MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Which Ilford Developer?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Hi folks

Going to develop some B+W film, my supplier has three Ilford developers - ID-11, Perceptol and Microphen, they are all the same price. I used to use Microphen 15 years ago, never heard of the other two.

What should I buy for processing B+W film?


Reply

I would go with ID-11 as reading the specs sheet it appears to be the general use developer from the list that provided. I have not used this brand of developer. Should work across a range of temperatures just be sure to adjust development times for the temperature of the solution.

Spec sheet found on the internet
http://www.darkroom.ru/info/manuals/ilford_powder_developers_manual_eng.pdf


Reply

Yes, when we developed Ilford films in the newsapaper lab, we always went for Ilford developers.

BTW: http://www.ilfordphoto.com/products/product.asp?n=6


Reply

I think that ID-11 tends to be regarded as the flexible all-rounder. I use it to develop Delta 100.

Microphen boosts speed slightly and Perceptol minimises grain.
The Ilford website linked above has more details.

All three can be purchased in powder form which is useful when buying them from the internet


Reply

Are you in N America?
Freestyle.com has all tge developers one could ever ask for.
Their priced generally low enough to be competitive even after shipping cost.
Also check out the 2pack HP5 deal for $4 they have right now (B&H also).
As to which developer, it depends on which film and other requirements or desired outcomes.


Reply

Thanks for the info guys, I think I'll go for the Microphen, I know that works good with T-Max 400, FP4 and HP5...

Just for experimental purposes, I just bought an ancient 1970s sealed box of Ilford Hyfin developer, being sealed it should be okay, chemicals don't break down unless exposed to the air I think...

BTW, has anyone tried using raw chemicals to develop film? I notice you can buy the raw chemicals in powdered form on ebay...


Reply

iangreenhalgh1: i would suggest to read ilford´s datasheets, they may help you to choose right developer.

if you are not sure about which one to pick, i would suggest to get ID-11. it is a good allrounder and you just can´t make mistake with it. delta films look wonderful in it, and fuji acros is at least fantastic in it!!!

microphen is great for pushing film at higher iso and achieving smooth grain, on the other side the grain isn´t sharp - that´s why i prefer rodinal (which isn´t making so fine grain, but photos look very sharp) or atomal (which makes grain even finer that microphen. you cannot see it even on big enlargements from 135film)

making your own developer from raw chemicals has it´s pros - you may make some special developer with special look and/or special features and you may save money. if something from these two isn´t your goal, i´d stay with commercial developers. it has to be said that playing with your own developing is great fun, but it takes time to make something which fits your needs well.

f16SUNSHINE: that is really great deal on that HP5+ !! thanks for pointing it out!


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 wrote:

What should I buy for processing B+W film?


It depends on the film and how you've shot it.

1D-11 is a general purpose developer which can be used for most applications. Once you mix it it starts to go off, that's why they sell it in powder form. I'm not sure how long it lasts mixed, it might say on the pack or on the Ilford site.

I know it wasn't on your list but I would suggest Ilford LC29 instead only because it's a liquid and lasts longer. It is also a general purpose developer. It was my favourite for medium format, with HP5-Plus.

http://www.ilfordphoto.com/products/product.asp?n=33&t=film+developers

JJ


Reply

jjphoto wrote:
I know it wasn't on your list but I would suggest Ilford LC29 instead only because it's a liquid and lasts longer. It is also a general purpose developer. It was my favourite for medium format, with HP5-Plus.

http://www.ilfordphoto.com/products/product.asp?n=33&t=film+developers

JJ

+1

I discovered LC29 about 4 rolls ago and I've been extremely pleased with it. Great tones and fine grain, it's easy to mix liquid (I found powder difficult to dissolve), and it's very economical with a long shelf life after opening and mixing. Just right for an "occasional" user like me.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1,

As usual the choice of developer depends on what films you use and the sort of results you want. Ilford had pretty much nailed it in their recommendations for their own films, of course, for "conventional" processing methods and results.

Normally, if you tend to use faster films, I would not go for Perceptol: it is a fine-grain developer but the film would not achieve box speed: a slow film would become even slower.

For a long time I used both ID-11 and Microphen: the former in all sorts of dilutions - including using the replenishment system. As a one-shot, 1:1 and 1:3 can indeed be pleasant to the modern eye: if used full-strength, which is also obligatory in a replenishment system, the result can be a little "mushy" but I am splitting hair. Microphen was a magic recipe when it came out, giving good speed gain. However, when mixed as stock solution Microphen keeps exceedingly well, where ID-11 or others would have gone off completely. Diluted Microphen as one-shot is also a somewhat unusual method and the results can even have a slight edge over diluted ID-11.

I would also agree with jjphoto's suggestion of giving LC-29 a try, being a liquid concentrate it is indeed most convenient and the results quite magnificent: I started using it when it was supplied as a kit with HP5 Plus and still called the "Plus" developer.

One thing I would not touch with a barge pole is Ilfosol: got burnt by it too many times, but when it works, it is actually slightly better than ID-11 IMHO.


Reply

Oh, I remember that 'Plus' developer, it was good.

I have developed a couple of rolls in Microphen and the negs look fine, just waiting for my scanner to arrive.

I also have some D-76 and Microdol, I'll use up the Microphen first.

I used it 1:1 with plain sodium thiosulphate pentahydrate as the fixer, all worked fine it seems to my eyes.

Thanks for all the advice guys, I look forward to showing you my scans.


Reply

I have some Ilfosol 3. It's ok, does its job, but after the bottle has gone that's it. I tend to use Rodinal for most films and DDX for fast films when I want less grain.


Reply

martinsmith99 wrote:
I have some Ilfosol 3. It's ok, does its job, but after the bottle has gone that's it. I tend to use Rodinal for most films and DDX for fast films when I want less grain.


Ilford claimed that, with the Ilfosol 3 they have fixed the "sudden death syndrome" found in earlier versions, but I still feel apprehensive.

Rodinal is of course a good option if you like the look it gives: it is never a fine grain developer, it makes individual grains sharp so as to accentuate sharpness. For fast films like HP5 or Tri-X this can be objectionable. Another funny thing is that Rodinal can take on different characteristics by using different dilutions, but loads have been written about that already.