| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
stevemark
 Joined: 29 Apr 2011 Posts: 5509 Location: Switzerland
|
 Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2026 11:08 pm Post subject: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
 Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2026 11:08 pm Post subject: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
The last series of Mamiya lenses for 35mm format SLRs didn't have as many primes as the previous Sekor CS series (mainly the 14mm Fisheyer as well as the 21mm superwide were missing), but it did contain a new 200mm lens not taken over from the previous CS line: the Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm.
The lens was my first ever 200mm tele (I bought it when I was about 16 years old), and pretty soon I was aware of its qualities. Slides shot with Kodachrome 64 or even Kodachrome 25 had an excellent detail resolution, even at f4.
Two years later (an eternity at that age ...) I changed from Mamiya SLRs to the then new Minolta 9000, and after I got the Minolta AF APO 2.8/200mm lens I gifted the Sekor E 4/200 to a highschool classmate.
About 15 years ago I got a whole lot of Mamiya ZE/ZM SLRs plus a lot of Sekor E lenses, including a 4/200mm. Testing it on 24MP FF resulted in a bit of disapointment: This second copy didn't live to my expectations - but maybe I simply had overestimated the properties of my first copy ?!?
A few days ago I got my third sample - and voilà, here it was again: The excellent performance I had missed on my second copy ...!
I knew from previous test of ten Sekor E 3.5/135mm lenses that Mamiya didn't have the quality control I was used to from Minolta. In other words: The "variable" performance of Sekor E lenses is a real thing, and one must be aware of that when buying these lenses (I also have a Sekor E 2.8/28mm which is nowhere nearly as good as my Sekor CS 2.8/28mm which should have the same optical formula). On the other hand the Sekor EF 1.4/50mm and Sekor E 3.5/50mm lenses are clearly better the corresponding Sekor CS copies I own
As you can see the image quality of the good sample is remarkable, and - apart from vignetting - exactly the same from f4 to f11. It's certainly on par with the the best 4/200mm from Canon, Leitz (4/180mm), Minolta, Nikon and Olympus - and maybe even a tad better.
CLICK TWICE AND DOWNLOAD THE ORIGINAL 1200 X 1700 px FILE, AND LOOK AT IT IN A STANDALON SOFTWARE SUCH AS PHOTOSHOP!
The lens itself is made from metal, but at 405g (without caps) not overlay heavy. And it looks quite nice!
Now that I have a good copy of the Sekor E 4/200mm I'm looking forward to a "slow 200mm test", including lenses such as ...
* Canon FD 4/200mm
* Canon nFD 4/200mm IF
* Konica Hexanon 4/200mm
* Leitz Tele Elmar 4/180mm
* Minolta Rokkor MC-X 4/200mm
* Minolta Rokkor MD-II 4/200mm
* Nikon Nikkor Ai 4/200mm
* Olympus Zuiko OM 4/200mm
* Pentacon (Meyer Görlitz) 4/200mm
* Pentax M 4/200mm
* Yashica ML 4/200mm C
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3912 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2026 7:54 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2026 7:54 am Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
See if you can include either a S-M-C Takumar 200mm f/4 or its SMC Pentax version. I always thought this lens was quite good. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
kiddo
 Joined: 29 Jun 2018 Posts: 1630
|
 Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2026 8:19 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2026 8:19 am Post subject: |
|
|
kiddo wrote:
Interested to see the Mamiya EF zoom 80-200mm thrown in there, as thy share same aperture |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Doc Sharptail
 Joined: 23 Nov 2020 Posts: 1504 Location: Winnipeg Canada
|
 Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2026 2:46 pm Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
 Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2026 2:46 pm Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
|
Doc Sharptail wrote:
| stevemark wrote: |
* Nikon Nikkor Ai 4/200mm
S |
I had the A/I 200 f4 and liked it, despite the lagging aperture blades.
The text in the first post touches on sample variation, which almost no one was immune from.
I may be taking a chance soon on a lens with a troubled sample variation history- A series 1 28-80 f2.8-3.8.
-D.S. _________________
D-810, F2, FTN, FT-3 in Black
35mm f2 O.C. nikkor
50 f2 H nikkor, 50 f2 H.C. nikkor, 50 f 1.4 AI-s, 135 f3.5 Q,
50 f2 K nikkor 2x, 28-85mm f3.5-4.5 A/I-s, 35-105 3.5-4.5 A/I-s, 200mm f4 Micro A/I, partial list.
"Ain't no half-way" -S.R.V.
"Oh Yeah... Alright" -Paul Simon |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
stevemark
 Joined: 29 Apr 2011 Posts: 5509 Location: Switzerland
|
 Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2026 6:27 pm Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
 Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2026 6:27 pm Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| caspert79 wrote: |
| See if you can include either a S-M-C Takumar 200mm f/4 or its SMC Pentax version. I always thought this lens was quite good. |
Yep, I happen to have one ... got from a photo store in the countryside a few years ago for CHF 10.--
| kiddo wrote: |
| Interested to see the Mamiya EF zoom 80-200mm thrown in there, as thy share same aperture |
Yeah, can be done
| Doc Sharptail wrote: |
The text in the first post touches on sample variation, which almost no one was immune from.
|
That's a problem whenever one's doing lens tests. I have run a few larger comparisons on 24 MP FF with Minolta primes (MD-III 1.7/50mm, eleven samples, one slight deviation found) and zoom lenses (MD 3.5/35-70mm, seven samples; Minolta AF 4-4.5/28-135mm, seven samples; no variations found) and Mamyia Sekor E primes (1.7/50 and 3.5/135 and 3.5/28 with eight samples each). The Mamyias were far less consistent than the Minoltas, but not deviating as dramatic as the two samples of the sekor E 4/200 shown above.
Since I have at least two sample from nearly 50 Minolta MF lenses I'm pretty confident about thesting them. As far as I remember there were only two outliers - an early MC-X 2.8/135 which was so completly "off" that something must have gone wrong after it left the factory (completely unsharp also at f11, probably an inversed lens in the rear part) and one MD-III 4.5/75-200 that wasn't as good as the other fours samples I own.
That said, I have several copies of most Konica lenses (usually two or three, occasionally four or six), but also "doubles" of ten or so Canon FD and fifteen Nikkor lenses. The Konica primes are pretty consistent too, but some of their zooms (including the huge 3.5/80-200) have wild variations.
| Doc Sharptail wrote: |
I may be taking a chance soon on a lens with a troubled sample variation history- A series 1 28-80 f2.8-3.8.
|
I'm not aware of such a lens - there's the
* Vivitar 2.8-3.8/28-85mm (not a "Series 1")
* Vivitar Series 1 2.8-3.5/28-90mm
* Vivitar Series 1 2.8-3.8/28-105mm
Which one do you mean?
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Alsatian2017
 Joined: 05 Mar 2018 Posts: 293
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 10:32 am Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 10:32 am Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
|
Alsatian2017 wrote:
| stevemark wrote: |
A few days ago I got my third sample - and voilà, here it was again: The excellent performance I had missed on my second copy ...!
I knew from previous test of ten Sekor E 3.5/135mm lenses that Mamiya didn't have the quality control I was used to from Minolta. In other words: The "variable" performance of Sekor E lenses is a real thing, and one must be aware of that when buying these lenses (I also have a Sekor E 2.8/28mm which is nowhere nearly as good as my Sekor CS 2.8/28mm which should have the same optical formula). On the other hand the Sekor EF 1.4/50mm and Sekor E 3.5/50mm lenses are clearly better the corresponding Sekor CS copies I own
As you can see the image quality of the good sample is remarkable, and - apart from vignetting - exactly the same from f4 to f11. It's certainly on par with the the best 4/200mm from Canon, Leitz (4/180mm), Minolta, Nikon and Olympus - and maybe even a tad better.
S |
Recently, I've been testing a bunch of Mamiya Sekor E lenses and I was very surprised by the optical quality they provide. While I very much like the performance of my Sekor E 28 mm f/2,8, 28-50 mm f/3,5-4,5, 50 mm f/1,7 and 80-200 mm f/3,8 lenses, I was stunned by the IQ of the E 200 mm f/4 which is nicely small and light as well.
Following are some quick samples I produced this spring ( Sony A7RII) :
#1
#2
#3
#4
#5
#6
#7
#8
#9
#10
#11
#12
The lens is fully useable wide open with 42 megapixel sensors and has consistently sharp image borders and corners with moderate and easy to correct chromatic aberrations. Among my dozen or so 200 mm f/4 and f/3,5 lenses it is among the top performers. Note that my SX 200 mm f/3,5 which was reissued in CS livery doesn't impress me.
Greetings
Volker _________________ Personal website : https://volkergilbertphoto.com
Classic lenses : https://volkergilbertphoto.com/objektive/
Adobe Lens Correction profiles :
https://volkergilbertphoto.com/adobe-lens-profiles-for-classic-lenses/
Instagram : https://www.instagram.com/volker.gilbert/ |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Doc Sharptail
 Joined: 23 Nov 2020 Posts: 1504 Location: Winnipeg Canada
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:46 am Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 11:46 am Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
|
Doc Sharptail wrote:
| stevemark wrote: |
| Doc Sharptail wrote: |
I may be taking a chance soon on a lens with a troubled sample variation history- A series 1 28-80 f2.8-3.8.
|
I'm not aware of such a lens - there's the
* Vivitar 2.8-3.8/28-85mm (not a "Series 1")
* Vivitar Series 1 2.8-3.5/28-90mm
* Vivitar Series 1 2.8-3.8/28-105mm
Which one do you mean?
S |
It is the 28-85 2.8-3.8, and is listed on some review sites as a series 1.
I thought it odd, since there's no series 1 on the name ring in the seller's photo.
Still on the fence about the purchase. There's a lot of stuff sitting here again not being used, but curiosity is becoming a hard to reach itch to scratch.
-D.S. _________________
D-810, F2, FTN, FT-3 in Black
35mm f2 O.C. nikkor
50 f2 H nikkor, 50 f2 H.C. nikkor, 50 f 1.4 AI-s, 135 f3.5 Q,
50 f2 K nikkor 2x, 28-85mm f3.5-4.5 A/I-s, 35-105 3.5-4.5 A/I-s, 200mm f4 Micro A/I, partial list.
"Ain't no half-way" -S.R.V.
"Oh Yeah... Alright" -Paul Simon |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3912 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 6:25 pm Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 6:25 pm Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| Alsatian2017 wrote: |
Recently, I've been testing a bunch of Mamiya Sekor E lenses and I was very surprised by the optical quality they provide. While I very much like the performance of my Sekor E 28 mm f/2,8, 28-50 mm f/3,5-4,5, 50 mm f/1,7 and 80-200 mm f/3,8 lenses, I was stunned by the IQ of the E 200 mm f/4 which is nicely small and light as well.
|
Nice images indeed!
I have the 28/2.8, 50/1.7, 50/1.4 and 50/3.5 macro and they’re all nice lenses. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
stevemark
 Joined: 29 Apr 2011 Posts: 5509 Location: Switzerland
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 6:54 pm Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 6:54 pm Post subject: Re: Mamiya Sekor E 4/200mm |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| Alsatian2017 wrote: |
Recently, I've been testing a bunch of Mamiya Sekor E lenses and ... I was stunned by the IQ of the E 200 mm f/4 which is nicely small and light as well.
...
The lens is fully useable wide open with 42 megapixel sensors and has consistently sharp image borders and corners with moderate and easy to correct chromatic aberrations. Among my dozen or so 200 mm f/4 and f/3,5 lenses it is among the top performers. Note that my SX 200 mm f/3,5 which was reissued in CS livery doesn't impress me.
|
Thank you for sharing these images! It's good to know that the Sekor E 4/200mm is uesable even on 43 MP FF cameras - I hadn't tried that yet ... The Mamiya Sekor SX/CS 3.5/200mm certainly has completely different characteristics; lots of detail as well (even at f3.5), but too much longitudianal CAs and therefore pretty soft overall plus an annoying amount of purple fringing visible even with "ordinary" subjects (not necessarily high contrast).
| Doc Sharptail wrote: |
It is the 28-85 2.8-3.8, and is listed on some review sites as a series 1.
...
Still on the fence about the purchase. There's a lot of stuff sitting here again not being used, but curiosity is becoming a hard to reach itch to scratch.
-D.S. |
Curiosity in itself is a valid reason - as long as the lens isn't too expensive of course ... Once curiosity vanishes one is getting old !
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3912 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 7:43 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 7:43 pm Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
Just bought me an E 200/4 from Ebay because it was cheap. Hopefully a good sample! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
stevemark
 Joined: 29 Apr 2011 Posts: 5509 Location: Switzerland
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 8:24 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2026 8:24 pm Post subject: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| caspert79 wrote: |
| Just bought me an E 200/4 from Ebay because it was cheap. Hopefully a good sample! |
That will be interesting to see ...!!
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|