MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

EOS 450d and Sigma 21-35mm f/3.5-4.2
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

This lens only works wide open on my 450D, but I will get good use out of it on my film EOS 10qd.

I tried it tonight for some nighttime shots, all at the 21mm end, and I'm quite impressed. Distortion on APS-C is very little, and it's really sharp considering it's wide open. I see some purple fringing on bright highlights and it flares a lot if there are bright light sources in the frame, but overall, I like it.

#1

#2

#3

#4

#5

#6


Reply

And a few HDRs. The remove ghosts feature of Photomatix really reduced the flare:

#1

#2

#3

#4

#5

#6


Reply

Nice learning phase , some of them interesting as well, good work.


Reply

Cheers. I was bored so I thought I'd try this lens out, I'd read that it would work wide open so I thought I'd see if that was so.


Reply

I would say that's damn decent performance, really like the carousel pix. Cool


Reply

Cheers Bill. I need to try it out on 35mm film soon. Sadly the roll of fp4 I shot with it came out blank due to the fomadon developer having oxidised and died, I thought it looked a bit brown. Sad


Reply

Sux when you find out about the developer the hard way. Wink I may be flying too close to the sun using 6 month expired Xtol.


Reply

Well I got the general impression from people saying "don't get an old sigma zoom"...but the AF 70-210 f4-f5.6 gave sharp results, using film, on my Nikon F-400 (camera and lens bought for £12). So I'm looking for its sister at wider angles at boot sales.


Reply

I've been reading up on the old Sigma AF zooms and primes for EOS because they are so cheap to buy due to not working on digital bodies other than wide open. The build quality is really good, in total contrast to the shoddy plastic crap they sell today. The 75-300 is supposed to be a good lens, much better than the 70-300 APO that replaced it, so I'm keeping my eye out for one of those. The consensus seems to be to avoid the UC series - stands for Ultra Compact but should be for Ultra Crappy is the standard opinion. There's a hell of a lot of different models of Sigma, but with some research and luck, you should be able to find some good ones.


Reply

Very nice results and a really cool flare in #3!
My dad used to shoot with this len on his first DSLR, a Fuji S1Pro and he also liked that Sigma a lot. Pretty heavy beast, though. Wink


Reply

Cheers Carsten. #3 was a 4 minute exposure. I found that the longer the exposure, the more pronounced the flare. It is quite a heavy lens but that doesn't bother me, it just shows it's very solidly built. I wish modern lenses were built like this.