MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

camera + lens = ?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I'm posting this because of an odd discovery I made Shocked - unless its all in my head and I'm nuts Confused (actually I believe I am but isn't that part of the creative process . . .) Smile

Do people find that the camera/lens combination changes the qualities of the work? At the end of February I posted some shots taken with my Steinheil Culminar 135mm on my Minolta XG70 using an adapter, I loved them. I used it on a Praktica PLC2 and I'm not as impressed.

Can a camera effect the quality of shots as much as the lens? Please share any thoughts/observations on this, thanks.

Jim


Reply

Well quality in a film camera is majorly determined by the film and lens used.

There are camera body factors too, such as a poor film holder that might curve the film a lot possibly.

Or tiny light leaks fogging the film, losing contrast.

Poor exposure metering.

Poor shutter design.

That's about all I can think of.


Reply

It might even come down to something as simple as camera shake making your photos a bit less clear if the Minolta shutter is electronic and smoother than the Praktica or the age of the camera affecting the shutter speed as I believe the Minolta is a few years newer so possibly more correct shutter than the Praktica. Sometimes even the viewfinder can be brighter so a bit easier to focus correctly.


Reply

Its important to know what you don't like in the case of the Praktica. Yes, in film photography the situation is like Athiril presented.
If the camera is in pefect working condition than, may be the light meter works different (as I know that camera has a more rare battery).
I think your older solution, using the Minolta body+adapter is better. More, that one has Av exposure mode, not only full manual (very few M42 cameras can do that) Smile


Reply

It may not be in your head as much as in your hands

To me, the Canon AE/AL series feels almost perfect in my hands so I'm far more comfortable shooting that 35mm film camera than most other bodies with a much wider lens selection so I am more inventive, more apt to take borderline pics etc.

Jules


Reply

montecarlo wrote:
Its important to know what you don't like in the case of the Praktica. Yes, in film photography the situation is like Athiril presented.
If the camera is in pefect working condition than, may be the light meter works different (as I know that camera has a more rare battery).
I think your older solution, using the Minolta body+adapter is better. More, that one has Av exposure mode, not only full manual (very few M42 cameras can do that) Smile

What I'm not liking is the performance of the lens on the Praktica body. As for the battery - that's good as I've got a substitute in as shown in the links Attila posted. After research and testing I think I have the metering on this down pat. Smile The Praktica's quirk of the DOF preveiw button being on the lens is probably my greatest irk with it.
Now I might be a tad impatient as this is the first roll - but not being satisfied with the results = Mad
The reason I don't like the old solution is as I've said in a past post, the adapter causes the apeture's linkage to engage so I am shooting through a stopped down lens and the only lens its tolerable with is the Steinheill Confused This is why I am interested in using an M42 body. I can get my head around not having the option of Automatic exposure setting as on my Minolta XG70 ( my SRT didn't have it Smile )

lulalake wrote:
It may not be in your head as much as in your hands

To me, the Canon AE/AL series feels almost perfect in my hands so I'm far more comfortable shooting that 35mm film camera than most other bodies with a much wider lens selection so I am more inventive, more apt to take borderline pics etc.

I've thought of this before but I don't think its the case for several reasons -
The Praktica even though slightly heavier, I find has a nice balance and natural feel to it - any discomfort from controls in different positions disappears after a couple shots.
I am working on the next audition for M42 body - is a Yashica TL Electro X. I've just started a roll now. Its feel so far is close to my Minoltas and it actually has a DOF preview which actually links to the meter (meter comes on when preveiw engaged).

As I'm righting I'm getting the feeling that the issue isn't the combination but the photographer! Embarassed As I don't have much in the way of M42 lenses I'm probably expecting too much from the couple I have. Rolling Eyes Before I totally write off the cameras I need an Adaptall2 M42 adapter for my Tamron lenses - then I can give a fair test. Wink

Jim