MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

50mm thoughts
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Many here probably have lots of 50-58mm lenses. I do and love the FL and have been thinking about my own use of it and come to a conclusion that I can scale down my collection based on categories of use.

This system can of course be used both to increase or decrease your collection.

You could make it easy and just sell the lenses you don't use much. But keeping at least one for every given task is my idea.

And the tasks or categories can overlap so this means the collection could be decreased even more if needed.


Here are my categories:


Portraits. In my case I don't think it needs to be expanded to full body/torso/dogs. My picks works well for all types.

Bokeh. This one has to be expanded it's probably my favorite. In my case bubble, smooth, very thin, character and elegant/refined.

3D pop. If you can't see it skip this point. Here I'd actually like to get one, the ZM Planar 50mm f2.

Landscape. Edge to edge sharpness. Only one should be enough.

Low light. Not sure if this one is needed.

Macro. I like to combine it with bokeh and have found the Rodagon 50mm f2.8 to be excellent at both sharpness and bokeh smoothness and elegance.
For macro experts I can images several lenses are needed, please share what you think about that.


What do you think, unnecessary or maybe useful?


Reply

For me , the Topcor 58mm 1.4 has no substitute on portraits (I don't have any 1.2), so is FD 1.4 ,but there's huge difference in FL between the two of them, besides the number of aperture blades , which I consider very important stoping down. For a vintage look there's the Septon , I could definitely get rid (should) of some of the 50's . Lately , for portraits I prefer fast 100-200mm FL whenever there's enough space , followed by 80-100mm and last would be the 50's indoors and close distance basically.
Mostly, for portraits I shoot wide open and have no problem with the softer look (some cases I'm using soft filters) ,but I'm not a pro shooter where clients would have their own demanding standards. (Definitely prepared models etc)
Macro 50's I do have few of them, but they don't fit on the same standards for portraits, maybe ML would be enough though.
I have a hard time getting rid of lenses, but I don't buy too many nowadays, only some specific ones (weird ones).


Reply

Maybe adding a category for "character" might go well for special lenses with vintage look.

Sticking to the aforementioned categories, adding personal favourites might be insightful.

Mine

Portraits: Super Takumar 55 1.8

Bokeh: Konica Hexanon 57 1.4

3D Pop: CV Nokton 58 1.4

Landscape: Minolta 50 f2 MDIII

Character: MOG Oreston 50 1.8 / Jupiter 8 50 f2

Macro: No special lens for this one.


Reply

kiddo wrote:
For me , the Topcor 58mm 1.4 has no substitute on portraits (I don't have any 1.2), so is FD 1.4 ,but there's huge difference in FL between the two of them, besides the number of aperture blades , which I consider very important stoping down. For a vintage look there's the Septon , I could definitely get rid (should) of some of the 50's . Lately , for portraits I prefer fast 100-200mm FL whenever there's enough space , followed by 80-100mm and last would be the 50's indoors and close distance basically.
Mostly, for portraits I shoot wide open and have no problem with the softer look (some cases I'm using soft filters) ,but I'm not a pro shooter where clients would have their own demanding standards. (Definitely prepared models etc)
Macro 50's I do have few of them, but they don't fit on the same standards for portraits, maybe ML would be enough though.
I have a hard time getting rid of lenses, but I don't buy too many nowadays, only some specific ones (weird ones).


The Topcor seems like a very fine lens, I've never had a chance to try it. My top options are the MC Rokkor 58mm f1.2 or C/Y Planar 50mm f1.4.

Yes longer lenses are a good choice. What is ML in the macro answer?


Reply

For those interested in reliable information about the bokeh of nromal lenses:

http://www.artaphot.ch/systemuebergreifend/objektive/477-standard-lens-bokeh-i (fast lenses in the 55mm to 60mm range)
http://www.artaphot.ch/systemuebergreifend/objektive/479-standard-lens-bokeh-ii (fast 55mm lenses)
http://www.artaphot.ch/systemuebergreifend/objektive/480-standard-lens-bokeh-iii (slower normal lenses)

Always interesting to compare the claimed properties of a lens with actual images ...

S

EDIT

There's also the handling! Some MF lenses are pretty awkward to unse, other are much more fun.


Reply

pabeu wrote:
Maybe adding a category for "character" might go well for special lenses with vintage look.

Sticking to the aforementioned categories, adding personal favourites might be insightful.

Mine

Portraits: Super Takumar 55 1.8

Bokeh: Konica Hexanon 57 1.4

3D Pop: CV Nokton 58 1.4

Landscape: Minolta 50 f2 MDIII

Character: MOG Oreston 50 1.8 / Jupiter 8 50 f2

Macro: No special lens for this one.


You are right character is more than bokeh where I put it! Good choice for 3D pop. I've seen really good samples.
After posting I thought about adding "gives you joy" that can be an alternative to personal favorits. I would add to many to favorites Very Happy


My full list:
Portraits: MC Rokkor 58mm f1.2 non PG, C/Y Planar 50mm f1.4, Rollei Planar 50mm f1.8.

Bokeh: MC Rokkor 58mm f1.2, C/Y Planar 50mm f1.4, Auto Yashinon 5cm f2

Landscape: C/Y Planar 50mm f1.4 or MC Zuiko 50mm f1.4.

Character: MOG Oreston 50mm f1.8, MOG Domiron 50mm f2. RE GN Topcor-M 50mm f1.4.

3D Pop: C/Y Planar 50mm f1.4

Macro: Rodenstock Rodagon 50mm f2.8, For ultimate performance I would try to find a APO Rodagon. One of the best on that go-to macro photo site I forgot the name.



If I only kept those I had to get rid of many many lenses!


Reply

stevemark wrote:
For those interested in reliable information about the bokeh of nromal lenses:

http://www.artaphot.ch/systemuebergreifend/objektive/477-standard-lens-bokeh-i (fast lenses in the 55mm to 60mm range)
http://www.artaphot.ch/systemuebergreifend/objektive/479-standard-lens-bokeh-ii (fast 55mm lenses)
http://www.artaphot.ch/systemuebergreifend/objektive/480-standard-lens-bokeh-iii (slower normal lenses)

Always interesting to compare the claimed properties of a lens with actual images ...

S

EDIT

There's also the handling! Some MF lenses are pretty awkward to unse, other are much more fun.


That is a great resource! I have looked at it many times and helped me choose a MC Rokkor 58mm f1.2.

handling Yes very important! Fortunately for me I think all of my other choices would fulfill this one. Most but not all of my issues comes from old grease or other defects rather than poor design. But the Helios 103 and Jupiter 8M are not very pleasant to use.


Reply

Excellent work Steve, your tests definitely can help many people choose a specific lens or not. I had the c/y planar 1.4 but once I got the topcor, I felt more comfortable with this focal length and results so it had to go. I also have the older version of the topcor 1.8 version, never did a comparison between them , but I did like the results from it. I did notice huge difference from 50 to 58mm on FL and image background etc, of course the fast 85mm would beat most of the 50's for portraits , as much as I lately prefer 100-200mm FL for this field . Many of the 50mm lenses are pretty cheap nowadays , in many cases results come very close to the expensive ones, petri 55mm 1.8 it's a nice one also, but I had no time to use it yet (rokkkor 55mm 1.7 is another smooth one that comes very cheap with vintage look). If I'd have to stick with 4 lenses on this FL for portraits it would be Topcor 1.4 (FD black nose 1.4 next ) , landscapes mamiya ze (in my case revuenon) and for macro Yashica ML (as being the smallest and lighter), for character the Septon. I don't know why but the 50mm PG Minolta 1.4 just doesn't convince me ,maybe it deserves some more attention.


Reply

OK. Here's my list. Images are clickable for full size.

Portraits/ smooth bokeh: I put these categories together, because in case of portraits, I will usually go for a lens with nice soft bokeh. Lenses with a particular bokeh, I will place under the category 'character.'
One of my absolute favourites is the Auto Rokkor-PF 55mm f/2,

AutoRokkorPF55mmf2444 by devoscasper, on Flickr

RokkorPF55f2382 by devoscasper, on Flickr

I like the Pentax-M 50mm f/1.7 as well:
PentaxM5017169 by devoscasper, on Flickr

And the Petri 55mm f/1.4:
Petri5514_6 by devoscasper, on Flickr

3D pop. Hard to define this exactly, but here two lenses that have a particular 3D quality in my subjective opinion:

Pentax-M 50mm f/1.7:
PentaxM5017DSC09978 by devoscasper, on Flickr

Or the Mamiya Sekor 55mm f/1.8:
AutoMamiyaSekor5518DSC08216 by devoscasper, on Flickr

Landscape.
When it comes to corner-to-corner sharpess, the Petri CC 55mm f/1.8 is one of the best. Already very good corners @ f/2.8 on a 42.6mp sensor, and perfect @f/4. Check out in this comparison:
comparisonA by devoscasper, on Flickr

The Minolta MD 50mm f/2 is another contender. It needs a bit more stopping down, but handles flare better, and shows less spherical aberration wide open.
The Rikenon XR 50mm f/2, another very sharp lens, but just like the Petri it has quite a bit of spherical aberrations wide open. The Zuiko 50mm f/1.4 I had (latest version) did also a really good job as a landscape lens, but is not that great for close by subjects (needs 2 stops stopping down for sharpness).

Low light.
Mamiya EF 50mm f/1.4. Just a great performer (in different ways). One of the very few real fast 50's that's actually sharp wide open.

DSC03431 by devoscasper, on Flickr

Mamiyaportret1447 by devoscasper, on Flickr

Macro

Yashica ML 55mm f/2.8 macro. Does an excellent job at all distances. Reaches very good corner sharpness @ f/2.8 and perfect corner-to-corner sharpness on 40.6mp sensor @ f/4, close by and @infinity. Small lens, handling very good. Good bokeh as well. Very sharp wide open.

YashicaML5528macro_5 by devoscasper, on Flickr

Comparison4 by devoscasper, on Flickr

Character
Ultra subjective of course, but I really do like the Auto Yashinon 5cm f/2:
DSC02792 by devoscasper, on Flickr
DSC01930bw by devoscasper, on Flickr

The Yashinon 5.5cm f/1.8 does a good job as well IMO:
DSC01198w by devoscasper, on Flickr


Reply

Very valuable information Caspert, many thanks - we could add night photography and flares group, both of them difficult field for vintage lenses , but some are better than others and very different


Reply

kiddo wrote:
Very valuable information Caspert, many thanks - we could add night photography and flares group, both of them difficult field for vintage lenses , but some are better than others and very different


Yeah that would be good, but most lenses i haven’t tested for that.


Reply

caspert79 wrote:
kiddo wrote:
Very valuable information Caspert, many thanks - we could add night photography and flares group, both of them difficult field for vintage lenses , but some are better than others and very different


Yeah that would be good, but most lenses i haven’t tested for that.


Have you tried the Nikkor-H (or HC) 50mm f/2? Curious how it'd stack up to something like your Auto Rokkor-PF 55mm f/2, Minolta MD 50mm f/2, .Rikenon XR 50mm f/2. IIRC those Nikkors don't have the smoothest bokeh though.


Reply

A modern manual focus lens Meike 50/1.7 with a 6/5 double Gauss optical scheme. I ordered it, but it never arrived.)


Reply

DaveNJ wrote:

Have you tried the Nikkor-H (or HC) 50mm f/2? Curious how it'd stack up to something like your Auto Rokkor-PF 55mm f/2, Minolta MD 50mm f/2, .Rikenon XR 50mm f/2. IIRC those Nikkors don't have the smoothest bokeh though.


While I don't have the Auto Rokkor 2/55mm, I have been using the Nikkor H/HC 2/50mm, the Minolta MD-i and MD-III 2/50mm (not the same computation!!), and the Rikenon.

I really like the Nikkor for its low contrast / vintage look at f2, and its high performance stopped down tp f5.6 or f8. Unmlie wome other vintage nromal lenses, the aberrations of the Nikkor are well balanced, resulting in a pretty uniform rendering over the entire frame. That results in much nicer images than, say, a lens a with good center sharpness and lost of astigmatism.

S


Reply

The Zenitar-M 50mm 1:1.7 would probably tick all boxes.


Reply

stevemark wrote:
DaveNJ wrote:

Have you tried the Nikkor-H (or HC) 50mm f/2? Curious how it'd stack up to something like your Auto Rokkor-PF 55mm f/2, Minolta MD 50mm f/2, .Rikenon XR 50mm f/2. IIRC those Nikkors don't have the smoothest bokeh though.


While I don't have the Auto Rokkor 2/55mm, I have been using the Nikkor H/HC 2/50mm, the Minolta MD-i and MD-III 2/50mm (not the same computation!!), and the Rikenon.

I really like the Nikkor for its low contrast / vintage look at f2, and its high performance stopped down tp f5.6 or f8. Unmlie wome other vintage nromal lenses, the aberrations of the Nikkor are well balanced, resulting in a pretty uniform rendering over the entire frame. That results in much nicer images than, say, a lens a with good center sharpness and lost of astigmatism.

S


Thank you for the comparison. That vintage look wide open and modern-esque stopped down performance is appealing. I do recall reading the Nikkor-H (HC) 50/2 is one of Nikons sharpest old 50s.


Reply

D1N0 wrote:
The Zenitar-M 50mm 1:1.7 would probably tick all boxes.


I tried it, but I don’t think it was better then let’s say, the Pentax-M 50mm f/1.7 (which is a good lens btw).


Reply

caspert79 wrote:
D1N0 wrote:
The Zenitar-M 50mm 1:1.7 would probably tick all boxes.


I tried it, but I don’t think it was better then let’s say, the Pentax-M 50mm f/1.7 (which is a good lens btw).


I have both, I think the Zenitar has a bit more air. Pixie dust.

Pentax-M
Mr Wonky ear by The lens profile, on Flickr

Zenitar
Wonky by The lens profile, on Flickr


Reply

D1N0 wrote:
caspert79 wrote:
D1N0 wrote:
The Zenitar-M 50mm 1:1.7 would probably tick all boxes.


I tried it, but I don’t think it was better then let’s say, the Pentax-M 50mm f/1.7 (which is a good lens btw).


I have both, I think the Zenitar has a bit more air. Pixie dust.

Pentax-M
Mr Wonky ear by The lens profile, on Flickr

Zenitar
Wonky by The lens profile, on Flickr


They look both really good if you’d ask me. Here’s a little comparison I did a while ago that I almost forgot about:
https://forum.mflenses.com/zenitar-m-50mm-f-1-7-and-comparison-t84842.html

By the way, the Mamiya Sekor EF 50/1.7 is also a great performer. Build quality not on par with the Pentax though.


Reply

the pentax m 1.7 is crazy sharp, wow - cannot imagine it on the portraits i`m shooting lol


Reply

It's really a lens that doesn't get the recognition it deserves. I had one lying around on an old K1000 when I purchased my first Pentax DSLR (a K5), and the first time I tried it on digital, my jaw hit the floor.

Its combination of sharpness and contrastiness makes it a bit less useful for "flattering" portraiture than some of the other lenses mentioned in this thread, but it's definitely a lens worth having in one's kit and typically available at bargain prices.

kiddo wrote:
the pentax m 1.7 is crazy sharp, wow - cannot imagine it on the portraits i`m shooting lol


Last edited by BrianSVP on Tue Dec 31, 2024 1:25 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

stevemark wrote:

I really like the Nikkor for its low contrast / vintage look at f2, and its high performance stopped down tp f5.6 or f8. Unmlie wome other vintage nromal lenses, the aberrations of the Nikkor are well balanced, resulting in a pretty uniform rendering over the entire frame. That results in much nicer images than, say, a lens a with good center sharpness and lost of astigmatism.

S


Could be some sample variation here, but I haven't really noticed it in the "H" series in regards to contrast.
I usually shoot mine with an L-37-C filter, but I doubt that filter does much for contrast.
I find contrast to be almost normal with mine-it's just very slightly low in that regard, and quite easily correctable.

The old "H" has another attribute not yet mentioned in this thread- handling, and speed of use.
I find mine a bit smaller than the later K based f2 variants, and very fast to focus.
There were some pro's around here that refused to go to the "K" and later f2's over the longer focus throw.
The "H" and "H.C." are personal favorites with me.
It behaves well on extension tubes up to about 1:1 magnification, and I usually don't need more than that.

The other favorite of mine is the Nikkor A/I-s 50mm f1.4.
This one starts 3-d popping around f4-f5.6 on the D-810, and really likes f8. It's minimum focus distance is a joy to use as well, with not quite noisy bokeh that close in. Oddly enough, I find the wide open performance a bit on the "meh" side- it ghosts a bit wide open on high contrast subjects. The old "S" 1.4 is just slightly better in terms of ghosting, but not by a whole lot.

Back to the "H" for a minute- it's very interesting reversed on a bellows- despite the rapid fall-off, the images have an interesting, almost character quality...

-D.S.


Reply

BrianSVP wrote:
It's really a lens that doesn't get the recognition it deserves. I had one lying around on an old K1000 when I purchased my first Pentax DSLR (a K5), and the first time I tried it on digital, my jar hit the floor.

Its combination of sharpness and contrastiness makes it a bit less useful for "flattering" portraiture than some of the other lenses mentioned in this thread, but it's definitely a lens worth having in one's kit and typically available at bargain prices.

kiddo wrote:
the pentax m 1.7 is crazy sharp, wow - cannot imagine it on the portraits i`m shooting lol


Looks great! Probably beats the MD Rokkor 50mm f1.7 that I have.

When it comes to these classic lenses I don't think any of them are too contrasty or clinical to make unflattering portraits.

MD Rokkor 50mm f1.7


Bigger version.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/190847005@N02/53303066798/in/dateposted-public/


Reply

Definitely a good bokeh lens


Reply

Fifties are inevitable. On a recent second hand vintage market I had to resist some of them as they have a tendency to pile up like nothing.

Pentax K 50mm 1.2





I also use Zenitar 50mm f1.7 which is exceptionally sharp lens wide open. I own Pentax M 1.7 as well. Russian lens has better bokeh and is sharper. Sometimes I shoot Helios 44-2 or 44-4m. Both are nice. My Pentax FA 50mm f1.4 is rarely used as I prefer manual lenses. I rarely used Industar 50-2 50mm f3.5 which is the smallest lens I own.