MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

What's your usual software(s) for editing?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Hello !
Wich soft do you use for editing , pros and cons ?


Reply

Acdseepro very handy , powerful tool with many feature , best what I know, sadly sometimes crash, but I can live with that.


Reply

Mainly Photoshop. I got CS4 from my department at university.
And sometimes Lightroom, now with the new computer it finally is usable. Wink


Reply

GIMP Smile .
Pros: first & foremost it's free Very Happy. It has most of the advanced functions one would want for photography work, such levels, curves and so on.
Cons: no 16bit support, sometimes confusing multi window interface.

Looks like these will be fixed soon in the 3.0 version.
We can see the WIP in the 2.7 development version, I'm testing it as part of major upgrade of my linux box.
The "self contained" monolithic window seems to work well and for what is concerning the 16bit support at least is possible to load 16bit tiffs. I'm still not sure if saving is possible too. I've not yet explored the new gegl operations.

Cheers, M.


Reply

marty wrote:
... the 3.0 version.


I am curiously wating for that one to see if the GUI really has improved.


Reply

I find them all varying degrees of being a real PITA Confused

GIMP is pretty much the only realistic option with Linux, though I detest the user interface. It's confusing, has horrible defaults (I still can't make it default to NOT having a little paint can that puts marks on my images if I click the mouse!)

I hope GIMP 3.0 really is better, though to be fair it has been horrible for the last ten or fifteen years, so I don't have high hopes Sad


Reply

Here's what the UI looks like in 2.7:


For the aficionados is still switchable with the old one.


Reply

There used to be a software called GIMPShop which unfortunately is no longer supported.
That turned GIMP into a PS lookalike.


Reply

http://rawtherapee.com/ is a great free program


Reply

photivo http://photivo.org/photivo/start


Reply

Downloader Pro / Breezebrowser Pro for raw file browsing
Lightroom for RAW processing and file sorting (I also have Capture One and Bibble but I feel less comfortable)
Photoshop CS5 for everything else.


Reply

poilu wrote:
http://rawtherapee.com/ is a great free program

I don't know why it didn't worked at all for me .
gimp and PS seems to need a knowledge that I don't have and a lot of time to work with.
Lightroom that I had a trial version and Capture One in trial version also are more suited to my needs .
ACDsee pro ? have to try it
A very good free denoiser and corrector (scratches ,dots, dust on sensor or film)was for me the Helicon filter 4.8 .Unfortunately the 5. version isn't free anymore.
for file browsing I am used with the Canon Zoombrowser .DPP sometimes for Canon Raw


Reply

For RAW conversions, I use Adobe Photoshop CS5 or Nikon Capture NX 2. Every time a new RAW converter comes out or is upgraded I test it, for the past 3 years I've been using this combo but time will show if a new software takes their place. For editing, I use only Photoshop CS5.

If I have a batch of many high ISO files (ie. a wedding documentary) I use CS5: although Adobe Camera RAW is a piece of junk, it comes with one of the best user interfaces on the market. For critical work (prints, commercial work on single files) I use Nikon Capture NX 2, which gives the best results but has a horrible user interface which only recently became 64-bit (thankfully). I dislike Lightroom, the file archiving/export system is slow and inefficient and it's not because of my hardware - fastest processor, max RAM, fastest GPU and SSD drives. With Lightroom I also dislike not being in as much control as with CS5. I have no use for cheesy profiles which Lightroom is full of - my profiles are in my head if I want to batch 100 files to have the same look.

Most camera manufacturers have not opened up all of their RAW source code to 3rd party software manufacturers like Adobe. About 10% of the code is still protected, especially the parts that affect highlight/shadow recovery as well as noise suppression. This is also the reason why ACR is crap especially when it comes to highlights and shadows. Same applies to lens profiles which correct geometric distortion (barrel or pincushion). Lens manufacturers have all the data in their computerized designs which means they can apply more precise correction when chipped lenses tell focal length used and distance to focus point - all the 3rd party software correction profiles are based on shooting test charts which is a research method that only reveals part of the problems. Adobe Camera RAW 6.6 seems to have improved considerably, I've used it for 1 week now and to me it seems that the v4 profiles are much more closer to the results I can achieve in CNX2.

I can't speak for Canon/Sony/Leica/etc. RAW files and how good or bad CS5 is with them - things may be different if you are not shooting with Nikon. Then again, I notice quality differences clients will never notice, so the differences are negligible in practice.

I don't denoisify images, ever since I got my D3 there simply has been no need for noise removal. Next month I'll replace the D3 with a D4, so it will be interesting to see how long it takes for Adobe to come out with a reasonably good profile for the Nikon D4


Last edited by Esox lucius on Sun Jan 08, 2012 8:50 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

+1 for CNX2. I could never get the "right" colours with ACR - although I haven't tried the latest version.


Reply

CS5, Adobe Bridge.

Pros: the definitive photo editing software.
Cons: spendy to get into initially.


Reply

Photoshop (Most editing, RAW conversion and Web Slicing), Noise Ninja (This should be self-explanatory) and Genuine Fractals (Interpolation for biiiig prints).

Pro's:-
Does what I want, and there is usually a Tutorial or guide for anything new to me.
Amazingly Powerful.
Plugins for anything you can think of.


Con's:-
Wallet-screamingly expensive.
No-one, almost without exception, will accept you have a Genuine product until you break out the documentation.
Learning curve is very very steep for anything other than the basic's.


Reply

I use Adobe Camera RAW for 99% of editing, it's quite slow but everything I need day to day is in the tabs. Very rarely if I need to layer merge or selectively edit I use Photoshop. Have recently tried Audacity for fun with strange results. This happened:



See this link for an introduction to databending:

http://www.hellocatfood.com/2009/11/16/databending-using-audacity/


Reply

Definitive? Definitely NOT for raw. Was built around jpg/tiff, Raw processing in PS in garbage ....


patrickh