MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Off camera flash -- why do they complicate things?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

In this topic I only refer to Canon bodies, Canon flashes and their way of communicating
on/off camera, master/slave, wired, IR or radio controlled.

If I use a Canon 580EX II on camera, it works beautifully as a master
and I can do lots of nice things with or without any slave flashes
(and this master does not even have to emit a flash itself if I don't want it to).

Obtaining an expensive flash cable (like an OC-E3), I can create
more interesting shadows by using the flash off camera, while
still having full E-TTL II capabilities. In this set-up, the master flash behaves
just like if it had been on camera and it can still handle any slaves
as well as groups of flashes.

But what if I want to be free of a cable? Oh, there are radio triggers, all right,
like PocketWizard and Phottix Odin. But then I would have to buy one trigger/receiver
for every flash I want to use, and that sounds like an unnecessary and a too complicated
way of handling things.

After all: all we really need is some sort of wireless connection between the camera
body and the master flash that mimics the cable -- and then let Canon's normal
way of handling signalling do its job.

Or am I totally off?


Reply

Is there full TTL capability for all flashes in a wired system?

A transmitter/receiver pair to reproduce the signals at each end of the cable. But that works only for one flash.


Reply

But my 580EX II would still be a master in my dream set-up,
even if the E-TTL cable has been changed into a radio/IR-link.


Reply

Dreams come true!

http://www.aokatec.com/


Reply

I just use the Canon ST-E2 transmitter to trigger a couple of 580exiis. Or a set of cheap Younnuo radio triggers if I want manual/auto control only with Nikon SB-28s.