MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Good sellers here on MFL and one bad
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Hi all
I bought too many lenses here from various members Embarassed , my last purchase was from Joosep, item as described, fast delivery. The same is also valid for: Attila, of course Smile , Pancolart, my first source for MF lenses, no-X, Kuunan and some more that i don t remember. Unfortunatelly i had a very bad expirience (at least so far) with a long time member Mal1909. Evil or Very Mad

Tomas


Reply

Can you explain a bit more about Mal1909?

I think you would say Mal1905, Malachy ? Right ?


Reply

glad to know that you were happy with the purchase from me, and thank you for mentioning Tomas.

hm..I am very curious about Mal1905. I had one perfect sale to him, but on a second had some small issues, but I assume that 'most of it' most was fault of the postal service
He has not been active in the forum for quite a while now, right?


Reply

First of all, let me say i don t want this to be a public process, above all with the absence of the "accused" pearson.

Here are the facts:
i payed for a Helios 40 Mal1905 was selling, he got the payment on the 6th of March. After a period of 2 or 3 weeks, we started to exchange emails here, about the fact it was taking so long for the lens to arrive. After a few more weeks, i got a email from him, saying he ll refund me the money if the lens didn t arrived in a week. I never got the lens, i checked at the post office, if there was a package for me, nothing. I wrote many emails after that, no response on that email adress. I asked Attila for the email adress that Mal1905 used to subscribe here, no response on this second email adress. Few days ago, i sent him a email to an adress i got from PayPal, asking where s my lens or my money, i got a replay the next day, this is a copy paste:

I sent your lens many months ago. I assumed you had received it and were just rude by not acknowledging receipt.




Sent from my iPad

On 2 Oct 2011, at 17:46

Needless to say i replayed immidiately, sadly no response again.

Tomas


Reply

This is really bad indeed Twisted Evil


Reply

tomasg wrote:
Mal1905 wrote:
I sent your lens many months ago. I assumed you had received it and were just rude by not acknowledging receipt.




Sent from my iPad

On 2 Oct 2011, at 17:46


Needless to say i replayed immidiately, sadly no response again.

Tomas


Whether or not there's any reasonable explanation for the missing lens, this isn't a nice thing for one of our members to say to another. It isn't the first time Mal1905 has been involved in trading controversy, I think I remember.

I hope you get your money back at least, Tomas. Can you make a Paypal claim?


Reply

Well i have made my conclusion, you make your own. BUT i would love to be proven wrong, i am always ready to give the benefit of doubt, a lot of things can happen in life, family death, illness, business trips, you got the idea. Personally i think i would find 5 minutes to write a couple of lines.

Tomas


Reply

Quote:
Can you make a Paypal claim?


I ll try, it s going to be the first time.

Tomas


Reply

Was the package send with tracking number?


Reply

BRunner wrote:
Was the package send with tracking number?


RIght question , never ever buy anything without tracking number.


Reply

First of all, thanx for the interest you guys are showing in this case and for the help. He didn t sent me the tracking number (lesson learned). This is from an email:
Quote:
I will send the lens by Registered Post on Tuesday
, the package was sent from Ireland, i guess.

Loosing money is bad enough, not being able to buy another lens is too:

Quote:
Mal

i didn t get the lens, now i can buy a Helios from Orio, please i want my money back, thanx

Tomas


Tomas


Reply

It's not the first, US member had same case, he opened to public, then Mal refund him.
Months before, I had same case. I didn't open to public, as I respect him. I even asked him to refund half price.
I think the problem is Ireland post office, maybe...
I believe in Mal... He will refund you, just give him time. Can you imagine if he lost the lens and he must refund?


Reply

Thanx for the feedback, IAZA, i hope you are right, as i earlyer said, i don t want this to be a trial, or public lynching.

Tomas


Reply

If some member lives near Mal, he can try to contact him directly.


Reply

Orio wrote:
If some member lives near Mal, he can try to contact him directly.

Malachy lives in Dublin. I have his email and his street address if you need it.


Reply

That s a good idea Orio, thanx, any members from Ireland?

Tomas