MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Pancolar 1.8/50 vs CZ Makro-Planar 2.8/60 - a little quiz :)
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Hi there -- shooting our christmas tree --

Let's do some quiz - please tell me, if you see any difference between the QUALITY of the picture 1 and 2 Smile

There are 2 pictures taken by 2 different lenses = Pancolar 1.8/50 and Carl Zeiss Makro-Planar 2.8/60..


n1 --- which lens is this one ?




n2 --- which lens is this one?




happy new year Smile 2009

yours

tf


Reply

Pretty impossible mission to find out which one for sure. Orio did it already best CZ vs some Russian. I wasn't sure at all which one is.



I guess second is Macro lens.


Reply

OK,

let's wait for some other members -- I increased the larger size to 1600 px to see more details on them Smile

I will announce the result by this morning Smile until 12 am ...

tf


Reply

Second is Macro for sure Very Happy. SEcond = more DoF Very Happy.
SO first one is Pancolar Very Happy.
Nice quiz Very Happy and nice photos!


Reply

first is better, must be the macro


Reply

The second string shows more glare/glow. It's typical for Pancolar at f/1.8, but I have no experience with macro Planar, so it's only my poor tip Smile


Reply

Thanks guys for looking Smile

Here is the result promised to be announced today Smile

1. picture was taken by Carl Zeiss Makro-Planar 2.8/60

2. picture was taken by Pancolar 1.8/50 Aus Jena -- (zebra version)

I would add -- I bought Pancolar because of Attila's reference ! Smile -- It's an excellent glass...

Both pictures at f/8 + flash -- hand held ... sharpness in camera at level 0 -- It was adjusted in Light Room -- no too much..

tf


Reply

Awesome! I've been absolutely tricked Sad.


Reply

Yes! I was amazed as well ..

My recommendation is : Pancolar 1.8/50 aus jena is SUPERB lens ..

tf


Reply

trifox wrote:

Here is the result promised to be announced today Smile
1. picture was taken by Carl Zeiss Makro-Planar 2.8/60
2. picture was taken by Pancolar 1.8/50 Aus Jena -- (zebra version)


I noticed this thread just now.
I usually play with these threads they are fun Smile
I played this too and did not cheat - I did not read in advance - and I guessed right Cool


Reply

1 is Pancolar
2 is contax
because I feel (2) get clearer in edge than (1), and (2) get more color.
Wink


Reply

Even after seeing the result, I still cannot tell the difference. Surprised


Reply

Quite a performance from the Pancolar, given how close it is to the Makro Planar, which is well known for its sharpness and other attributes. When price goes into the equation..... Shocked



patrickh


Reply

Wow. Very close IQ.
Without looking at postings before, I'd say 1st Planar 2nd Pancolar

PS: Dang, I've been folled aswell. Impressive Pancolar!


Reply

So very close!!

I don't have any of these lenses, so there is no chance for me to tell.
I guessed that the second one was the Macro-Zeiss, because I thought I saw a tiny bit more details. But then, I would not have bet on it. Wink


Reply

Pancolar is a terrifis lens IMO, i have one and it's the most used manual lens in my cabinet (even though i cannot reach to infinity)


Reply

Nice Stan!

without further reading, #1 MP, #2 Pancolar, I have noticed the tiny yellowish color cast and a different FOV Smile