MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

How does it come out?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I thought the glass would fairly easily come free from the lens mount after I removed the retaining ring but it doesn't want to budge at all. Is there an approved way of getting lenses out of such rings? It looks as if corrosion of the mount could be gripping it more tightly than desired (and, of course, I want to be able to get it back in afterwards). It isn't very big, either, about the size of the end of my thumb. Should I try WD 40, perhaps? There isn't any coating to worry about.





Reply

Some screw removal spray ? what is makes corrosion to liquid state ? and gently push after ...


Reply

It is rather unlikely that it screws apart - you'll often come across screw-in front elements with hidden (or missing) holes or slots, but on rear elements, function usually wins over (invisible) looks, and there almost always are slots or holes for a lens wrench if there is anything to screw apart.

My guess is that it is a flanged mount, with the flange driven over the glass on a turning lathe - these can only be separated by destroying one other of the parts, and if you really have to get at the glass, you'll need a identical spare mount to put it in for reassembly.

As far as the lens damage is concerned, it looks like plain separation to me - before you do anything more drastic, you should first try whether the cement will settle if you melt it. Slowly (over an hour or more) heat that group to the boiling point, leave it there for a day or two, and chill it again just as slow.


Reply

Do you mean the boiling point of water? If that would cure it, it would save a lot of bother (if it's even possible to do anything).

There was a screw inside the ring, which I took out. If the lens does come out, it can only escape from the recessed side on the top picture, not the side with the surface flush to the glass. Does that tell you anything about it?


Reply

PaulC wrote:
Do you mean the boiling point of water? If that would cure it, it would save a lot of bother (if it's even possible to do anything).


Try it. If there is enough cement inside, it may fix it. Of course, it might be a issue with cement loss/spill, if the camera was subjected to heat, so that there is not enough matter left to fill the gap by redistribution.

PaulC wrote:

There was a screw inside the ring, which I took out. If the lens does come out, it can only escape from the recessed side on the top picture, not the side with the surface flush to the glass. Does that tell you anything about it?


Well, if there was a lock ring screwed onto it, the lens ought to come out that way. It might be that the lens has simply glued itself into the ring thanks to spilled cement - warming it might release it. Try to heat it that side up first, and if that doesn't re-cement it try to push it out while still warm.


Reply

Ok, it's warming up in the biggest saucepan I've got. Hope this works. Thanks for the advice.


Reply

Overnight, the two lenses have separated. The rear one has come out of the holder, the other one is still fixed tight, which is great because the holder should hold them in place when I try sticking them back together (though I won't be able to wipe any surplus off the sides). So the water-bath trick worked, though not quite as hoped.

Most of the old glue seems to have washed off or disintegrated, I am trying to wash the rest off with nail varnish remover (hopefully it will contain acetone, which is given as a solvent for Canada balsam). It is difficult to see whether the lens surfaces are completely clean or not but what remains is slightly cloudy (only a fraction of what it was before, though).

Microwaving might be a possibility for the loose lens, I've read that this melts canada balsam without heating the glass.


Reply

I'd stay clear of microwaving, unless you have access to some industrial device. In household appliances, the field tends to come out very uneven, and you don't have much control over radiation power - the risk of punctual hotspots, which can crack a lens, is high.

Sevo


Reply

Ok. No microwaving then. Anyway, I managed to get some xylene from the country's scientific shop, so they are in that now which should shift anything shiftable.

I also got a completely dried up bottle of canada balsam which is probably useless but might become usable after being topped up with xylene for a while. Not sure what else I can get to fix them back together. Maybe the university will have something they would let me have.

Or should I just put the back lens back in and screw in the ring well in behind it until I can get a proper, modern cement? How much difference will it make to the image quality not having them cemented together?


Reply

PaulC wrote:


I also got a completely dried up bottle of canada balsam which is probably useless but might become usable after being topped up with xylene for a while.


Don't put xylene into it! It is actually a very lucky accident - you need dry canada balsam to cement lenses, and usually it takes weeks to let the turpentine spirit from the commonly available liquid canada balsam evaporate in a dust-free environment.

Sevo


Reply

Ooops! Well, only the surface of it had dissolved. I guess it won't take long for the rest of it to evaporate (I've got a lint-free cloth over it now). It was one rock solid lump, though. How can you work with that?

Both the lenses are much better now but one has faint misty traces from where the old glue was and nothing seems to shift them; they are invisible from straight on but I can see them when I view it at an angle through a lens. I guess a rear-lens problem is bound to affect IQ.

For the time being, I have screwed everything back together without any attempt to glue it (pics below), at least it is in a stable state. More than 99% of the crud must have gone and I can get things in focus looking through the camera.

Here are shots of the lens, taken in the same lighting conditions as the previous ones:



[img]


As you can see, the marks are no longer visible[/img]