MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Coloured filters on a DSLR?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I have a yellow filter (Hoya Y-K2) that I've just tried out on my Lydith, attached to a 40D.

Comparing the before and after filter images I really can't see any difference so I assume there is some digital wizardry compensating somewhere? Camera set to JPG and Monochrome.

With filter


Without filter


Reply

Maybe the camera does a whitebalance first (removing the yellow cast) and does a B/W conversion after that?

I'd recommend to just shoot RAW and in color. Any B/W conversions can be done afterwards (only if you want that of course).


Reply

Automatic white balance. If the filter is weak enough, teh camera software is able to compensate that if set to automatic WB. The effect of stronger ones cannot be compensated. You have to use a preset WB to see the difference if you want to.

Funny that you would call that "colored filters" - sounds like you painted them... Wink


Reply

Spotmatic wrote:
Maybe the camera does a whitebalance first (removing the yellow cast) and does a B/W conversion after that?

I'd recommend to just shoot RAW and in color. Any B/W conversions can be done afterwards (only if you want that of course).


Well I usually shoot in RAW but used JPG just to view the images on the screen, I only wanted to learn how to use the filter for my film cameras and doubt I'll use them on digital.

I'll have another go with a preset WB and see what happens. Thanks for the replies.


Reply

This appears to be similar to the problem when you shoot JPG and try to get Sunrise/set shots using the no flash setting. The camera software does it's very best to make the captured image look like daylight. Another reason to buy a bigger card and shoot RAW.


Reply

is it just my imagination, or has the first shot slightly more contrast?


Reply

greg wrote:
This appears to be similar to the problem when you shoot JPG and try to get Sunrise/set shots using the no flash setting. The camera software does it's very best to make the captured image look like daylight. Another reason to buy a bigger card and shoot RAW.


This is the 1st time I've used JPG since owning this camera. The reason I shot in JPG was to view them on screen straight away without having to convert them in RAW 1st and using the preset monochrome setting.

I've tried using a preset WB and it still makes no difference (apart from losing about 2/3 of a stop), so I'm quitting while I'm behind. Laughing

I'll try loading up a film camera and making a comparison. I think the 40D is too clever for its own good.


Reply

What I did in order to use my Yellow and Blue filter.
I shot in jpg w/o any filter on the lens and set my white balance to the type of day; e.g. Sunny, Shady, etc.

Then once It was close to what I was looking for on the white balance part, I would place the filter on my lens and take a shot in .RAW

If you use lightroom, remember to set your WB to what ever setting you had when you took the shot. That way it keeps the color of your filter.
Then set the mode to Monochrome.


Reply

My Pentax K20d and K200d actually have digital filters. The only filters that are of any practical value are polarizers and special effects filters.


Reply

OK, here is a little test that shows the effect of filters on a DSLR (Canon 5D2, jpgs with automatic white balance):

Here is the same book shot with a Zeiss Trioplan, once without a filter and then with a red 25A and a yellow Y2. Clearly, the DSLR's WB cannot compensate for the strong absorption of blue by the red filter, so the word people becomes almost invisible.

Converted using photoshop's simple desaturation control gives this:


But we are often told Channel Mixer is the best way to convert colour to B&W, so what happens if we desaturate with channel mixer's default of Red=100, Green=0 Blue=0?



The red lettering has completely disappeard in all versions, on the ordinary colour version white has become grey and the word "PEOPLE", has become white on a grey background.

I reduced the red to 54% and upped green and blue to 24% each to get this:


I hope that is of some interest. I think it's clear that colour filters do affect DSLRs and that channel mixer is a powerful, if difficult tool. Obviously, anybody who wants to can grab my top version and run channel mixer on it if they like.


Last edited by PaulC on Fri Sep 04, 2009 9:57 am; edited 1 time in total


Reply

Blue wrote:
My Pentax K20d and K200d actually have digital filters. The only filters that are of any practical value are polarizers and special effects filters.


Don't forget neutral density.


Reply

PaulC wrote:
Blue wrote:
My Pentax K20d and K200d actually have digital filters. The only filters that are of any practical value are polarizers and special effects filters.


Don't forget neutral density.


Indeed. Excellent examples Paul - thanks for that!!

Blue, you have never done serious scientific photography obviously or you would never have said that for sure. Wink Wink
Quote Mr Microsoft: "A computer will never need more than 64 kilobytes of memory".
I would be rather careful with absolute statements though...


Reply

kds315* wrote:
PaulC wrote:
Blue wrote:
My Pentax K20d and K200d actually have digital filters. The only filters that are of any practical value are polarizers and special effects filters.


Don't forget neutral density.


Indeed. Excellent examples Paul - thanks for that!!

Blue, you have never done serious scientific photography obviously or you would never have said that for sure. Wink Wink
Quote Mr Microsoft: "A computer will never need more than 64 kilobytes of memory".
I would be rather careful with absolute statements though...


You need to be careful about reading a lot into a single short sentence. I never made and absolute statement. The "special effects" apparently parted your hair.

Actually, I use my cameras mainly for scientific work frequently because I put my own presentations together. UV and Skylight filters still have practical value but they usually get overlooked even though sensors respond to UV light. I also had one save a lens from getting broken a couple of weeks ago. Regardless, I don't often whip out the 25a on my digital when doing macro of insects.

On a different note, I have worked with insect color response to traps and have an integrating sphere.


Reply

Well, even better then Blue that I was wrong with my assumption - let us see some of your works here if possible! I would be very curious, since that type of photography interests me a lot!!


Reply

kds315* wrote:
Well, even better then Blue that I was wrong with my assumption - let us see some of your works here if possible! I would be very curious, since that type of photography interests me a lot!!


I will post some of those images at some point. The problem with the color filters in digital bodies is that they require imaging in jpg and I prefer RAW. If I shoot B&W, I usually use film. One of the strengths with the Pentax dSLR is color out of the camera, hence I don't use filters for color correction. That's not to say I wouldn't use certain filters for certain effects.

To clarify what I meant earlier, I find polarizing filters, ND, UV, Skylight, etc. to be practical while many others are for more artistic purposes. For macro, I use no filter unless it is a situation where stuff may get on my lens.


Reply

martinsmith99 wrote:
I have a yellow filter (Hoya Y-K2) that I've just tried out on my Lydith, attached to a 40D.

Comparing the before and after filter images I really can't see any difference so I assume there is some digital wizardry compensating somewhere? Camera set to JPG and Monochrome.


Auto white balance?