| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
papasito
 Joined: 09 Jan 2015 Posts: 1721
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 2:10 pm Post subject: sharpest takumar 50/1,4 |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 2:10 pm Post subject: sharpest takumar 50/1,4 |
|
|
papasito wrote:
Hi.
There are 4 different Super Takumar 50/1,4 (except hybrid ones) in M42 mount
ST 8 elements
ST 7 elements
S-M-C
SMC
Am I right if say that the ST 7 elements is a bit sharper than the others, specially at F/1,4? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3912 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 2:24 pm Post subject: Re: sharpest takumar 50/1,4 |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 2:24 pm Post subject: Re: sharpest takumar 50/1,4 |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| papasito wrote: |
Hi.
There are 4 different Super Takumar 50/1,4 (except hybrid ones) in M42 mount
ST 8 elements
ST 7 elements
S-M-C
SMC
Am I right if say that the ST 7 elements is a bit sharper than the others, specially at F/1,4? |
I thought the 8 el was supposed to be superior, but I only have the normal S-M-C, so I never compared. And I believe the differences are minimal. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
visualopsins
 Joined: 05 Mar 2009 Posts: 11699 Location: California
Expire: 2027-07-11
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 2:51 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 2:51 pm Post subject: |
|
|
visualopsins wrote:
Yes. I have them all. The S-M-C and SMC coatings improve contrast and increase flare resistance. The 8-element has "character". _________________ ☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮ like attracts like! ☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮
Cameras: Sony ILCE-7RM2, Spotmatics II, F, and ESII, Nikon P4
Lenses:
M42 Asahi Optical Co., Takumar 1:4 f=35mm, 1:2 f=58mm (Sonnar), 1:2.4 f=58mm (Heliar), 1:2.2 f=55mm (Gaussian), 1:2.8 f=105mm (Model I), 1:2.8/105 (Model II), 1:5.6/200, Tele-Takumar 1:5.6/200, 1:6.3/300, Macro-Takumar 1:4/50, Auto-Takumar 1:2.3 f=35, 1:1.8 f=55mm, 1:2.2 f=55mm, Super-TAKUMAR 1:3.5/28 (fat), 1:2/35 (Fat), 1:1.4/50 (8-element), Super-Multi-Coated Fisheye-TAKUMAR 1:4/17, Super-Multi-Coated TAKUMAR 1:4.5/20, 1:3.5/24, 1:3.5/28, 1:2/35, 1:3.5/35, 1:1.8/85, 1:1.9/85 1:2.8/105, 1:3.5/135, 1:2.5/135 (II), 1:4/150, 1:4/200, 1:4/300, 1:4.5/500, Super-Multi-Coated Macro-TAKUMAR 1:4/50, 1:4/100, Super-Multi-Coated Bellows-TAKUMAR 1:4/100, SMC TAKUMAR 1:1.4/50, 1:1.8/55
M42 Carl Zeiss Jena Flektogon 2.4/35
Contax Carl Zeiss Vario-Sonnar T* 28-70mm F3.5-4.5
Pentax K-mount SMC PENTAX-A ZOOM 1:3.5 35~105mm, SMC PENTAX ZOOM 1:4 45~125mm
Nikon Micro-NIKKOR-P-C Auto 1:3.5 f=55mm, NIKKOR-P Auto 105mm f/2.5 Pre-AI (Sonnar), Micro-NIKKOR 105mm 1:4 AI, NIKKOR AI-S 35-135mm f/3,5-4,5
Solinon 1:5.6/18 ASPH.
Tamron SP 17mm f/3.5 (51B), Tamron SP 17mm f/3.5 (151B), SP 500mm f/8 (55BB), SP 70-210mm f/3.5 (19AH)
Vivitar 100mm 1:2.8 MC 1:1 Macro Telephoto (Kiron)
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3912 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 2:54 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 2:54 pm Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| visualopsins wrote: |
| Yes. I have them all. The S-M-C and SMC coatings improve contrast and increase flare resistance. The 8-element has "character". |
What about the 8 el, does it have better resolution? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
stevemark
 Joined: 29 Apr 2011 Posts: 5509 Location: Switzerland
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 4:16 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 4:16 pm Post subject: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| visualopsins wrote: |
| Yes. I have them all. The S-M-C and SMC coatings improve contrast and increase flare resistance. The 8-element has "character". |
| caspert79 wrote: |
| visualopsins wrote: |
| Yes. I have them all. The S-M-C and SMC coatings improve contrast and increase flare resistance. The 8-element has "character". |
What about the 8 el, does it have better resolution? |
I recently have compared the 8 element and the 7 element 1.4/50mm side-by-side in different situations, both for resolution as well as for bokeh. Results:
1) There was a distinguished difference in colors (7 element version contains thorium glass)
2) No visible differences concerning resolution (24 MP FF)
3) No visible differences concerning bokeh
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3912 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 4:28 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 22, 2021 4:28 pm Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| stevemark wrote: |
| visualopsins wrote: |
| Yes. I have them all. The S-M-C and SMC coatings improve contrast and increase flare resistance. The 8-element has "character". |
| caspert79 wrote: |
| visualopsins wrote: |
| Yes. I have them all. The S-M-C and SMC coatings improve contrast and increase flare resistance. The 8-element has "character". |
What about the 8 el, does it have better resolution? |
I recently have compared the 8 element and the 7 element 1.4/50mm side-by-side in different situations, both for resolution as well as for bokeh. Results:
1) There was a distinguished difference in colors (7 element version contains thorium glass)
2) No visible differences concerning resolution (24 MP FF)
3) No visible differences concerning bokeh
S |
That's good news for my wife, because then I don't have to get one  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
papasito
 Joined: 09 Jan 2015 Posts: 1721
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 23, 2021 11:46 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 23, 2021 11:46 am Post subject: |
|
|
papasito wrote:
Thank you, to all.
When used the 8 el. I had an aps-c cam with 16 mp, so I couldn't have a real idea about the rendering of the lens .
I didn't find another one to test.
Both SMC have nice colours and contrast.
But to my eyes, the 7 el. getting off the yellowish is a bit sharp. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
D1N0
 Joined: 07 Aug 2012 Posts: 2726
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 23, 2021 1:07 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 23, 2021 1:07 pm Post subject: |
|
|
D1N0 wrote:
I don't have the 8 element, but I do have the 7-element super-takumar and Super-Multi-Coated Takumar. The latter is the better performer concerning sharpness wide open. The soft glow the lens has seems to be a bit closer the the subject matter on the S-M-C. _________________ pentaxian |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
blotafton
 Joined: 08 Aug 2013 Posts: 1794 Location: Sweden
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 23, 2021 2:47 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 23, 2021 2:47 pm Post subject: |
|
|
blotafton wrote:
I have a 7 element Super Takumar and a Super Multicoated Takumar. The Super Takumar copy has slightly better edge sharpness and more yellowing. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
yoyomaoz
 Joined: 31 Jul 2018 Posts: 97 Location: Adelaide
|
 Posted: Wed Aug 25, 2021 11:44 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Wed Aug 25, 2021 11:44 am Post subject: |
|
|
yoyomaoz wrote:
I have recently seen a video providing an in-depth comparison of images from the 7 and 8 element versions of this lens. Quite honestly there is almost nothing between them and to the extent that there is, some shots look marginally better (depending on preferences) in the 7 element version and some look marginally better with the 8 element version but to be honest if the video had not been a direct one to one comparison I would hardly notice any differences if at all. I have concluded that the "8 element 50mm f1.4 is a super lens" idea often pushed on the internet is all hype for all practical purposes. In other words, don't sweat the difference and do not pay big money for the 8 element version if it is attracting a premium - it is not really worth it. Both are excellent. _________________ Peter M
Flickr me: https://www.flickr.com/photos/life_in_shadows/
Articles on Style and Mood in Photography
http://www.stevehuffphoto.com/2014/11/24/character-style-and-mood-in-photography-by-peter-maynard/
http://www.stevehuffphoto.com/2014/12/02/character-style-and-mood-in-photography-part-2-by-peter-maynard/
http://www.stevehuffphoto.com/2017/01/10/character-style-and-mood-in-photography-part-3-by-peter-maynard/ |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
KEO
 Joined: 27 Sep 2018 Posts: 813 Location: USA
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 26, 2021 7:10 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 26, 2021 7:10 pm Post subject: |
|
|
KEO wrote:
The big difference is that the 8-element version is not radioactive.
Some of the later ones also have more aperture blades than the earlier ones with hexagonal irises. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
visualopsins
 Joined: 05 Mar 2009 Posts: 11699 Location: California
Expire: 2027-07-11
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 26, 2021 8:11 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 26, 2021 8:11 pm Post subject: |
|
|
visualopsins wrote:
| KEO wrote: |
The big difference is that the 8-element version is not radioactive.
Some of the later ones also have more aperture blades than the earlier ones with hexagonal irises. |
That is controversial -- the 8-element may have far less radioactivity, not from thorium, but from other less radioactive material (I forget which )
Maybe you mean earlier versions tend to have more blades... _________________ ☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮ like attracts like! ☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮☮
Cameras: Sony ILCE-7RM2, Spotmatics II, F, and ESII, Nikon P4
Lenses:
M42 Asahi Optical Co., Takumar 1:4 f=35mm, 1:2 f=58mm (Sonnar), 1:2.4 f=58mm (Heliar), 1:2.2 f=55mm (Gaussian), 1:2.8 f=105mm (Model I), 1:2.8/105 (Model II), 1:5.6/200, Tele-Takumar 1:5.6/200, 1:6.3/300, Macro-Takumar 1:4/50, Auto-Takumar 1:2.3 f=35, 1:1.8 f=55mm, 1:2.2 f=55mm, Super-TAKUMAR 1:3.5/28 (fat), 1:2/35 (Fat), 1:1.4/50 (8-element), Super-Multi-Coated Fisheye-TAKUMAR 1:4/17, Super-Multi-Coated TAKUMAR 1:4.5/20, 1:3.5/24, 1:3.5/28, 1:2/35, 1:3.5/35, 1:1.8/85, 1:1.9/85 1:2.8/105, 1:3.5/135, 1:2.5/135 (II), 1:4/150, 1:4/200, 1:4/300, 1:4.5/500, Super-Multi-Coated Macro-TAKUMAR 1:4/50, 1:4/100, Super-Multi-Coated Bellows-TAKUMAR 1:4/100, SMC TAKUMAR 1:1.4/50, 1:1.8/55
M42 Carl Zeiss Jena Flektogon 2.4/35
Contax Carl Zeiss Vario-Sonnar T* 28-70mm F3.5-4.5
Pentax K-mount SMC PENTAX-A ZOOM 1:3.5 35~105mm, SMC PENTAX ZOOM 1:4 45~125mm
Nikon Micro-NIKKOR-P-C Auto 1:3.5 f=55mm, NIKKOR-P Auto 105mm f/2.5 Pre-AI (Sonnar), Micro-NIKKOR 105mm 1:4 AI, NIKKOR AI-S 35-135mm f/3,5-4,5
Solinon 1:5.6/18 ASPH.
Tamron SP 17mm f/3.5 (51B), Tamron SP 17mm f/3.5 (151B), SP 500mm f/8 (55BB), SP 70-210mm f/3.5 (19AH)
Vivitar 100mm 1:2.8 MC 1:1 Macro Telephoto (Kiron)
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Lightshow
 Joined: 04 Nov 2011 Posts: 3666 Location: Calgary
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 26, 2021 10:24 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 26, 2021 10:24 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Lightshow wrote:
I have the 8 element ST, 7 element ST, S-M-C, SMC K, SMC M, and SMC A 50/1.4's
I skipped the SMC Takumar because I don't like the rubber focus ring.
The lens I prefer is the S-M-C.
Which is sharper? I think my SMC K is, it definitely is better than the M and A, and IIRC it's sharper than the ST's, I think my S-M-C is second.
Between the 8 & 7 element ST, I found the 8 to be a tiny bit sharper but it had worse flare than the 7, I think the 7 has very nice flare, more photogenic than most lenses flare, ideal for portrait flare.
My Topcor RE 58/1.4 is sharper than all of then wide open.
Oh, I do recall reading that the 8 element was designed to compete against the Zeiss Plannar and draw users to their system, a short time later after all the reviews were done they quietly transitioned to the 7 element to save money, the 8 has a triplet (3 element group) which would be expensive to manufacture, so I don't really blame them for reducing cost, the bait and switch is, or was, slimy. _________________ A Manual Focus Junky...
One photographers junk lens is an artists favorite tool.
My lens list
http://www.flickr.com/photos/lightshow-photography/ |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
cbass
 Joined: 27 Jul 2019 Posts: 457
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 26, 2021 10:37 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 26, 2021 10:37 pm Post subject: |
|
|
cbass wrote:
I have neither so I can't say which is sharper or not. However, I found this Soviet lens test that includes the 8 element version and a few other lenses. The test was intended to compare two 0.95 lenses. A Soviet 0.95 that was designed to be beat/compete with the Canon 0.95 at the time.
Here are the lenses translated from Russian. The rest should be obvious enough.
1. Ð¡ÑƒÐ¼Ð¼Ð¸Ð»ÑŽÐºÑ = Summilux
2. Ðра-6 = Era-6
3. Супер-Такумар = Super-Takumar
4. ГекÑагон = Hexanon
5. Юпитер-3 = Jupiter-3
6. Канон-Ленз = Canon-Lens
7. Рекорд-4 = Record-4
8. Канон-Ленз = Canon-Lens
9. Ðуто-Топкар = Auto-Topcor
10. Канон-Ленз = Canon-Lens
The 8 element seems to be a excellent performer but starts to lag behind other lenses in the extreme corners. The other thing to point out is the Leica is playing on another level. If you have the funds, then just buy it and forget the other 50's.
Sadly the Zeiss was not included so we will never know if it beat the Zeiss or not. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Lightshow
 Joined: 04 Nov 2011 Posts: 3666 Location: Calgary
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 26, 2021 10:47 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 26, 2021 10:47 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Lightshow wrote:
| KEO wrote: |
Some of the later ones also have more aperture blades than the earlier ones with hexagonal irises. |
All of the Super Takumar or SMC K mount 50/1.4 lenses I own have 6 blade apertures, perhaps you mean earlier lenses.
cbass, do you have a link to that test?
The 3 columns on the right are the resolution numbers, I believe the columns are: 0=centre, 10= 10mm from centre, 20= 20mm from centre.
These results don't make sense to me, the Record-4 equals or beats all other lenses except the Leica? Within the quote it sounds like this test is from the makers of the Record-4 lens... How convenient.
Here's a google translation:
| Quote: |
The advertisement was created by the Japanese lens "Canon-Lenz", which has a record-breaking aperture ratio of 1: 0.95.  As studies of the industrial design have shown, the lens has a lower quality of the optical image in the field.  Of course, the task of creating such a fast wide-angle anastigmata is extremely difficult.  We were convinced of this when developing the Record lens.  This anastigmat, developed by D. Volosov, N. Khmelnikova and I. Driatskaya, in the "Record-4" version has a relative aperture of 1: 0.9 with a field of view of 45%;  with a relatively large back focal distance (s'% 322.3 mm), it has a focal length of 67.5 mm;  the lens circuit is nine-pins.  The task is greatly simplified by decreasing the relative aperture.  For example, in the Canon-Lenz lens (f% 358mm; 1: 1.2) it has already turned out to be possible to increase the back focal length to 36 mm;  of course, the task was all the more simplified because the angle of the field of view was also reduced to 41 °. |
Optical design of "Record" lenses Especially fast lenses for 24x36 mm
[below is from within the table, I had to move some things around due to how Google messed things up, hope I fixed everything]
cameras Optical characteristics Photographic resolving power, mm Lens brand Geometric vignetting,% Number of components and lenses f, mm s', mm
{focal length f-stop} (FOV? & back focal distance?) ~Geometric vignetting,%~ #Number of groups & elements# [Photographic resolving power 0-10-20 I think it's distance from centre in mm?]
Summilux (Germany) {50 1: 1.4} (46 28.3) ~70~ #5g7e# [46 32 32]
Era-6 (USSRÂ Â ) {52 1: 1.5} (45 39.6) ~63~ #5g6e# [40 28 21]
Super Takumar|(Japan) {50 1: 1.4}Â Â (46 36.4) ~58~ #6g8e# [42 32 22]
Hexanon (Japan) {52 1: 1.4} (45 34.5) ~66~ #5g6e# [41 31 18]
Jupiter-3 (USSR) {52 1: 1.5} (45 23.5) ~68~ #3g7e# [37 28 24]
Canon-Lenz (Japan) {50 1: 0.95} (46 20.1) ~82~ #5g7e# [41 25 11]
Record-4 (USSR) {52 1: 0.9} (45 22.3) ~82~ #6g9e# [42 27 15]
Canon-Lenz | (Japan) {50 1: 1.4} (46 36.6) ~69~ #6g7e# [40 31 23]
Auto-Topkar (Japan) {58 1: 1.4}Â Â (41 36.9) ~72~ #5g7e# [39 30 24]
Canon-Lenz "(Japan) {55 1: 1.2} (41 36.0) ~60~ #5g7e# [30 23 14] _________________ A Manual Focus Junky...
One photographers junk lens is an artists favorite tool.
My lens list
http://www.flickr.com/photos/lightshow-photography/ |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
cbass
 Joined: 27 Jul 2019 Posts: 457
|
 Posted: Fri Aug 27, 2021 3:33 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Fri Aug 27, 2021 3:33 am Post subject: |
|
|
cbass wrote:
| Lightshow wrote: |
cbass, do you have a link to that test?
|
Not currently. I will have to try to find it. I saw this posted on a forum some time ago. So I downloaded the picture in order to preserve it in case it was removed
| Lightshow wrote: |
Within the quote it sounds like this test is from the makers of the Record-4 lens... How convenient.
|
That is correct. The test was done by the Soviets so there could be some bias or number fudging. However, if there was I think the fudging would be in favor of the Record-4 vs the Canon lens. I don't think they would bother with the other lenses. I will also point out.
1) The Soviets were capable of making high quality sharp lenses. I have several of them.
2) The Record-4 in comparison is at the bottom in corner performance. It has the third worst corners.
3) The Leica outperformed every other lens in the center, mid frame, and extreme corners. Not a Soviet lens.
4) Other Soviet lenses in the comparison didn't dominate either. The Jupiter 3 has the second worst center performance. Is mid pack mid frame. However, it is in the top for corner performance. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|