MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Testing Sigma 17-50/2.8 before holidays
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I recently acquired this lens and regret not having done it long ago.

1.
DSC_0329 by Lena_i

2.
DSC_0471 by Lena_i

3.
DSC_0526-5 by Lena_i

4.
DSC_1216 by Lena_i

5.
DSC_1224 by Lena_i

6.
DSC_0297-1 by Lena_i


Reply

That black car Shocked Shocked Shocked Razz Razz Razz it's, delicious!

Nice images Smile


Reply

Great photos Lena, but I wonder how do you compare this Sigma 17-50/2.8 with your Tamron 17-50/2.8?
From samples found online I must say, they look pretty equal, also from your photos I remember Tamron to be good performer (one of the reasons why I bought the lens Smile ).

Pozdrawiam
Mateusz


Reply

To tell you the truth, I was never a fan of Sigma lenses. I sticked with the Tamron (two versions in a row) for a few years, but then the Sigma got much cheaper than when it was introduced. Now the prices are comparable.

There are a few advantaged of the Sigma over Tamron, as well as disadvantages.

From my experience, Sigma wins in terms of:
image quality - yes, it really figures without the need to compare crops. My Tokina 11-16 was always a clearly better performer than the Tamron, now Sigma slightly outperforms the Tokina

OS - very helpful for me, I have a terrible handshake and now I can hold 1/30s easily, while I sticked to 1/125 with the Tamron (non VC)

optical performance at 50mm - Tamron deteriorated towards 50mm, while the Sigma seems to be improving. I did some test shots at 50mm/f.2.8 and I couldn't say a bad word about sharpness. The bokeh is also nice for a modern lens.

My arguments in favour of the Tamron:
I like the images at 17mm a bit better
It is smaller and lighter and uses 67mm instead of 77m filters
The older version (no motor) had a warmer colour rendering

Although I was very happy with the Tamron for a long while, now that I got the Sigma I regret not having done it before (after the price drop).