MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

What kind is good?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Hello everybody! I am a new member.
I'm wondering what kind of lens should I choose? Hope to get help from everyone!
Which type is the sharpest? (Gear SONY A7II)
Hope everyone has photos taken with these lenses.

Minotla 50mm F1.4
Canon FD 50mm F1.4/Canon FDn 50mm F1.4
SMC Pentax 50mm F1.4/SMC Takumar 50mm F1.4
Konica 50mm F1.4/Konica 50mm F1.7

Thank you everyone for your help.


Last edited by Nguyen The Duong on Sat Aug 14, 2021 4:53 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

For flowers you better use a macro lens. This Nikkor is very cheap and very sharp as well: https://www.kenrockwell.com/nikon/55f35ai.htm


Reply

Hallo Nguyen welcome.

You can take flower pics with the range of lenses. Your good fast 50mm lenses can do very well, with lots of bokeh possibilities. A 90/100/105mm macro is an obvious lens to use as already mentioned, especially for small blooms etc. I also find myself using wide angle lenses like the sigma superwide II 24mm to encompass a wider field eg a carpet of pansies for example, and more depth of field. I took this pic with an old tamron t-mount 200mm f6.3!



Reply

caspert79 wrote:
For flowers you better use a macro lens. This Nikkor is very cheap and very sharp as well: https://www.kenrockwell.com/nikon/55f35ai.htm


Thank you! Since I already have a Nikon lens, I want to choose another brand of lenses.


Reply

marcusBMG wrote:
Hallo Nguyen welcome.

You can take flower pics with the range of lenses. Your good fast 50mm lenses can do very well, with lots of bokeh possibilities. A 90/100/105mm macro is an obvious lens to use as already mentioned, especially for small blooms etc. I also find myself using wide angle lenses like the sigma superwide II 24mm to encompass a wider field eg a carpet of pansies for example, and more depth of field. I took this pic with an old tamron t-mount 200mm f6.3!



Thanks, your photos are very nice. But I'm looking for 50mm focal length.


Reply

Nguyen The Duong wrote:


Minotla 50mm F1.4
Canon FD 50mm F1.4/Canon FDn 50mm F1.4
SMC Pentax 50mm F1.4/SMC Takumar 50mm F1.4
Konica 50mm F1.4/Konica 50mm F1.7


With 24,3 mp sensor, all that lenses will be sharp enough to any job.

Different thing is with more mp sensors.

Perhaps the Minolta MDIII and the Canon fdn are the sharpest of the bunch.


Reply

All good lenses. Just look up samples on Flickr taken with those lenses and see which you like best.


Reply

Welcome Nguyen The Duong

http://forum.mflenses.com/macro-takumar-50-4m42-preset-t77210.html


Reply

...

Last edited by Blazer0ne on Tue Feb 22, 2022 6:33 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

papasito wrote:
Nguyen The Duong wrote:




With 24,3 mp sensor, all that lenses will be sharp enough to any job.

Different thing is with more mp sensors.

Perhaps the Minolta MDIII and the Canon fdn are the sharpest of the bunch.


Thank you very much, I will consider these two lenses.


Reply

D1N0 wrote:
All good lenses. Just look up samples on Flickr taken with those lenses and see which you like best.


I also used Flickr, but still can't compare the sharpness of each lens, I find them balanced.


Reply

visualopsins wrote:
Welcome Nguyen The Duong

http://forum.mflenses.com/macro-takumar-50-4m42-preset-t77210.html


Thank you very much, I went through the link, really very high sharpness for 40 Euro, maybe I also look for this lens in terms of experience.


Reply

The konica 50mm 1.7 is incredibly inexpensive for its capabilities. 30. Dollars. But as stated the similarities in this group will be more profound than the differences.


Reply

jamaeolus wrote:
The konica 50mm 1.7 is incredibly inexpensive for its capabilities. 30. Dollars. But as stated the similarities in this group will be more profound than the differences.


I see it too. The colors are beautiful, bold, and very attractive.


Reply

Konica Hexanon AR 135mm f/3.2 is still a really sharp and affordable option. And offers pretty good close focusing capability.


Reply

Nguyen The Duong wrote:
Hello everybody! I am a new member.
I'm wondering what kind of lens should I choose? Hope to get help from everyone!
Which type is the sharpest? (Gear SONY A7II)
Hope everyone has photos taken with these lenses.

Minotla 50mm F1.4
Canon FD 50mm F1.4/Canon FDn 50mm F1.4
SMC Pentax 50mm F1.4/SMC Takumar 50mm F1.4
Konica 50mm F1.4/Konica 50mm F1.7

Thank you everyone for your help.


Of those listed, I'd pick either of the Konica 50's, or the SMC K 50/1.4(not the M or A versions, the K version doesn't have a K, it's the first generation K mount)

For lenses not listed:
RE Topcor 58/1.4 it's razor sharp wide open. Just make sure the grip is in good condition.
OM Zuiko 50/1.4 (MC)(Zuiko without the letter prefix is also multi coated),
Contax C/Y 50/1.4


Reply

The SMC Pentax-M 50mm 1:1.7 is very sharp and under rated.

Mr Wonky ear by The lens profile, on Flickr


Reply

I'd take the MD 50mm 1.4 because I like how well Minolta lenses feels adapted. The FDn is very similar when I looked at samples, good if you like Canon.

But my favorite is C/Y Planar 50mm 1.4.


Reply

caspert79 wrote:
Konica Hexanon AR 135mm f/3.2 is still a really sharp and affordable option. And offers pretty good close focusing capability.


Thank you very much, I also enjoyed this lens from Konica.


Reply

Of those listed, I'd pick either of the Konica 50's, or the SMC K 50/1.4(not the M or A versions, the K version doesn't have a K, it's the first generation K mount)ote]


For lenses not listed:
RE Topcor 58/1.4 it's razor sharp wide open. Just make sure the grip is in good condition.
OM Zuiko 50/1.4 (MC)(Zuiko without the letter prefix is also multi coated),
Contax C/Y 50/1.4[/quote]

Thank you very much. Really this 50mm focal length is a difficult choice. I will learn more about the lenses you recommend.


Reply

D1N0 wrote:
The SMC Pentax-M 50mm 1:1.7 is very sharp and under rated.

Mr Wonky ear by The lens profile, on Flickr




Is it this lens? I find it really beautiful and the photos in Flickr are really amazing.


Reply

blotafton wrote:
I'd take the MD 50mm 1.4 because I like how well Minolta lenses feels adapted. The FDn is very similar when I looked at samples, good if you like Canon.

But my favorite is C/Y Planar 50mm 1.4.


Thanks you very much.
I will take a look and find out the line of lenses you recommend.


Reply

Nguyen The Duong wrote:




Is it this lens? I find it really beautiful and the photos in Flickr are really amazing.


Yes that is the one.


Reply

D1N0 wrote:
Nguyen The Duong wrote:




Is it this lens? I find it really beautiful and the photos in Flickr are really amazing.


Yes that is the one.

I have multiple copies of the M50/1.7 (having been given all the ones family members had). It is indeed a fantastic lens, very slightly better than my M50/1.4 unless that extra fraction of speed is wanted.

The later A series is I believe optically the same design, but the aperture mechanism is less robust, so best left for those shooting Pentax where the A series has some advantages (mainly EXIF recognition).


Any of the original list of primes will work well so choosing between them (if you don't already have preferred mounts), comes down to ergonomics more than anything else. I find the FD mount awkward. For some the direction of focus travel is a factor...


Reply

The Super Takumar 55/1.8 (through to the SMC Pentax 55/1.8 is basically unchanged optically for 4 or more generations), and is one on my most favourite lenses from the brand, it's decently sharp, pair it with the early Super Takumar 28/3.5 and 85/1.9 and they will make a nice "character" set of lenses.