference at all. It would be nice to dispel all the nonsense about red MC! Laughing


Reply

@estudleon

I'm not found of tests of that kind.
I'd rather shoot outside.

But I'm a chemist and I can't fight my analytical side when I ask myself a question Very Happy

@peterqd : yes ! great !


Reply

Happy to see that I don't need the MC. Here's my zebra at 2.8: