MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Dislike of AF
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Even though my dslr is AF, I strongly prefer to use MF lenses on it and not shoot AF. I just dont like the trigger delay
and possiblity of the camera missing on focusing. Anyone else feel this way too?


Reply

hifisapi wrote:
...I just dont like the trigger delay...

What do you mean by "trigger delay" ? The delay between pressing the shutter release button and the shutter release itself ? Surely this delay occurs for manual focusing as well ?

Quote:
...and possiblity of the camera missing on focusing.

Always a possibility - but that possibilty exists for manual focusing also ?


Reply

sichko wrote:
hifisapi wrote:
...I just dont like the trigger delay...

What do you mean by "trigger delay" ? The delay between pressing the shutter release button and the shutter release itself ? Surely this delay occurs for manual focusing as well ?

>>Im talking about the delay that occurs when the system has to autofocus after attempting to fire the shutter

Quote:
...and possiblity of the camera missing on focusing.

Always a possibility - but that possibilty exists for manual focusing also ?


Reply

hifisapi wrote:
>>Im talking about the delay that occurs when the system has to autofocus after attempting to fire the shutter


You mean that some camera-lens combinations are slow to acquire focus ? I've certainly had that problem - particularly when I try to focus on a distant object with focus set on a near object (or vice versa). AF isn't perfect but, overall, I find that the advantages outweigh the disadvantages. It's a personal thing and not a recommendation to anyone else.


Reply

sichko wrote:
You mean that some camera-lens combinations are slow to acquire focus ? I've certainly had that problem - particularly when I try to focus on a distant object with focus set on a near object (or vice versa). AF isn't perfect but, overall, I find that the advantages outweigh the disadvantages. It's a personal thing and not a recommendation to anyone else.

+1


Reply

AF seems like it would be good for action where its too hard to MF ( cant keep up with the action),
but I dont shoot a lot of action. For me its mostly static stuff and my manual focus percentage
is higher than AF percentage ( of in focus shots ). To me, its just as easy to view, focus on what I
want to be in focus, and shoot, than to have to aim the camera, half way push down the shutter
button for af to lock in and then recompose and shoot.


Reply

Another thing I dont like about AF lenses in general is that they came out later than mf lenses
and they typically dont have as nice a build quality as vintage mf lenses.


Reply

hifisapi wrote:
AF seems like it would be good for action where its too hard to MF ( cant keep up with the action),
but I dont shoot a lot of action.


I shoot a lot of "action" - not sports or air shows but plants ! In my part of the world there's usually a breeze of some sort if not a strong wind. Even indoors, in a glasshouse, there might be an open window or a large fan blowing. It's often difficult to find a plant which is perfectly still. So I rely on AF to find the focus and a high shutter speed to freeze the action.

Quote:
For me its mostly static stuff and my manual focus percentage
is higher than AF percentage ( of in focus shots ).


For static subjects I have no problems with AF. That doesn't mean that I get a 100% hit rate but it's certainly no worse than using MF. However I think that lots of people don't understand the potential difficulties. Is the camera front- or back-focusing ? Is the focus point placed over a suitable target - the area under a focus point can be much larger than you think. Shutter speed - is it high enough to mitigate against camera shake which might be confused with missed focus ?

AF is often seen as a lazy way to take photographs. I don't think that it is. I think that it's necessary to understand the limitations of a system and to work within and/or around them.


Reply

hifisapi wrote:
Even though my dslr is AF, I strongly prefer to use MF lenses on it and not shoot AF. I just dont like the trigger delay
and possiblity of the camera missing on focusing. Anyone else feel this way too?


I do not !
I like to MF, but i will never dislike AF...
..when kids are runing/jumping or when i shoot on a race track, i prefer 100000x my 7D+L lens for its speed !


Reply

sichko wrote:
I don't think that it is. I think that it's necessary to understand the limitations of a system and to work within and/or around them.

Very true.


Reply

Nelson wrote:
hifisapi wrote:
Even though my dslr is AF, I strongly prefer to use MF lenses on it and not shoot AF. I just dont like the trigger delay
and possiblity of the camera missing on focusing. Anyone else feel this way too?


I do not !
I like to MF, but i will never dislike AF...
..when kids are runing/jumping or when i shoot on a race track, i prefer 100000x my 7D+L lens for its speed !

Yeah, good AF is better for fast action as I said above. But I dont shoot much action so MF suits me fine.


Reply

I like them all .I shoot MF and AF without feeling any pain . Just assure me that I am using central focusing point lock focus +/- exposure and recompose . What I dislike is that camera chooses the focusing point .O,yes ! that's crazy driving situation and I am allways assure me not to happen(like in the first days of using AF cam ,long time ago).


Reply

SonicScot wrote:
sichko wrote:
I don't think that it is. I think that it's necessary to understand the limitations of a system and to work within and/or around them.

Very true.

Well there are workarounds to MF too. For example on action photography you can prefocus to a spot like the finish line in a horse race or the paint in a basketball game.


Reply

I used my Pentax K10 almost exclusively with manual lenses, and I have some nice AF glass for the Pentax. But it died and I'm now agonizing over it's replacement.
Last week my lovely niece got married and took my NEX with it's autofocus lens, which soon got replaced by a Helios 44-2, and a selection of old film camera, all old manual things. Then the groom handed me his Nikon D somethingoranother and I used that for most of the day, and loved it. The AF was fast and accurate, which was perfect for dancing girls, kids running around, old guys trying to dance with the girls, and all the stuff that goes on at weddings. Horses for courses, the AF won hands down. But for the type of picture I take most times, I love the MF stuff.
Strangely, the NEX just wasn't good enough in AF and I lost a lot of shots where the Nikon, which is an amateur model of some sort, coped with perfectly.


Reply

I have only one AF lens , did come with camera Samsung NX100, to me really not matter AF or MF if I like image IQ and I like lens itself.
Both have place in our tools.


Reply

hifisapi wrote:
AF seems like it would be good for action where its too hard to MF ( cant keep up with the action)


This is debatable, or at least it should be analyzed.
Not all actions are the same, and not all action situations are better suited for autofocus.

I would start saying that a big difference is made if the action is near, or far.
If the action is far (which is the case of most sport shows, usually, because the public can not get close too much)
autofocus makes very little difference, because the subjects that are at a long distance (20-30 meters or more)
even when they move, they don't change their position much compared to the focusing possiblity of a tele lens.
What I am trying to say is, that a football player, who is at 40 meters distance, even if he runs fast, he needs 2 seconds
to cover a 10 meters distance. In a manual lens, the focus distance between 40 meters and 30 meters is very small,
mostly a matter of a simple little twist. The photographer has all the needed time to adjust the focus even better than
most AF lenses would, because unless super fast, an AF lens will take more time to adjust in that situation, than a MF lens.
If the action is near, then the range of adjustment of focus on the manual lens becomes longer (i.e. you need to rotate more
the focus ring), and in the same 2 seconds, the proximity of the subject will force the manual photographer to a long range
rotation of the focus ring. The reaction time is the same (2 seconds) as in the long distance, but the physicality of the lens
is such that at a short distance, the long focus throw makes it slower to adjust. In this near situation, the AF lens has an advantage,
because the motor does it fast enough, where the fingers can't.

Another difference is made by the direction of the movement: a movement that is parallel to the film plane, means nothing
to the manual focus photographer, but can deeply annoy the AF lens, because it has to track the movement, and along the
panning, it is common that the AF finds and "engages" a different object, losing the subject completely. And even if it stays
on the subject, the tracking is going to be slower, in any case, than with a manual lens.
If on the contrary, the movement of the subject is perpendicular to the film plane, the situation is reversed: the manual photographer
needs to make a fast adjustment over a rather long focus throw, while for the AF lens nothing changes in terms of time, and
it's even better in terms of tracking, because with a subject that comes towards you, or straight away from you, you don't have
to pan the camera, so the chances of autofocus intercepting a different object and losing track are minimal.

So as you can see, it is not possible to say that AF is better of MF when there is action. One must analyze the action, because
there are actions that are favoreable to AF and actions that are favoreable to MF.


Reply

Clearly the issue is you are not using Sony/minolta
The old beercan design is probably better made than 90% of mf stuff fast to focus and you can use the quick navi to tell where you want the focus really easy
You want to see fast focus lenses the 35/75 and the 35/105 and 50 f1.7are insane the beercan is also very good and dont tend to miss often