MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Is Nikon D800E the best digital platform for MF lenses?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I've had a D800E for several weeks now and I'm totally impressed with it's MF lense performance. With no AA filter and full frame it really lets you see exactly what a lens is capable of. The live view focus is amazing compared to the live view of my old D90. I have a bunch of neglected MF lenses that I plan to pull back out and try on this camera. I've already found a few surprises on the shelf and there is more life in some of those old lenses than I ever thought.


Reply

Depends on your stock: For Nikon MF lenses, is fine.
But if you want to use other legacy lenses, forget it: the Nikon register distance is too big to allow mounting most foreign lenses...
To use variety of legacy MF lenses is much better to use a short register distance system, like the mirrorless platforms, Sony NEX , Samsung NX or micro 4/3.

Regards.
Jes.


Reply

Generally speaking, all cameras without AA filter are the ideal benchmark for all lenses.
As Jes remarked, however, the Nikon's register distance limits most third party lenses to a macro use only.


Reply

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/nikon-d800-d800e/26
This shows how badly the CMOS on the 5DIII performs at base iso.
I didn't think it the difference was so huge and the problems date back to the 15 and 18mpx sensors.
Is it so hard to narrow the gap with Nikon?
Confused


Reply

ilguercio wrote:
Is it so hard to narrow the gap with Nikon?

Nikon (I mean Sony) make noise reduction in raw stage, you cannot undo the noise reduction
Canon raw is what is recorded at the sensor, I hope Canon will never fall in those tricks
if someone need to recover 3 stops with a Canon body, he can use a noise reduction plugin like Dfine or Topaz


Reply

poilu wrote:
ilguercio wrote:
Is it so hard to narrow the gap with Nikon?

Nikon (I mean Sony) make noise reduction in raw stage, you cannot undo the noise reduction
Canon raw is what is recorded at the sensor, I hope Canon will never fall in those tricks
if someone need to recover 3 stops with a Canon body, he can use a noise reduction plugin like Dfine or Topaz

Are you sure about this?


Reply

I have seen several reports that the difference between the 800E and the (regular) 800 is not that big, really, performacewise, if you use it for "normal" purposes.

And, although I believe the Nikon 800 is a fantastic cam, I don't think that it is a better cam for legacy lenses than the 5D MkIII.

poilu wrote:

Nikon (I mean Sony) make noise reduction in raw stage, you cannot undo the noise reduction


Which is not really a problem, since the NR is very sophisticated!


Reply

As Carsten said before, the differences between D800E and normal D800 are not that big. But in the meantime it is clear that the D800(E) has very high requirements to the lenses. This is true for Nikon (MF) lenses too.

Wink


Reply

LucisPictor wrote:
I have seen several reports that the difference between the 800E and the (regular) 800 is not that big, really, performacewise


Which indirectly sounds as a confirmation of what poilu wrote about the noise reduction in RAW. Because I have cameras both with (Canons) and without (M9) AA filter and the difference in detail rendition between the M9 and the full frame Canons is huge - even with comparison to the original 5D which, according to most sources, has a weaker AA filter than most other DSLRs.


Reply

If not the best, it sure is on the short list. I did forget about the issue with mounting other than nikon mount lenses though. Had the camera a little longer now and it sure does bring out the best/worse in my collection of MF lenses.. I shoot a lot of macro so it's been a really good platform for that.


Reply

poilu wrote:
Nikon (I mean Sony) make noise reduction in raw stage, you cannot undo the noise reduction
Canon raw is what is recorded at the sensor, I hope Canon will never fall in those tricks
if someone need to recover 3 stops with a Canon body, he can use a noise reduction plugin like Dfine or Topaz


Completely unsubstantiated BS. Canon 5D Mk II and III noise suppression is clearly much more aggressive in RAW output, you would know if you had used anything but Canon. Look at D700/D3 (4 year old DSLR body) detail at 100% and compare to newest 5D Mk III. If Canon owners want to become depressed, look at Nikon D4 dynamic range, detail and lack of color noise vs. Canon bodies at ISO 1600 to 6400 calibrated ISO... You can't call that a fight, much less a bout - Canon has spent years focusing on video and it shows in how their still DSLR bodies lag far behind today.


Reply

Esox lucius wrote:
Canon 5D Mk II and III noise suppression is clearly much more aggressive in RAW output


?
Can you support that statement with some evidence? I see no sign of noise removal in 5DMkII Raw files. In fact, I get a lot of noise (much more than I would like) in my Raw files.


Reply

I have used a 5D Mk II side-by-side with D3 in 2008, the 5D Mk II files showed more aggressive color noise removal than the D3/D700 sensor and A/D converter produced. This year, I have compared files from my D4 with files colleagues produce with 5D Mk III, with same results: even with noise removal set to "OFF", the analog to digital converter on Canon's 5D Mk II and III applies more aggressive noise removal before saving the file as RAW, than the Nikon bodies do. You will most prominently see this in shadows as well as the red color channel.

Google "noise removal canon vs nikon" and there's plenty of "evidence" ie testimonials from other users who have noticed the same. Perhaps some mflenses member with a 5D Mk II/III wants to carry it over to my studio, and I'll be happy to produce comparable shots against the D3, D700, D800 and D4 - the only Canon product I nowadays own is a printer.


Reply

I'm missing the word "currently" in the title line - bodies come and go so quickly,
but our MF glass stays on and on and on. I have 50+ year old lenses that still beat
the crap out of the famous 800E (or any other commercial body) .... :biggrin:


Reply

kds315* wrote:
I have 50+ year old lenses that still beat the crap out of the famous 800E (or any other commercial body) .... :biggrin:


I haven't a clue what that means.


Reply

I think there's no doubt that the current crop of Sony made sensors are king of the hill at the moment, especially with regards dynamic range, but noise control appears better too. But, for MF lenses the Canon 5D III is the more attractive package with regards compatibility. Plus, as far as I'm concerned, everything since the original 5D and D700 has been more than adequate for most purposes anyway Laughing


Reply

ManualFocus-G wrote:
I think there's no doubt that the current crop of Sony made sensors are king of the hill at the moment ...... but noise control appears better too.


Some Sony cameras do appear to carry out noise reduction on RAW files. See, for example the evidence presented by DxOMark for the Sony alpha900. Trawling through the DxOMark site you can find similar results for other Sony cameras and for at least one Pentax camera. If DxOMark has presented similar results for any Nikon cameras or indeed for Canon cameras, then I would be interested to see them - or indeed, any evidence from elswhere.

Of course some detractors of DxOMark suggests that it favours Nikon so ......