MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Antique Rome by night
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Luckily I was invited for 3 days to Rome. That also meant being rather busy during day, but I had plenty of time to roam this amazingly beautiful city at night.
Here remnants of the Temple of Saturn at the Forum Romanum in the foreground and the church of Santi Luca e Martina at the back ( see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temple_of_Saturn resp. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santi_Luca_e_Martina )


NEX5N + SEL18-55

best greetings,
Andreas


Reply

Beautiful capture!
I think I would prefer it B&W.


Reply

Orio wrote:
Beautiful capture!
I think I would prefer it B&W.


thank you Orio.
I had made a B&W version too but had preferred the color version. Color tones at this kind of long exposure could be disturbing but in this case I rather liked them, here the B&W



another showing more of the grounds of the Forum Romanum, converted to duo tone. Someone more clever PPing also here may be able to better the image, possibly improving the impact of the cloud formation



best greetings,
Andreas


Reply

nice night shot, I like the color version, I don't like the composition of the duo tone one


Reply

poilu wrote:
nice night shot, I like the color version, I don't like the composition of the duo tone one


+1


Reply

+2


Reply

kuuan wrote:
here the B&W


Colour was good, but B&W is FANTASTIC!
I'd like to see the second image in B&W too.


Reply

stunning! just love the first one. add it now to your perennial portfolio!
tony


Reply



I think a crop gives the best result ? Then I messed about in PS Elements and Photoscape a bit. Maybe OTT ? Wink


Reply

I prefer original #1 and 3, although they are all superb.


Reply

Lloydy wrote:

I think a crop gives the best result ?


I prefer the original crop, in my opinion the image benefits from the dark area at right, it gives depth.
But the sepia looks false to me (hence why I prefer straight B&W)


Reply

wow, thank you so much for all your reactions! Interesting that opinions are divers.
Poilu most prefer the first one, and I guess would agree with you that the composition of the second is not so good. Also on flickr the one seen first received many more hits, comments and favs. From the point I took the photos the view of the second, showing more of the Forum Romanum, seemed to be the more obvious choice though. There was a number of photographers and most took that angle only.

haha, thank you Tony! Also if going by flickr it should be part of my "portfolio" as it had made it into "explore".
thank you very much Lloydy for giving it a go PPing. Interesting approach I would not have thought of because I hardly ever change the aspect ratio.

Orio it seems that while you prefer B&W most prefer the color version.
Of the second I already had made two more versions, one with less strong tones and another straight B&W which you wanted to see, here they are:


#1

#2


thank you everybody once again for looking and commenting,
best greetings,
andreas


Reply

I really like the very first image, but my eye catches the green far left. I'd probably desaturate that little bit but everything else is excellent. Very Happy


Reply

kuuan wrote:

Orio it seems that while you prefer B&W most prefer the color version.
Of the second I already had made two more versions, one with less strong tones and another straight B&W which you wanted to see


THanks, in fact I largely prefer B&W also for the second photo. Compare these last two versions you made, look into the perspective
of the view, the "platinum" version, although much better than the colour one, still creates a bit of flattening effect, whereas the
straight B&W offers a greater sense of depth and "air".
The reason is simple: colder tones in photography help the perception of the distances and dimensions. This is true of both the
colour and B&W photography. It is not Orio that discovered this, it's a guy called Leonardo some 500 years ago Smile
Leonardo attributed this to the so called "aerial pespective" (influence of haze), but there's also another reason, more physical:
the human eye is much more sensible to the shades of green than it is to the shades of red. Therefore, a neutral tone image
will always look richer in tones to the human eye than a warm-tinted image.

Quote:
#1

#2



Reply

SonicScot wrote:
I really like the very first image, but my eye catches the green far left. I'd probably desaturate that little bit but everything else is excellent. Very Happy


thank's Scott, I think it's a good advice


Reply

Orio wrote:


THanks, in fact I largely prefer B&W also for the second photo. Compare these last two versions you made, look into the perspective
of the view, the "platinum" version, although much better than the colour one, still creates a bit of flattening effect, whereas the
straight B&W offers a greater sense of depth and "air".
The reason is simple: colder tones in photography help the perception of the distances and dimensions. This is true of both the
colour and B&W photography. It is not Orio that discovered this, it's a guy called Leonardo some 500 years ago Smile
Leonardo attributed this to the so called "aerial pespective" (influence of haze), but there's also another reason, more physical:
the human eye is much more sensible to the shades of green than it is to the shades of red. Therefore, a neutral tone image
will always look richer in tones to the human eye than a warm-tinted image.


thank you for the explanation Orio.
I am certain that everything you say is correct. However others who commented prefer the color version of the first. I don't know what others feel about the second, I slightly prefer the toned versions to the B&W also of the second. ( btw. there is no original "color version". The first, darker one was from some preset in Lightroom, the later brighter one was adjusted, saturations lessened and maybe tones slightly changed from that preset )
How come, even though everything you say sure is valid? I'd say that must be because there are many variables which make an image more or less attractive to the viewer, some purely visual, others come from the mind through ideas. Maybe I simply prefer the toned version of the second because my mind tells me that tones which remind me to old photographs better fit ancient ruins? I don't know..

thank you for your very interesting informations,
best regards,
andreas