MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

My first scans; please examine and advise
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Here is a three-way comparison:

drugstore scan, PP'd in photobucket:


V300 scan at 8 bit, 2400, autofix in photobucket:


v300 scan at 16 bit, 3200, autofix in photobucket:


Advice? I think it is obvious the drugstore scan is sharper, and I know the Epson neg holder is not well-regarded. different holder to sharpen things up? Change settings on the scanner? I used professional mode ...


Last edited by fish4570 on Wed Jun 23, 2010 4:34 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

Here are some scans from my first roll of self-developed Tri-X. I think I shorted the development time, or my thermometer is off. The negs look a little thin.
Scanned at 8 bit, 2400:



On this shot, I was focused on the rock.




Other than hitting development right on, what do I need to do with my scanning? Other than brush lint from the negatives ... Rolling Eyes I used professional mode, jpeg.


Reply

Hm.. they doesn't look in focus .. is the film flat?

The film should be placed with the clear side down.

in scanning software turn off everything (except of digital ice if it's a c41 film)

You can try to place it on the scanner with no holder and put a piece of glass on top of it ( for example from a photo frame ) this should keep it flat.

If it's still that bad maybe it's a better idea to return it and scan at your drug store. looks that they have a very nice unit.


Reply

The drug store is incredibly hit and miss. I hope it is a matter of flatness and my own idiocy in figuring out how to get the best out of the machine.


Reply

Since you don't have a lot of PP tools, try scanning with USM set to Medium,
and scan with 16 bit grayscale selected. Scan the neg with bowed side UP,
not down. You can flip it in Irfanview (free download) if you have to.


Reply

trying bow side up right now. i didn't see anything marked USM ...


Reply

fish4570 wrote:
trying bow side up right now. i didn't see anything marked USM ...


If you're scanning in Professional Mode, there should be a USM box to
check/uncheck with settings Low, Medium, High.


Reply

maybe he Katastrofo means unsharp mask - sharpening to medium.

but it's better if sharpening and grain reduction is turned off..you can do sharpening later in photoshop or lightroom.


Reply

Katastrofo wrote:
Since you don't have a lot of PP tools, try scanning with USM set to Medium,
and scan with 16 bit grayscale selected. Scan the neg with bowed side UP,
not down. You can flip it in Irfanview (free download) if you have to.


USM = sharpening at V300 I think.

Iron with heavy books all strip for hours before scan. Scan to .tiff instead of jpg , tiff basically a RAW file so most image manipulation will works better than on .jpg. If you need more sharpness than scanner did it, you can finish it with better tools like Photoshop or Acdsee pro.


Reply

bowed side down:



bowed side up and flipped:



Reply

std wrote:
maybe he Katastrofo means unsharp mask - sharpening to medium.

but it's better if sharpening and grain reduction is turned off..you can do sharpening later in photoshop or lightroom.


Agree, better to having everything off, but I don't know how great the
sharpening tools he has in his software. Was something to try at any
rate.


Reply

OK, I do have the mask thingie. I will try that one time.


Reply

There is a little more detail in the flipped version, look at the piling in the
foreground, more shadow detail. These could still be sharper, though.

EDIT: actually, they look pretty much the same. These scans are back in
the days when I had USM set to low:



Gives OK results for web use. Nowadays I have everything turned off, just
straight scan.


Reply

I am having trouble uploading to photobucket now. I will get back with you guys.


Reply

Here is an image from my first roll of self-developed TriX, scanned by me, optimized in photoshop:



Reply

Given software default settings I'm guessing the image that had to be flipped was scanned upside down.

dMax is scanner term for contrast dynamic range. The drug store scanner looks like it has a bigger number dMax than V300.

Any case, scanner dMax doesn't approach C41/E6 color film dynamic range, much less B&W.

I think an acceptable HDR image can be constructed from 2 or 3 scans at different brightness levels, or layered. Stitch software might work best to get perfect pixel-level alignment of separate scans; pixels are likely much smaller than mechanical scan tolerances. When I haul out the V500 next I'll be trying this with 6x7! Very Happy

Simply moving the grey-point slider in PP Levels to the right should make a scan closer to drug store scan brightness, stretch out the range of blacks. Any Curves Experts Laughing here might suggest adjustments for best results; somebody might already have made a Curve for correcting this scanner results with this particular film.


Reply

I wasted a couple of hours this afternoon trying to upload photoshopped versions of a couple of my scans to photobucket. I couldn't figure out why. But my lovely, right-brained bride took about, oh, 4 minutes to find out the bucket does not accept tiffs.
Therefore, I opened a pro Flickr account. I'll see what I can do with that tomorrow morning ...