MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Register and lenses - impact on image quality
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

after some real experience with different registers --- I can tell this:

I think the short register is --- better -- in my opinion..

so rangefinder propably wins ...

what do you think? Smile

tf


Last edited by trifox on Sun Oct 18, 2009 9:39 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

Better in what ? Altough 110 cameras have very short register, this format is dead...
Edit : and medium format systems are not so bad...


Reply

RF is dead? Did you mean this? Smile

tf


Reply

trifox wrote:
after some real experience with different registers --- I can tell this:

I think the short register is --- better -- in my opinion..

so rangefinder propably wins ...



Can you tell us why you think that ?


Reply

If you mean better in terms of adaptation possibilities, then yes.
But in general terms I wouldn't agree.


Reply

I'm convinced that you are correct. Smile
The real advantage besides IQ for me with RF is framing and comp.
You can see the entire scene rather than one tiny focused area and nothing outside of the VF.
It's like tunnel vision.


Reply

at shorter register -- exposure times are shorter --

it works like an extension tube ...
i.e. 3 mm difference may be critical between two registers

I don't know -- I just think that one fast lens at 42 mm register
is faster than the same lens at 45 mm or 46 mm camera register..


tf


Last edited by trifox on Sun Oct 18, 2009 10:12 pm; edited 4 times in total


Reply

F16SUNSHINE wrote:
I'm convinced that you are correct. Smile
The real advantage besides IQ for me with RF is framing and comp.
You can see the entire scene rather than one tiny focused area and nothing outside of the VF.
It's like tunnel vision.


that's the second issue -- comp ..


Reply

The light hits the medium with more intensity with RF short register.
I'm not an engineer but, it makes sense to me that this will equate to sharper images with greater detail.
Of course the control of distortion is better as well.
The only disadvantage is some illumination drop of with wider lenses.

edit= spelling


Last edited by F16SUNSHINE on Sun Oct 18, 2009 10:46 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

I also got better result with RF cameras Yashica Electro 35 and Canon QL17 than any of my 35mm SLR with any of my best lenses.

Also I got better result with most medium format camera and lenses than my 35mm systems include RF and SLR.


Reply

trifox wrote:


I don't know -- I just think that one fast lens at 42 mm register
is faster than the same lens at 45 mm or 46 mm camera register..



Suppose we take a Nikon lens mounted on a Nikon camera (register = 46.5 mm) and take a picture of some object. We now replace the Nikon camera with a Pentax camera (register = 45.5 mm) - no adapter is needed for many lenses - so that the sensor plane of the Pentax is in the postion occupied by the Nikon sensor. In order to regain focus on the same object we have to move the optical cell of the lens 1 mm further forward. The register distance is irrelevant. The distance between the optical cell and the sensor, determines the light reaching the sensor and it is the same in both cases.


Reply

rangefinder cameras means no compromise in the design of lenses, especially wide angle.
I don't say this - Zeiss does Wink

Anyway like all things in life, things balance, and if with RF you see the whole scene, like Andy says, with SLR you see exactly what you lens is seeing, including depth of field, and for some genres of photography, like portraits for instance, this is a definite advantage.

-


Reply

Well, having read a few lens design books and tried to understand what they want to express, it got quite clear that a shorter lens register makes design of lenses much easier.


Reply

F16SUNSHINE wrote:
The light hits the medium with more intensity with RF short register.


Really?

How much light is lost by going through a few mm of air?


Reply

F16SUNSHINE wrote:
The light hits the medium with more intensity with RF short register.


And after another meter or so, the light has lost all its intensity and everything turns black - apart from a tendency to develop asthma and oversized black helmets the main disadvantage of being on the dark side of the Force. Rolling Eyes

Nope. Long registers would only mute the light more than short ones if there was a coloured or opaque medium (like fog or iodine vapour) between the lens and film/sensor.


Reply

kds315* wrote:
Well, having read a few lens design books ...


please share titles! Smile


Reply

Orio wrote:
rangefinder cameras means no compromise in the design of lenses, especially wide angle.
I don't say this - Zeiss does Wink

kds315* wrote:
Well, having read a few lens design books and tried to understand what they want to express, it got quite clear that a shorter lens register makes design of lenses much easier.


That's the point, esp. for wide angle lenses.

Composing is another issue, away from lens performance.

More light? Don't think so. The bayonet flange is exactly where the design of a lens needs it to be, or the other way around. In every case, no matter if the cam has a short or longer register distance.
Only if you use extension tubes you change that. And then you need to accept a loss of light.

The absence of a mirror flap enables the photographer to hold longer exposure speeds. Perhaps that's the answer why RFs are very good for low light shots.


Reply

Extension tubes, or think of a bellows. Before TTL metering you had to do some exposure compensation math.... but these are not a matter of a handful of millimeters, but rather armfuls Smile

So: in 35mm SLR, take some of the short flange distance mounts: Konica @40.7mm, Canon FD @42mm. Compare to Nikon F @46.5mm, or Leica R @47mm, or Contax-N @48mm.

Taking the Konica and Leica R - a difference of 6.3mm - and if you used this size extension tube on a 50mm Konica lens, you'd get a loss of 1/3 stop (my math may be way off!)

Does this mean that a Konica f/1.7 50mm lens is 1/3 stop slower - in absolute terms - than a Leica R f/1.7 50mm? But due to smaller register distance, the two perform equivalently in their native mounts?


Or conversely, those who have adapted MF lenses to 35mm, do these larger lenses act slightly faster with the "negative" extension tube equivalent Wink (Distension tube? LOL)


Reply

[duplicate post due to hiccups]

Looking at the handy 1/3 stop scale ... 1/3 stop faster than f/1.8 = 1.6

Would the Leica R 50/1.8 act like a f/1.76 on a Konica?


Reply

Nesster wrote:

Does this mean that a Konica f/1.7 50mm lens is 1/3 stop slower - in absolute terms - than a Leica R f/1.7 50mm?


No. The distance of their optical plane is the same. "Register distance" is no optical property but the purely mechanical distance between the mounting flange and the film/sensor plane. The optical planes of the lens are entirely independent of it - register is merely a body/barrel thing.

We tend to connect register distance and the useful space for lens construction, because SLRs inevitably have a long register distance as a consequence of their deep mirror box - but only the mirror swing range inside the latter prevents attachment of optical constructions protruding into the camera body.

As a matter of fact, rangefinders usually haven't really that small a register distance (the 27.95 of the Leica M is pretty much the shortest standard - not enough to fit a true 35mm wide-angle if the rear element does not protude), but as they have clear space up to the shutter, wide-angle constructions with very small distance between rear element and film are feasible, by letting the rear elements protrude into the camera. Even the 2.8/28mm G Biogon, a modest wide-angle, goes 16mm deep into the camera body, more than half its register distance and about a third of its size - the rear elements of some RF ultrawides are only 3-4mm off the film plane.


Last edited by Sevo on Mon Oct 19, 2009 6:40 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

siriusdogstar wrote:
kds315* wrote:
Well, having read a few lens design books ...


please share titles! Smile


Too many actually...a few I liked especially:
- Lens Design Fundamentals by Rudolf Kingslake and R. Barry Johnson
- A History of the Photographic Lens by Rudolf Kingslake
- Applied Photographic Optics, Third Edition (I have all three editions, all expensive but a great book with lots of illustrations) by Sidney Ray
- Photographic Lenses: Photographer's Guide to Characteristics, Quality, Use and Design by Ernst Wildi (he has written the great classic book on Hasselblads also)

and many many more in my library....