MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Planning: Youtube channel for old German Lenses
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Hi all,

has been a while since I've posted here. During the past several years I collected a wide range of Meyer, Zeiss, Schneider, Isco and other German lenses ranging from 1930 - 1970. Might have around 100+ by now and I am still not done collecting.

I just wanted to test the waters if there is demand for videos on those lenses consisting of

1.) review and info of the lens
2.) real life video footage (apsc + fullframe)
3.) real life still images
4.) Comparisons

"Normal" videos, without that annoying 'hype' that some youtubers do. Just a channel for people who want to know more about (mostly German) old lenses and cameras (mainly Exakta as they are the focus of my collection).

Let me know what you think.

George


Reply

Nice idea - I‘m always interested in seeing it.

Two questions:

1.) Are you planning on proving full res images or at least 100% crops somewhere as a download (perhaps in the description of the video)?
2.) Are you going to test the Meyer Optik Domiron 50 mm f/2?

Thanks for the initiative!


Reply

There are lots of lens reviews on the Tube, so I think you need to come up with something valuable no one else is doing in their reviews.

If you specialize in old German lenses, that could be a start. I don't remember seeing many reviews of say, the Steinheil Quinar 135s or the ISCO 100 Isconar f/4.5.


Reply

KEO wrote:
There are lots of lens reviews on the Tube, so I think you need to come up with something valuable no one else is doing in their reviews.

If you specialize in old German lenses, that could be a start. I don't remember seeing many reviews of say, the Steinheil Quinar 135s or the ISCO 100 Isconar f/4.5.


… or the Steinheil Reproobjektiv 80 mm f/4.5 or the Zeiss Graphikon 90 mm, or the Agfa Color-Solagon DI 70 mm f/4.5… 😅 Okay, okay - I know I‘m the only one interested in those! 😉


Reply

georgegrant wrote:
... if there is demand for videos on those lenses consisting of

1.) review and info of the lens
2.) real life video footage (apsc + fullframe)
3.) real life still images
4.) Comparisons

"Normal" videos, without that annoying 'hype' that some youtubers do. Just a channel for people who want to know more about (mostly German) old lenses and cameras (mainly Exakta as they are the focus of my collection).


I've always had a fascination for old German lenses, ever since the '60's and my first Zeiss Ikon Nettar (12 on 120, converted to 16-on-120 for 'economy') and then the fixed Tessar on an old Contaflex which seemed to have more shades of grey than any other lens I'd used!

My current assemblage (it's hardly a collection) comprises a small selection in Exakta mount (and a working Exa Ia to use them with) and a few in M42 for use on my Spotmatic.

Definitely interested in some hype-free factual videos Smile


Reply

Whenever I plan to buy a 'new' lens I always try to look it up on Youtube to get an impression. Also whenever I'm in the mood for it, I try to make a short Youtube video myself.

So yeah, I'd appreciate it if you start a Youtube channel, the more the merrier.


Reply

Like 1 Like 1 Definitely go for it! Nobody else will do it like you.


Reply

Thanks for all the replies.

@keo, Steinheil is one of my favorite lensmakers. Both the lenses you mentioned are in my collection. The Isco 100/4.5 is too slow for my taste, but its good glass nevertheless.

@simple.joy , yes, I am plannign to upload 100% images for each and every review I do, including 4k ungraded footage. The Domiron is hig on my wish list, but I haven't found one in good condition yet.

Except reviews I also plan on publishing videos on how to restore both lenses and cameras as it seems to me that this is becoming a forgotten art. You can literally spend weeks on repairing an Exakta camera if you don't know what you're doing. I am no master, but I can manage to take care of the most common issues (shutter, winder, etc).

Another part is creating videos on cleaning and polishing. I keep on seeing so many "golden" Exakta's for sale just because someone polishing it didn't know some parts are actually made out of brass.

I am starting filming some b-roll tomorrow and hope to push episode 1 out end of the month. If there is more specific lenses you'd like to see, feel free to post them here.


George


Reply

Like 1 Friends


Reply

georgegrant wrote:
@keo, The Isco 100/4.5 is too slow for my taste, but its good glass nevertheless.


You should give it another chance! Mine has wonderful color rendition and is extremely sharp with the aperture closed down. It's excellent for landscape and macro shooting. On the other hand, it can be hard to find a good one because the overall construction is so simple - too simple, really. The aperture mechanism in particular is incredibly flimsy.


Reply

KEO wrote:
georgegrant wrote:
@keo, The Isco 100/4.5 is too slow for my taste, but its good glass nevertheless.


You should give it another chance! Mine has wonderful color rendition and is extremely sharp with the aperture closed down. It's excellent for landscape and macro shooting. On the other hand, it can be hard to find a good one because the overall construction is so simple - too simple, really. The aperture mechanism in particular is incredibly flimsy.

How about a comparison to the Steinheil Cassar 100/4.5? Wink


Reply

Like 1 Like 1


Reply

we-the-people can judge only when we taste something.

like vanilla ice for example.

so show us those videos and be prepared for a flop.

or a rise to the tron of youtube-old-lens-reviewer.

nothing in between will be accepted.