| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3911 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 8:06 am Post subject: Tamron SP 90mm f/2.5 vs Tokina AT-X 90mm f/2.5 macro |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 8:06 am Post subject: Tamron SP 90mm f/2.5 vs Tokina AT-X 90mm f/2.5 macro |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
In the coming days I will post a few comparisons between the Tamron SP 90mm f/2.5 and the Tokina AT-X 90mm f/2.5 macro.
Let's start of with a bokeh comparison:
bokehcomparison by devoscasper, on Flickr
Bokeh is very pleasant of both two lenses. Not surprising, because of their reputation. There's a slight difference in colors as well; the Tamron is a tiny bit warmer? Contrast seems to be a bit higher in the Tokina images.
Then, some 100% crops:
cropcomparison by devoscasper, on Flickr
Both lenses have very good resolution through the aperture range. (micro) contrast of the Tokina seems to be a bit higher, especially with the aperture closed down a little.
Very good performance of both lenses, as expected and differences are not earth-shattering. More tests will follow. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
blotafton
 Joined: 08 Aug 2013 Posts: 1794 Location: Sweden
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 11:30 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 11:30 am Post subject: |
|
|
blotafton wrote:
Almost as close as it gets. Thanks for posting! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
kiddo
 Joined: 29 Jun 2018 Posts: 1630
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 11:51 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 11:51 am Post subject: |
|
|
kiddo wrote:
Thank you for this one, as right now the tokina goes about 2.5-3 times more expensive than Tamron.
Some users mentioned good corners on landscapes with both lenses , I'm only taking out mine BB version when doing macro, and some portraits, not bad at all, but do prefer faster lenses for portraits. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
stevemark
 Joined: 29 Apr 2011 Posts: 5509 Location: Switzerland
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 12:33 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 12:33 pm Post subject: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
Interesting to see that the bokeh of the "Bokina" AT-X in fact is smoother than that of the Tamron SP. While I have a few Tokina AT-X lenses, I never have used the AT-X 2.5/90mm Macro.
Ah yeah - real world resolution tests with uniformely red (or blue, that is) objects may be a bit misleading. In a Bayer sensor, only 25% of the pixels are red ones, therefore limiting the resolution of your 43 MP FF sensor to about 11 MP ...
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3911 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 12:54 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 12:54 pm Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| stevemark wrote: |
Interesting to see that the bokeh of the "Bokina" AT-X in fact is smoother than that of the Tamron SP. While I have a few Tokina AT-X lenses, I never have used the AT-X 2.5/90mm Macro.
Ah yeah - real world resolution tests with uniformely red (or blue, that is) objects may be a bit misleading. In a Bayer sensor, only 25% of the pixels are red ones, therefore limiting the resolution of your 43 MP FF sensor to about 11 MP ...
S |
Yeah true, bokeh is slightly smoother of the bokina, at least wide open. Indeed hard to be conclusive yet on resolution; more tests will be added. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
vivaldibow
 Joined: 23 Jun 2018 Posts: 844
Expire: 2021-03-09
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 3:44 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 3:44 pm Post subject: |
|
|
vivaldibow wrote:
Thanks for the comparison. Both are excellent. Which Tamron 90/2.5, 52B or 52BB? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3911 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 3:45 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 13, 2023 3:45 pm Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| vivaldibow wrote: |
| Thanks for the comparison. Both are excellent. Which Tamron 90/2.5, 52B or 52BB? |
It's the 52B. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3911 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 14, 2023 10:14 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 14, 2023 10:14 am Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
Ok, here another comparison. This time 100% center crops of a bank note.
banknotecomparison by devoscasper, on Flickr
The image of the Tokina is more contrasty, in fact it shows very good contrast wide open.
@f/4 the image of the Tamron improves a lot; the Tokina less so. It looks like the Tamron is even a bit sharper here.
When closing down the aperture further, the Tamron doesn't seem to improve much (or at all), but the Tokina is. The Tokina seems to be sharper @ f/5.6 and significantly sharper @f/8. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3911 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 14, 2023 3:11 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 14, 2023 3:11 pm Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
Ok, now what about infinity? Note: I corrected the WB of the images to make them easier to compare. The Tamron renders very warm, whereas the Tokina seems more life like.
infinity comparison by devoscasper, on Flickr
The differences are not all that big, but in the center, I rate the Tamron slightly sharper than the Tokina @ f/2.5, and maybe also @ f/4. Also, the corners of the Tamron seem slightly better wide open. From f/4 on, corners of both lenses are very similar. From f/5.6 until f/11, the center performance of the Tokina seems a bit better.
Conclusion: differences between both lenses seem smaller @ infinity than at close focus. @ infinity, the Tamron seems a bit better at large apertures, and the Tokina seems a bit better at small apertures. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
kiddo
 Joined: 29 Jun 2018 Posts: 1630
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 14, 2023 9:14 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 14, 2023 9:14 pm Post subject: |
|
|
kiddo wrote:
thank you Caspert , very nice results from both lenses, tamron wins for better price, Tokina for just a tiny bit on details (macro);
flares might change the dispute towards tokina, tamron has got the blue (eventually) spot reflection issue in certain circumstances |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
alex ph
 Joined: 16 Mar 2013 Posts: 1802
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 14, 2023 9:46 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Mon Aug 14, 2023 9:46 pm Post subject: |
|
|
alex ph wrote:
A nice demonstation of both lenses. Thank you for posting. It looks like the difference in rendering is marginal. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3911 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 15, 2023 5:43 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 15, 2023 5:43 am Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
For whomever is interested in the Tamron, please PM me. I have two now (fd & ai), so one can go for an interesting price. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
LittleAlex
 Joined: 27 Nov 2008 Posts: 2085 Location: L'vov (Western Ukraine)
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 15, 2023 8:58 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 15, 2023 8:58 am Post subject: |
|
|
LittleAlex wrote:
And that tiny difference is able to be the difference between the particular samples as well. _________________ "Sharpness is a bourgeois concept" - © H. Cartier Bresson |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3911 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 15, 2023 2:48 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 15, 2023 2:48 pm Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
OK guys, two final tests to wrap it up. This time a picture of flowers under controlled lighting conditions. Colors are corrected in PP.
To give an idea about the full image:
overviewflowers by devoscasper, on Flickr
Then, the 100% crops:
cropcomparisonflowers by devoscasper, on Flickr
Again, the Tamron seems to be a bit sharper @ f/2.5 and f/4. From f/5.6 on, the Tokina AT-X is sharper. I think the difference is most clear @ f/8. The Tokina is also more contrasty.
The difference may seem insignificant, but IMO the macro's of the Tokina look significantly more 3D than the Tamron's; I guess it has to do with the image being more contrasty, not sure if sharpness has to do with it.
Then, a bokeh test:
flowersbokehcomparison by devoscasper, on Flickr
The Tokina has slightly softer bokeh, but the difference is not so big.
Time to sum up my findings:
- Tamron slightly sharper @ f/4
- Tamron very impressive performance from corner to corner already @ f/2.5
- Tamron unbeatable quality for its price
- Tamron warm colors (correctable in PP)
- Tokina sharper @ f/5.6, f/8 and f/11
- Tokina higher contrast and more 3D quality in macro's
- Tokina more neutral colors
- Tokina slightly softer bokeh
It's up to the individual whether the Tokina AT-X 90mm f/2.5 is worth the extra money compared to the Tamron. Of course it also depends on your budget, and probably the kind of photographs you want to make with it.
For me personally, after testing quite a few macro lenses in this focal length, the Tokina remains my absolute favorite macro lens. Sharpness, build quality, contrast and colors, are truly impressive. However, I'm very happy to keep the Tamron in my collection: it truly is an impressive lens, especially at this price point. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Doc Sharptail
 Joined: 23 Nov 2020 Posts: 1504 Location: Winnipeg Canada
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 15, 2023 6:16 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 15, 2023 6:16 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Doc Sharptail wrote:
That is a lot of work.
Thanks for putting the time in to show the performance of two really nice lenses!
-D.S. _________________
D-810, F2, FTN, FT-3 in Black
35mm f2 O.C. nikkor
50 f2 H nikkor, 50 f2 H.C. nikkor, 50 f 1.4 AI-s, 135 f3.5 Q,
50 f2 K nikkor 2x, 28-85mm f3.5-4.5 A/I-s, 35-105 3.5-4.5 A/I-s, 200mm f4 Micro A/I, partial list.
"Ain't no half-way" -S.R.V.
"Oh Yeah... Alright" -Paul Simon |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3911 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 15, 2023 7:07 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 15, 2023 7:07 pm Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| Doc Sharptail wrote: |
That is a lot of work.
Thanks for putting the time in to show the performance of two really nice lenses!
-D.S. |
Thanks! Fun to do, so not really work  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
iso rivolta
Joined: 16 Aug 2023 Posts: 15
|
 Posted: Wed Aug 16, 2023 12:39 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Wed Aug 16, 2023 12:39 pm Post subject: |
|
|
iso rivolta wrote:
Thank you for the careful comparison, this is very interesting. After looking at all the test images, I started wondering if the Tamron has a higher effective F-number, especially when focusing close. It looks like it has a larger DOF than the Tokina at same nominal F-numbers (e.g., look at the first series of crops).
This might also explain why the Tokina has softer background at low F-numbers and can squeeze more details at F5.6 and F8, while possibly the Tamron starts to be diffraction limited at these apertures.
Were the required exposure times the same between lenses set at the same nominal F-number?
Can you do a slanted ruler test at medium magnification to better compare DOF between the lenses?
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3911 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Wed Aug 16, 2023 1:48 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Wed Aug 16, 2023 1:48 pm Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| iso rivolta wrote: |
Thank you for the careful comparison, this is very interesting. After looking at all the test images, I started wondering if the Tamron has a higher effective F-number, especially when focusing close. It looks like it has a larger DOF than the Tokina at same nominal F-numbers (e.g., look at the first series of crops).
This might also explain why the Tokina has softer background at low F-numbers and can squeeze more details at F5.6 and F8, while possibly the Tamron starts to be diffraction limited at these apertures.
Were the required exposure times the same between lenses set at the same nominal F-number?
Can you do a slanted ruler test at medium magnification to better compare DOF between the lenses?
 |
Wide open I see no difference, but @f/8 the Tamron seems to have shutter speeds that are about 20% longer, so it's possible diffraction kicks in slightly 'earlier'. 20% is not really a lot though; a whole stop would double the shutter speed, so I don't think diffraction can completely explain the difference in sharpness. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
iso rivolta
Joined: 16 Aug 2023 Posts: 15
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 17, 2023 11:58 am Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Thu Aug 17, 2023 11:58 am Post subject: |
|
|
iso rivolta wrote:
| caspert79 wrote: |
| iso rivolta wrote: |
Thank you for the careful comparison, this is very interesting. After looking at all the test images, I started wondering if the Tamron has a higher effective F-number, especially when focusing close. It looks like it has a larger DOF than the Tokina at same nominal F-numbers (e.g., look at the first series of crops).
This might also explain why the Tokina has softer background at low F-numbers and can squeeze more details at F5.6 and F8, while possibly the Tamron starts to be diffraction limited at these apertures.
Were the required exposure times the same between lenses set at the same nominal F-number?
Can you do a slanted ruler test at medium magnification to better compare DOF between the lenses?
 |
Wide open I see no difference, but @f/8 the Tamron seems to have shutter speeds that are about 20% longer, so it's possible diffraction kicks in slightly 'earlier'. 20% is not really a lot though; a whole stop would double the shutter speed, so I don't think diffraction can completely explain the difference in sharpness. |
Interesting, thanks. I agree that a 20% difference in exposure (0.26 EV) is probably not enough to explain it all, and is not showing necessarily a difference in effective F-numbers (transmittance can also differ by such an amount).
Another thing that may play a role in Tamron's decrease in contrast at F8 in the bill images could be a very slight form of sensor reflection, known to happen with this lens. Especially if it the bill was right in the center. The real "blue spot" I think is only visible at smaller apertures than F8.
On the other hand, in Tokina copies nowadays I very often see haze on the middle elements and this also affects the contrast. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
kiddo
 Joined: 29 Jun 2018 Posts: 1630
|
 Posted: Fri Aug 18, 2023 8:35 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Fri Aug 18, 2023 8:35 pm Post subject: |
|
|
kiddo wrote:
Did anyone compare the Elicar 90mm 2.5 with these 2 goodies Tokina or Tamron ? I've found a cheap elicar medical , which I've read doesn't reach infinity (maybe with a shorter adapter could reach it?) but being used in this medical field ,might give better result on macro? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
caspert79
 Joined: 31 Oct 2010 Posts: 3911 Location: The Netherlands
|
 Posted: Fri Aug 18, 2023 9:11 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Fri Aug 18, 2023 9:11 pm Post subject: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
| kiddo wrote: |
| Did anyone compare the Elicar 90mm 2.5 with these 2 goodies Tokina or Tamron ? I've found a cheap elicar medical , which I've read doesn't reach infinity (maybe with a shorter adapter could reach it?) but being used in this medical field ,might give better result on macro? |
No, never had one. Images on Flickr look good though. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
iso rivolta
Joined: 16 Aug 2023 Posts: 15
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 20, 2023 3:02 pm Post subject: |
|
 Posted: Sun Aug 20, 2023 3:02 pm Post subject: |
|
|
iso rivolta wrote:
| kiddo wrote: |
| Did anyone compare the Elicar 90mm 2.5 with these 2 goodies Tokina or Tamron ? I've found a cheap elicar medical , which I've read doesn't reach infinity (maybe with a shorter adapter could reach it?) but being used in this medical field ,might give better result on macro? |
The Elicar should be a larger magnification (more than 1x) version of the Komine-made 90mm that normally goes to 1:1 (also sold as Vivitar and Panagor 90mm f2.8, and sometimes f2.5). It is an older and simpler, almost symmetrical design with 6 elements in 4 groups and no fixed rear element. The Komine lens was not highly corrected for wide open use (it has a lot of spherical aberrations glow), in contrast with the Vivitar Series 1, Tokina and Tamron which double as portrait lenses, very usable wide open.
You can see a comparison at 1x magnification between the Vivitar Series 1 (optically almost identical with Tokina) with its 1:1 adapter and the Komine-made Vivitar, and other vintage macro lenses, here: http://makingnottaking.blogspot.com/2010/03/8-lens-macro-shoot-out.html |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|