MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

5d mk3 and contax
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

hi all new to this forum .i used to use a 5dmk2 and contax 35 70mm 3.4 lovely lens ,now ive got a 5dmk3 and a lot of lenses ,any users out there that have this combo and are happy,i mainly use live view and do landscape stuff .any mirroe issuies that you know of and do you think in the end it will be possible to get a focus screen .allso any recommendation for more contax or maybe lecia .ive got 35 70mm 3.4
28.28
50mm 1.4
canon 50mm 1.8 really sharp but like the contax look better
100mm 3.5
and can any body recommend the best adapter to get and allso maybe a case to put all my lenses in .musr add they are all near new
totally mint and i think i will never sell them lol


Reply

andya147 wrote:
hi all new to this forum .i used to use a 5dmk2 and contax 35 70mm 3.4 lovely lens ,now ive got a 5dmk3 and a lot of lenses ,any users out there that have this combo and are happy,i mainly use live view and do landscape stuff .any mirroe issuies that you know of and do you think in the end it will be possible to get a focus screen .allso any recommendation for more contax or maybe lecia .ive got 35 70mm 3.4
28.28
50mm 1.4
canon 50mm 1.8 really sharp but like the contax look better
100mm 3.5
and can any body recommend the best adapter to get and allso maybe a case to put all my lenses in .musr add they are all near new
totally mint and i think i will never sell them lol


welcome to the forum!

simple recommendation - get all c/y lenses Laughing

my personal recommendation, get the C/Y distagon 35 1.4 and the C/Y Planar 85 1.4

you cannot go wrong with these lenses and they will cover all needs from basic architeture to street to portrait

i dont have a 5d3 so dont know if there are any issues with using these lenses


Reply

thx for the reply.i notice you have a few contax lenses,i love them just the tone and bokeh


Reply

andya147 wrote:
thx for the reply.i notice you have a few contax lenses,i love them just the tone and bokeh


I've tried a wide variety of lenses ... but in the end, i narrowed down to C/Y lenses for my DSLR's and Leica M lenses for my RangeFinder and a nex7 with some M42 lenses as a travel kit

Do try the C/Y 21mm Distagon for architecture shooting or maybe the C/Y Distagon 18mm if you want to go a little wider

This is a great place to see what a lens is capable of and how some memers have put them to use ->

http://forum.mflenses.com/best-of-lenses-gallery-f37.html

Do share your pictures with us. Where do you post them usually?


Reply

thx for the link Very Happy


Reply

andya147 wrote:
hi all new to this forum .i used to use a 5dmk2 and contax 35 70mm 3.4 lovely lens ,now ive got a 5dmk3 and a lot of lenses ,any users out there that have this combo and are happy,i mainly use live view and do landscape stuff .any mirroe issuies that you know of and do you think in the end it will be possible to get a focus screen .allso any recommendation for more contax or maybe lecia .ive got 35 70mm 3.4
28.28
50mm 1.4
canon 50mm 1.8 really sharp but like the contax look better
100mm 3.5
and can any body recommend the best adapter to get and allso maybe a case to put all my lenses in .musr add they are all near new
totally mint and i think i will never sell them lol

the 50 1.4 is better than 50 1.8 canon
IMHO Rolling Eyes Rolling Eyes


Reply

The Canon 50/1.8 is better if you're shooting test charts at close range, while the Planar 50/1.4 is much sharper at infinity and creates images with much nicer pop and rendering.


Reply

ManualFocus-G wrote:
The Canon 50/1.8 is better if you're shooting test charts at close range, while the Planar 50/1.4 is much sharper at infinity and creates images with much nicer pop and rendering.


field curvature?

and about the problem of andya147
there is the optix v6 ... but it is difficult to find on ebay.
http://www.ebay.it/itm/AF-Confirm-Contax-EOS-PRO-Adapter-Hi-Precision-OPTIX-V6-5D3-5Dmk3-5D-mark3-/280996716893?pt=Camera_Cables_Cords&hash=item416cb5a15d#ht_4581wt_1186


Reply

metallaro1980 wrote:
field curvature?


On the Canon? Possibly. The Zeiss has more CA at closer distances (when shooting a test chart).


Reply

ManualFocus-G wrote:
The Canon 50/1.8 is better if you're shooting test charts at close range, while the Planar 50/1.4 is much sharper at infinity and creates images with much nicer pop and rendering.

Most 50mm lenses are better than the Canon 50/1.8. If it can beat the Planar in any test, you aren't convincing anyone to buy Zeiss.
Cool


Reply

martinsmith99 wrote:
ManualFocus-G wrote:
The Canon 50/1.8 is better if you're shooting test charts at close range, while the Planar 50/1.4 is much sharper at infinity and creates images with much nicer pop and rendering.

Most 50mm lenses are better than the Canon 50/1.8. If it can beat the Planar in any test, you aren't convincing anyone to buy Zeiss.
Cool


Keeping the prices low, bruv...Wink


Reply

for me, the Planar 50 1.4 has more field curvature than Canon 50 1.8.........


Reply

I have a 20D and I use three types of lenses - M42, Contax and Leica R. I've had a number of lenses and sold a number, and my findings have been:

Leica R 35-70 is slightly better than Contax 28-70. Both are excellent
Leica R 75-200 is slightly better than 70-210, which is to say a totally wonderful longer zoom
Leica R 50/2 is a lot better than the Contax 50/1.4 which is actually fairly soft unless you stop down. I regret selling my Contax 50/1.7
Contax 100/3.5 is uncommon, but a cracking good lens and sharper than a Leica R 90/2
I love the look of Super Takumars - even more than SMC versions. Contrary, maybe, but they glow.
Pentax lenses vary more than Leica and Contax. I have two 55/2. One is sharper than the Contax and nearly as sharp as the Leica. The other is rubbish. On the other hand, I have two 135/2.5 Super Taks and they are similar and both very nice.
My Carl Zeiss Jena 35/2.8 is sharper than my CZJ 35/2.4
For 28/2.8 a Leica R is better than a Contax.

I sold off a lot of the cosmetically good Contax and Leica lenses and just kept one or two battered old ones which have good optics, and I mix the odd Contax and Leica R I have left with the good Pentax and Carl Zeiss Jena lenses. I found I could downsize and still get equivalent quality by selecting the best examples that came my way, and I ended up with a much more economical and cost-effective setup. If you have full frame, look for a Leica R 75-200 and see if you can pick up a battered but still good 50/2, unless you are seduced by Super Takumars. They both have a certain look. But then, so did the Contax 50/1.7 I sold - the colours jumped out at you.


Reply

les24preludes wrote:
I have a 20D and I use three types of lenses - M42, Contax and Leica R. I've had a number of lenses and sold a number, and my findings have been:

Leica R 35-70 is slightly better than Contax 28-70. Both are excellent
Leica R 75-200 is slightly better than 70-210, which is to say a totally wonderful longer zoom
Leica R 50/2 is a lot better than the Contax 50/1.4 which is actually fairly soft unless you stop down. I regret selling my Contax 50/1.7
Contax 100/3.5 is uncommon, but a cracking good lens and sharper than a Leica R 90/2
I love the look of Super Takumars - even more than SMC versions. Contrary, maybe, but they glow.
Pentax lenses vary more than Leica and Contax. I have two 55/2. One is sharper than the Contax and nearly as sharp as the Leica. The other is rubbish. On the other hand, I have two 135/2.5 Super Taks and they are similar and both very nice.
My Carl Zeiss Jena 35/2.8 is sharper than my CZJ 35/2.4
For 28/2.8 a Leica R is better than a Contax.

I sold off a lot of the cosmetically good Contax and Leica lenses and just kept one or two battered old ones which have good optics, and I mix the odd Contax and Leica R I have left with the good Pentax and Carl Zeiss Jena lenses. I found I could downsize and still get equivalent quality by selecting the best examples that came my way, and I ended up with a much more economical and cost-effective setup. If you have full frame, look for a Leica R 75-200 and see if you can pick up a battered but still good 50/2, unless you are seduced by Super Takumars. They both have a certain look. But then, so did the Contax 50/1.7 I sold - the colours jumped out at you.


i don't agree about summicron-r 50/2
http://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/824804/0

Fascinating. Note how all lenses have good 3D effect except the Leica, which has, quite simply, none at all. It is the flattest, dullest, most lifeless, lens of them all, in terms of 3D. I suppose you can try to inject 3D effect with a combination of contrast and sharpening manipulations, but in my experience its pictures will never really come alive.
leica-r 28/2.8? probably the rom version but it costs 2000euro!


Reply

Hello there!

Thanks for the link. It's pretty much what I get when I stick lenses on a solid tripod and take infinity shots out of my window. I was testing wide open to f4, and in that range my Leica has more micro-detail than two Contax 50/1,4. You can actually see it in the original thread in the tree detail in the upper left corner at f2. I suspect my Leica is better than the one in the thread, and my two Contax's maybe a little softer just in terms of sharpness.

But in terms of contrast and snap, that's Contax alright. That's what I was saying about the 50/1.7 that I stupidly sold. No argument there.

I think it's important not to pre-judge and take each lens on its merits. I think I detect a hint of sarcasm in "28 must be the ROM version" - you can see my fondness for micro-detail here...... So my working assumption is that you prefer the Contax "look". In terms of the 28/2.8 I was comparing two standard Leicas (one sharper than the other) to one Contax. Same kind of thing - the Leica had more micro-detail.

Which kind of "look" and rendering you like will be a personal preference. Many like the Leica, and where it really used to excel is transparencies through a Leitz projector - the Leica R series and in particular the M series which could be quite stunning.

I'm in the UK where we get a lot of overcast weather and not too much intense sunlight, so maybe I'm more used to subtle effects of light rather than the more exciting "Velvia" look. The Leica lenses always seemed to do best with Kodachrome 64.

How that all translates into digital I don't know. I don't shoot much these days and my digital body (EOS 20D) isn't really good enough to get the best out of lenses like these, though it out-resolves the wide open lens performance in good light.


Reply

les24preludes wrote:
Hello there!

Thanks for the link. It's pretty much what I get when I stick lenses on a solid tripod and take infinity shots out of my window. I was testing wide open to f4, and in that range my Leica has more micro-detail than two Contax 50/1,4. You can actually see it in the original thread in the tree detail in the upper left corner at f2. I suspect my Leica is better than the one in the thread, and my two Contax's maybe a little softer just in terms of sharpness.

But in terms of contrast and snap, that's Contax alright. That's what I was saying about the 50/1.7 that I stupidly sold. No argument there.

I think it's important not to pre-judge and take each lens on its merits. I think I detect a hint of sarcasm in "28 must be the ROM version" - you can see my fondness for micro-detail here...... So my working assumption is that you prefer the Contax "look". In terms of the 28/2.8 I was comparing two standard Leicas (one sharper than the other) to one Contax. Same kind of thing - the Leica had more micro-detail.

Which kind of "look" and rendering you like will be a personal preference. Many like the Leica, and where it really used to excel is transparencies through a Leitz projector - the Leica R series and in particular the M series which could be quite stunning.

I'm in the UK where we get a lot of overcast weather and not too much intense sunlight, so maybe I'm more used to subtle effects of light rather than the more exciting "Velvia" look. The Leica lenses always seemed to do best with Kodachrome 64.

How that all translates into digital I don't know. I don't shoot much these days and my digital body (EOS 20D) isn't really good enough to get the best out of lenses like these, though it out-resolves the wide open lens performance in good light.


i have tested the 50 1.7 and 50 1.4... infinity test...and you can see also the mtf from Zeiss..the 50 1.4 is better... the curves of 50 1.4 are more high than 50 1.7...i saw this also from my test...
http://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/824804/0
there is some of wrong with focus with 50 1.4 .. maybe...but here...the blacks in the shots (bokeh) of summicron-r are less blacks than the blacks in the shots (bokeh) of 50 1.4...