MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Canon 100/2.8 L IS "Test"
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I rented the Canon 100/2.8 L IS and did a test for my purposes. IS is supposed to be limited when near 1:1, for me it did not work at all. Was able to hand-hold at 1/100th and faster, as I already do with my NIkkor 105/2.8.

It is very sharp, a bit bulky compared to the Nikkor (USM motor and IS gerbils). Not that big an improvement over the Nikkor, so I'll pass.

Here are my test samples (this is not a formal test. It's a test for the way I shoot, hand-held, natural light, using my very own one-of-a-kind body to hold the camera even!): http://markcolman.tv/?p=758










I may rent the Zeiss 100/2 or 50/2 next. Wish I could find a Voigtlander 125/2.

There's a few more images on my blog:
http://markcolman.tv/?p=758


Reply

Though not mf these are stunning!


Reply

Wonderful images!!! Congrats!


Reply

Sharp, contrast, colors, anything is there.
How is the price compared with Zeiss 100/2.8?


Reply

Fabulous shots. Lens looks to be good too.


Reply

Thanks guys!

@Himself, the Zeiss 100/2 is twice as expensive. It only goes 1:2 but the samples I've seen are razor sharp wide open. The IS didn't work for me and the previous version of this lens w/o IS is half the cost. My Nikkor 105 Micro is close to this good. I'm considering an older Zeiss 60mm Makro (thanks to Orio for the good advice).

Willem, I did manually focus all of these. The autofocus is most irritating! Smile


Reply

too good, I wish I can do that in 20 years Crying or Very sad
if you work at 1:1, you should also consider a apo rodagon 75, only F4 but should give better result from 1:1 to 2:1 for 100 euros

Quote:
Kram has over twenty years experience in fine art, fashion, and advertising photography. Mark can save you twenty years of attending the School of Hard Knocks!


Reply

poilu wrote:
too good, I wish I can do that in 20 years Crying or Very sad
if you work at 1:1, you should also consider a apo rodagon 75, only F4 but should give better result from 1:1 to 2:1 for 100 euros



Thanks poilu! I'll check out the apo rodagon 75mm. Sounds interesting!


Reply

Kram - your images are amazing!!! I have a couple of macro lenses, but lately I have been taking the lazy way out. I use a Canon 135 f/2 L, focus manually and rely on the sharpness of this lens and high pixel count (21 MP) of the Canon 5d Mii body to provide enough lee-way for digital enlargement. My dragonfly image is nowhere near as nice as your pics, but it demonstrates the magnification and resolution that can be obtained using this technique.

[quote="poilu"]too good, I wish I can do that in 20 years Crying or Very sad
if you work at 1:1, you should also consider a apo rodagon 75, only F4 but should give better result from 1:1 to 2:1 for 100 euros

Poilu, is the Apo Rodagon you refer to an enlarging lens?





Reply

Kram, superb images! Thanks for sharing.


Reply

Kram, it's well known that the AF is slow for the macro lenses.
DOF is very thin and it takes time to "see" the part of the picture that is in focus.


Reply

poilu wrote:
too good, I wish I can do that in 20 years Crying or Very sad
if you work at 1:1, you should also consider a apo rodagon 75, only F4 but should give better result from 1:1 to 2:1 for 100 euros


I would very much like to know where you can get that lens for 100€


Reply

pdccameras wrote:
is the Apo Rodagon you refer to an enlarging lens?

it look like a enlarger lens but it is a macro lens optimized for 1:1 where enlarger lenses are optimized 1:20

lauge wrote:
I would very much like to know where you can get that lens for 100€

maybe I am out of date, I didn't follow the prices lately
I bought mine 90 euros and my zeiss 60 for 230 euros


Reply

I have moved the topic to the autofocus corner; after all it's about the use and results of AF lenses. That these shots were made by manually focusing an AF lens is not a determining factor Wink

But the results are stunning. Because of the photographer and not because of the lens, I reckon Smile


Reply

poilu wrote:
pdccameras wrote:
is the Apo Rodagon you refer to an enlarging lens?

it look like a enlarger lens but it is a macro lens optimized for 1:1 where enlarger lenses are optimized 1:20

lauge wrote:
I would very much like to know where you can get that lens for 100€

maybe I am out of date, I didn't follow the prices lately
I bought mine 90 euros and my zeiss 60 for 230 euros


In my book that is a bargain, if you ever find that lens again at that price range let me know Smile That lens sells for $649 at B&H