MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Digital black & white
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

The more I look at digital black and whites, the more artificial they become to me. They are too smooth and "plastic" to my eyes, I guess.

I just made this picture, and I think it would look so much better on film. Actually, there are two exposures on a roll of Kodak BW400CN Smile



What do you think of digital black and white, and about tricks like adding grain or other imperfections to the pictures?


Reply

What I think of digital b&w??? Smile

I just installed a b&w film in one of my SLR's because I can not produce nice B&W shots with my DSLR.

There is something about a real b&w film... I don't know what, but it is there.


Reply

Well i like film b&w rendition more cause the grey shade is more important. Though i also appreciate the digital rendition of it, maybe it be for quick shots in jpeg or "serious' shots in raw.

In fact i'm happy with both, here's one example, raw file converted in Lightroom Very Happy




Reply

zippie wrote:
What I think of digital b&w??? Smile

I just installed a b&w film in one of my SLR's because I can not produce nice B&W shots with my DSLR.

There is something about a real b&w film... I don't know what, but it is there.


+1


Reply

hexi wrote:
Well i like film b&w rendition more cause the grey shade is more important. Though i also appreciate the digital rendition of it, maybe it be for quick shots in jpeg or "serious' shots in raw.

In fact i'm happy with both, here's one example, raw file converted in Lightroom Very Happy


Actually that one is not bad. But if you look at the progression from black to white on the bridge rails, you would think that film could give more tones there.


Reply

eeyore_nl wrote:
(...)
What do you think of digital black and white, and about tricks like adding grain or other imperfections to the pictures?

No. I think that there is nothing like converting digital to film. We can get such final filing that is more "analog" image by occasion during PP but usually this what we see - is what we want to see. And really true is in the middle. My way. Shot in RAW, keep it as RGB file, I don't use grayscale to convert. Last step in my case is always changing a bit tonality of the picture. I like very much both above conversion. Currently mine look like or similar to these below. Taken with Canon5m2 and 1.4/24L, ISO 6400!!!





Reply

eeyore_nl wrote:

What do you think of digital black and white


What I think of it... it's different. My personal experience is that I always get the best results with film. Digital BW can "work", of course, when it is properly processed and all, and sometimes can even fool the viewer... but in general, it's different.
I am trying to think of a comparison, and the best one to explain what I think, is to think of different tunings in musical instruments.
For instance, several pieces of baroque keyboard music were written to be played with tunings that are "alternative" to the currently common "tempered" tuning.
These pieces, can also "work" when played on a keyboard with conventional tempered tuning, but when you listen to them played on the tuning that they were supposed to be played in originally, you say "ahh". They just sound right. Not that the tempered performance was bad. But these sound just right.
That's the BW film for me. If feels just right. While a digital conversion (at least, my own digital conversions) feels ok, but, not quite 'there'. BW Film feels "just right".

I have pondered about it and my personal impression is that it has to do with the 'intervals' or different distances between the different tones in the grey scale.
Like, both a film and digital BW may start and end from the same black and white points, but the relations between the 'in-betweens' changes.
And I have the feeling that while the digital file offers a more constant and somehow predictable series of intervals, BW film does offer different lenghts and size of intervals between tones.
I am probably saying a lot of stupid things Laughing but that is how it feels to me, speaking from my absolutely non-technical point of view.

eeyore_nl wrote:
and about tricks like adding grain or other imperfections to the pictures?


They may work, but usually they feel like easy shortcuts to me, like quick cheating. Like "my photo is good, but not good enough, so let's take a cheap shortcut to improve it". So I don't like them. I prefer to work on making my photo better to start with. And when I use BW conversion plugins that offer grain feature, I always zero it. It feels more honest to me (although it is probably just stupid Laughing )


Reply

Orio wrote:

I have pondered about it and my personal impression is that it has to do with the 'intervals' or different distances between the different tones in the grey scale.
Like, both a film and digital BW may start and end from the same black and white points, but the relations between the 'in-betweens' changes.
And I have the feeling that while the digital file offers a more constant and somehow predictable series of intervals, BW film does offer different lenghts and size of intervals between tones.
I am probably saying a lot of stupid things Laughing but that is how it feels to me, speaking from my absolutely non-technical point of view.

eeyore_nl wrote:
and about tricks like adding grain or other imperfections to the pictures?


They may work, but usually they feel like easy shortcuts to me, like quick cheating. Like "my photo is good, but not good enough, so let's take a cheap shortcut to improve it". So I don't like them. I prefer to work on making my photo better to start with. And when I use BW conversion plugins that offer grain feature, I always zero it. It feels more honest to me (although it is probably just stupid Laughing )


Yes, I agree with all that. Like I said in the first post; digital (at least with my simple conversion in Canon DPP) looks more plastic to me. That probably has to do with the equal sensitivity to all color tones of a digital sensor, though that should be the case with panchromatic films as well.

About adding noise or (like I saw recently) scratches and spots ... I don't like that at all. If you want to mimic film, then you should simply use film, instead of making something else look like it.


Reply

Film is film, and digital- digital only. Final product. Prints. Prints from digital lab and print made in darkroom. I am very conservative regarding this.
Pure analog product is taken with any film camera using any light sensitive material to prepare negative image. Then developing-processing using darkroom equipment and chemistry. After our picture is dried and we can see The Final one. Then we can talk about pure "soul" of analog photography. There is another true. No one monitor is good enough to show pros and cons of darkroom print. It is always "close more or less".


Reply

I'm with Eeyore and Orio on this one. I was looking at some shots taken with a Yashica FX rangefinder on quite indifferent film.. and the detail, the tonality was much greater to my eyes than digital's rendering. I am pretty sure that Ansel would have eschewed digital and stuck with film! lol

There is almost a photogravure look to a genuine film rendition. Even here we scan the B&W to show on the web, so it is still a digital rendering, albeit of a halide original? Seeing 'pure' silver process prints, I can ALWAYS tell them from digital prints - Hell it's easy enough to distinguish even when the film is scanned then printed via ink-jet.... Maybe some playing with HDR can get close to film (with maybe PP grain) but.. who else thinks it's easy to trick the senses?

Maybe we should institute a competition where the same scene is captured using each technology, and we guess which is which?

Doug.


Reply

It's similar to colour film and colour digital.
Neither one is "better", they are "different".

With some tools (such as Silver Efex Pro) you can simulate film pretty well.


Reply

LucisPictor wrote:

With some tools (such as Silver Efex Pro) you can simulate film pretty well.


Just as the purpose of a synthesizer is not to simulate traditional instruments, digital photography should not simulate film. At least, in my opinion.


Reply

An interesting point.. though of course most synths ARE used to replace traditional instruments, where one synth can 'be' a clarinet, a drum set and a piano in one small box. I like the music from the early moogs where the synth WAS the sound Smile Smile


Doug

eeyore_nl wrote:
LucisPictor wrote:

With some tools (such as Silver Efex Pro) you can simulate film pretty well.


Just as the purpose of a synthesizer is not to simulate traditional instruments, digital photography should not simulate film. At least, in my opinion.


Reply

eeyore_nl wrote:
LucisPictor wrote:

With some tools (such as Silver Efex Pro) you can simulate film pretty well.


Just as the purpose of a synthesizer is not to simulate traditional instruments, digital photography should not simulate film. At least, in my opinion.


And still both are frequently used that way. Who tells the users that they do wrong?


Reply

A question from a rookie.

How about scanning analog B&W. Does that beat B&W from digital exposure (as viewed on a screen)?

Otherwise analog B&W is better viewed on paper and cannot be directly compared to a screen regardless of the digital screen source.

Or do you compare printed digital B&W to copied analog film?

/T


Reply

I spent 4 years with developing negatives/positives which was a part of my education

There was not too much interest from my side -- I was too young but we did all professionally ..

temperature, chemicals, gradation curves, density measuring on developed film

I saw first drum scanners in my life and results were INCREDIBLE.

all these things had to be done in perfection as a part of printing work-flow (mainly offset) ...

We worked with all kind of films - small, big formats .... bla bla ... even colour ones and of course, with different gradations
.. from smooth to the strongest ones..

I think that the film is the best for BW ... i.e. AGFA or FOMA films were very very good.

tf


Reply

torbod wrote:
Or do you compare printed digital B&W to copied analog film?


Can a trained eye can't spot right away a film or digital b&w print ? I"m not so sure ...

Ok now just a quick part about both digital and film b&w and stuff.

In my shots, might they be serious, or not, i like them to be enjoyable. There's always an "artistic" part with b&w, but not everyone likes it. I do and some of my friends as well, in fact they don't care if it's film or digital, they just like b&w, and they're happy with the shots i do.

Nothing exceptional, but i think that digital b&w ( and color of course ) can make photos more user friendly to some people not into serious shooting, or even not in photo. All they want is a good image.


To sum it up : i found my digital b&w to me more than honest "even" in L JPEG evil mode, it's enough for what i do. And it makes people happy, what else do we need ?


Reply

I've tried the in-camera B&W transformation (PictureStyle monochrome) and I like it, and the people to which I've shown the pictures do too.
Two examples:
One with Jupiter 37A 135mm 3.5, at f5.6 I think, 1/3200s, ISO 100

The other one with a Sigma 20mm (AF, sorry guys), f1.8, 1/250s, ISO 100


I agree that they certainly not look like film, but it's not film, it's digital. That does not change the advantages of B&W photography.


Reply

I know eeyore_nl, for example, has shot 400 CN films. I welcome comments on this from anyone.

In your experience what is the difference, if any, in comparing any of the 400CN films to the silver film and digital-digital conversions talked about in this thread? Does it make a difference if the 400CN negative is inkjet printed after a 400CN to digital conversion or is "straight" darkroom printed from the negative?

In my experience - Kodak 400CN, Ilford XP2, Neopan 400CN, Konica 400CN - each 400CN is different from the others in terms of various observable properties if one uses the same printing paper, either darkroom or inkjet, or scans negatives from each without any real PP. However I just have not spent serious time trying out different print papers or doing serious PP to get these to look more or less the same. If anyone has, I would also appreciate opinions about those results.


Reply

Ok, now i'm very happy cos today i've made my first prints, b&w of course . It was great and it's not "very" difficult Very Happy

Back to topic : the visual difference is small indeed, and one can be fooled. But what a pleasure to see the pic appear in the developer, once the tests are done !!!!!!!!!

That's one "thing" that digital b&w whatever it may be better looking than film can't beat !!

maybe it has to go to darkroom, sorry for the off thread :s


Reply

jmiro wrote:
I know eeyore_nl, for example, has shot 400 CN films. I welcome comments on this from anyone.

In your experience what is the difference, if any, in comparing any of the 400CN films to the silver film and digital-digital conversions talked about in this thread? Does it make a difference if the 400CN negative is inkjet printed after a 400CN to digital conversion or is "straight" darkroom printed from the negative?


400CN prints look more like digital prints than like analog film prints. I don't (inkjet) print at home, but I send my pictures to a digital printing lab instead. If your primary purpose is printing, then I would go for traditional silver film and darkroom printing.

However, I recently scanned a couple of "real" B/W negatives, and that is a pain compared to BW400CN scanning.

The main differences between digital B/W and C-41 monochrome film:

- the highlight details are much better preserved in the C-41 film
- digital black & white delivers a "plastic" look
- the shadow detail in digital B/W is superb
- the resolution of digital B/W is much higher than of scanned film (with my Epson scanner)


Reply

Digital images usually look cleaner. I think this is what you call `plastic'. Yes it does look synthetic, but that's because it is I guess. Film has a character that I like but often the grain bothers me and I remove it.


Reply

Grain is a particular thing to b&w analog, it doesn't bother me at all ! I've even been surprised when i made enlargments this weekend , already with a medium fast film the grain is quite visible ( 4OO )

i just wait to enlarge pushed film ^^


Reply

Hi!

It's my first post.

I think an anterior experience with BW film will give the parameters to practice an aesthetic BW with digital cameras, but the approach and the possibilities are different. I think the way is not simulating a BW film but get inspiration in BW film to make a digital BW.