MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

The Pentax king is dead, who will replace him ?
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

The bad news arrived a few days ago, my Pentax K10 is officially uneconomical to repair, it was sent for repair on the 2nd April and I got the death certificate on September 1st - but that's another story.

The purpose of this thread is "tell me what to buy next ?" because I am officially 100% confused.

I liked my K10, it had a lot going for it, far more than I disliked, but overcame. I found the ISO range very restricting, it was crap over 400, I shot 200 and used a tripod or monopod. That's the bad stuff, I loved the weather sealing, the in camera shake reduction, the vast range of lenses that I could use with adapters, the menu was logical and easy, the ergonomics were fine ( I have big hands ) and it did everything I wanted it to do.
But now it's dead.

I have one great lens for the K10 - the superb DA*50-135 f2, I know it's autofocus, but it's fabulous. Even if I rarely use it. Confused I have in total 3 autofocus PK lenses, two I can live without. Three if the prices of the DA are what they seem to be !
I have 7 other manual focus PK lenses, all decent enough but I won't cry if I can't use them.

I also have -
23 M42 lenses ( about half I would really want to keep )
5 M39 T2 lenses - with M42 adapters.
2 M39 Leica thread
8 Canon FD
3 Canon EOS ( not bothered about any of those )
7 Minolta MD ( love these to bits, using these is essential )
4 Minolta AF ( 2 really good ones, I'd like to use, even in MF )
3 Olympus OM ( 1 great lens 2 decent )
and finally -
the kit zoom lens for my Sony NEX 5 18-55mm.

And there ladies and gentlemen lies my problem. I have too much stuff Laughing and no consistency. Rolling Eyes

I've been using my NEX 5 ( and my film cameras ) for damn near 6 months now. Do I miss my K10 ? "yes I do" - but I actually like my NEX a great deal, there is a great freedom using the NEX, I love the live view and focus peaking, I like the way I can use it at arms length and single handed with a light lens. I love the high ISO capability, it's taken a long time to get used to that after the K10, but shooting at ISO1600 regularly and getting very useable images is wonderful. Do I get a NEX 7 ?

Or.....another DSLR ?
I still like the idea of a DSLR, and at the moment a Pentax K5 is probably top of my list for the continuity of great weatherproofing, in camera anti shake and being able to use my very expensive DA lens. I could probably sell that at a profit, so that's not the deal breaker.

I'm not a brand slave, I have no issues with a used camera or an older model. Sell me a DSLR ! Smile


Reply

Another K10 possibly? Wink Smile


Reply

After getting an EOS 450D and seeing how inferior the sensor is to the NEX-3, I really can't recommend buying older cameras, sensor technology has improved so much in such a short space of time. The 450D has a 12mp sensor that isn't that old, but it has inferior dynamic range, far worse noise and a good deal less fine detail than the NEX-3.

Sony SLT cameras are really nice and you can find the A-55 and A-57 on ebay for under 300ukp atm.

You can use your Minolta AF lenses with it. Might be worth it just to use that fabulous Minolta AF mirror lens Wink

Sadly there is no DSLR you can use your Minolta MDs on, but they will serve you well on the NEX.


Reply

Well, I am not going to sell you DSLR as I don't have one and have no interest in having one. My view is this: if you are going to get another camera then you better get one that is sufficiently different from NEX-5 to make it worthwhile. The Pentax is exactly the same crop factor, will have about the same basic IQ and low light ability. Essentially this is a bigger heavier NEX with a better interface and faster AF that can't use half of your lenses. NEX-7 is a very similar story, the main improvement is an interface at the expense of money and bulk.

If I were in your place, I'd look either at a second hand Canon 5D II to get FF and better interface, or at Oly m4/3 camera to get IBIS, a different crop, and better interface (depending on your camera choice though). Alternatively, I'd buy nothing at all and wait for FF mirrorless.


Reply

Pentax K-30. You'll love it.

These reviews ought to sell you:

http://www.dpreview.com/previews/pentax-k-30

http://gizmodo.com/5934221/pentax-k+30-review-bulletproof-body-sensitive-soul

[img]http://www.techradar.com/us/reviews/cameras-and-camcorders/cameras/digital-slrs-hybrids/pentax-k-30-1090208/review[/img]

I do not, however, agree with Gizmodo that it's for 'accident-prone beginner photographers.' I think this camera is great for anyone looking for an intuitive DSLR with great performance and exceptional toughness.


Reply

Get a K5. It is now cheaper and waiting for a newer model.
It's also light speed a head of your old dslr.


Reply

the K30 is certainly a contender, they're around £600 at the moment, the K5 is probably the better option, and they're around £700. The Canon, although a great camera is still over £1,000 for a used camera, my wife knows my limits ! Laughing
The Sony DSLR's are very interesting, I will have to investigate more.
Another K10 ? I've seen good ones for just under £200 and K20'S for £300.

I'm still confused..........


Reply

Sony A580 or 550 are also a good choice if you don't want to go the SLT way. I'm also thinking of getting one eventually but can't decide whether to get a A900 (for FF) or the A580 for a newer sensor (better ISO etc) and movies, and the most important £££ Laughing


Reply

Well as you know i have 2 sony slrs the A55 and the A700 i can honestly say SLT is the way to go, the sony A65 would be my purchase if i was you.
£539 for body only brand new from digitalrev thats price delivered an amazing spec at that price
Or £589 for body and kit lens


Reply

sorry to hear that your K10 finally kicked it

what to get will depend on personal preferences.

If I was in the situation I'd buy a new NEX5R ( or NEX5N ) with the EVF, use it as only camera and sell the NEX5 ( as much as I like Pentax and have some reservations against Sony as a brand, I hardly ever have used my Pentax K-x since I have the 5N. oh, I could sell you my K-x incl. a Katzeye! )

If dSLR I'd take the K30 with improved AF performance over K5 for your Pentax AF lenses and focus peaking for your MF lenses
The K-5 is a bit better specced but I wouldn't know the details
oh, now I googled them, here you go, quote:

Updated list of K-5 advantages vs. K-30
1) faster FPS burst
2) metal body
3) top lcd
4) a few more dedicated buttons (eg separate AF and AE-L, AF number of points selection switch)
5) faster shutter speed 1/8000
6) wider EV compensation
7) provision for battery grip
Cool 14 bit RAW
9) 80 - 51200 ISO
10) expanded bracketing choices
11) expanded user modes (5 vs 2)
12) much longer battery life (~450 shots vs 1,000+)
13) HDMI out
14) microphone jack
15) DOF on the on/off switch
16) much deeper RAW buffer
17) More effective self sensor cleaning (K30 just shakes sensor, K-5 includes some ultra sonic magic that is very effective). Credit to Class A for noticing this. As someone with a K-x and K-5 I can attest to the excellent sensor self cleaning of the K-5 vs the K-x.
1Cool If the K30 sensor performs as the K-01 (seems likely, both 12 bit RAW and ISO100 floor) then the K-5 has slightly better IQ at all ISO's, see DXO graphs

quote from PentaxForums.com: http://www.pentaxforums.com/forums/pentax-k-5/186886-k5-vs-k30-2.html#ixzz25NxHJsvm


Reply

eddieitman wrote:
the sony A65 would be my purchase if i was you.


+1

Also, a57 is great for what it costs. Only drawback is that you will be limited to m42, minolta AF and medium format lenses, but you have a nex for the others.


Reply

The Minolta AF lenses I have are -

Minolta 1.7 / 50mm
Minolta macro 4 / 35-70mm
Tokina SD 4-5.6 / 70-210mm
AND -----the superb Minolta Reflex 500mm, the only AF reflex ever made apparently, which is in mint condition

All those are nice lenses, although the Tokina has had very little use. If I could use those and the M42 on a Sony that would give me over 40 lenses, which should be enough ! Wink The Pentax DA* 50-135 is mint and boxed so I could probably sell that for more than a new Sony ?


Reply

I have a K-5 and it is the best thing I bought in a long time. The ergonomics are great, the WR is really nice and the 14 bit files are a dream to work with. I use a bunch of M42 lenses on it also and I am really loving the results I get with this combo.
If you have questions about it I'd be happy to answer them for you Razz


Reply

Pentax K20D or K-5 Cool


Reply

Go for one of the newer DSLR K's...then you can tell us!

I have the weather sealed K200D but like your K10 the iso above 400 is not great...not that I use that setting.I like its weight in the hand nice and heavy it balances the bigger lenses nicely because it does not have that plasticky light weight "feeling" with a larger lens attached.

The K20D is the one above mine with weather sealing and a few more bells and whistles.I would say go newer rather than older...or perhaps a K100D super?... Laughing


Reply

Sorry to hear about your lovely K10 Dave. 6 months at the repair shop - sounds as though there's a saga there.

It seems to me a large proportion of your lenses are for the NEX and can't be used on K mount, so from that angle I wonder if it's sensible to go with a Pentax DSLR again. But if you want to use your Pentax AF lens to its full capability once again then you're going to need one. That's the choice you need to make yourself. I can't see the wisdom in going for a completely new mount (Sony/Canon) if you can't use the AF lens. And, for the cost, a new NEX-7 isn't going to be worthwhile value over your 5N. Better to buy the EVF if that's what you want. Or maybe it would be better to wait for a Pentax or NEX FF camera.

Just a thought - would you consider a Pentax AF film cam?


Reply

For me, the chance of using your minoltal AF lenses' autofocus is another good point for choosing sony.
But I must admit I'm a bit biased, having enjoyed so much my past and present alphas.


Reply

how often do you reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeealy use all those lenses.

The more I end up with, the more I find myself using but only one. perhaps I'm not sharing my attention evenly


Reply

tromboads wrote:
how often do you reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeealy use all those lenses.

The more I end up with, the more I find myself using but only one. perhaps I'm not sharing my attention evenly


I know....... Rolling Eyes


Reply

paulusje wrote:
I have a K-5 and it is the best thing I bought in a long time. The ergonomics are great, the WR is really nice and the 14 bit files are a dream to work with. I use a bunch of M42 lenses on it also and I am really loving the results I get with this combo.
....


Ditto Smile
Pete


Reply

You know.. i was just thinking.. going from your K10, anything is going to be mental Razz

Did you have a split screen in your K10?

I'm in a similar boat, in that i have a K10, but its getting tired, or I'm getting itchy for another toy...

I'm really having a hard time looking past a kr or kx to be honest.. They are cheap as sh1t at the moment, and, well, I don't really care about 14bit raw files, and i don't tend to use my camera in a monsoon because most of my lenses are not water proof like the K10 Razz I'm not interested in video recording and hdmi what evers. As far as a scanner to play with my M42 glass and K-mount lenses.. well, i mean the Kr has the same LCD as the k5, the autofocus system is better then you K10, the image quality in silly iso land is great. The kr takes lens profiles to auto adjust them, it will run of AA batteries, and its 500odd grams!.

I mean, for use with M42 glass and your auto focus K-mount lenses... "shrugs"

Shit i wonder how much I can get one for over here (australia) .. Man $600 bucks with a 18-55 Lens.

Compared to the K5 / K30
http://www.dpreview.com/products/compare/side-by-side?products=pentax_k5&products=pentax_kr

I reckon that's gota be a bargain. Put the split screen out of your K10 in there and BAM!

as we all wait for a FF body to take K-mount Razz

#Edit there plenty 2nd hand ones around my way from 4-$500. Thats cheap maaaaan


Reply

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrN7xiHGg80

Man I cant help myself. They just look fun! bahahha


Reply

What about a K30 mate?
It's pretty much a K5 with upgraded AF but no mic port.
Plus it has focus peaking. I just picked up one of these body only for $675 australian.
If you are only wanting to shoot manual, then a Nex is a very good investment. Very Happy


Reply

I'd wait for a fullframe mirrorless. Sony is about to anounce one just next week, at least that's what the rumours are saying (apparently a camcorder first, then a regular photo camera a few months later). I'm in a similar situation as you. I've been using my NEX-5 almost exclusively (as far as digital goes) for the last year or so since my A100 died which is actually a very similar camera to a K10. All this time I've been thinking about what to buy to replace it and I almost gave in to an A77 but then it just doesn't make sense to buy a DSLR (any DSLR) when you can't use most of of your lenses with it. So I'm now waiting for that NEX-9 or whatever they'll call it. It certainly won't be cheap though so I may actually go for a NEX-6 instead (which is supposedly about to come out any time now) if my NEX-5 breaks or something.


Reply

yes until then, Get a Kr Razz

Quote:

What about a K30 mate?
It's pretty much a K5 with upgraded AF but no mic port.
Plus it has focus peaking. I just picked up one of these body only for $675 australian.
If you are only wanting to shoot manual, then a Nex is a very good investment. Very Happy


Focus peaking? on a manual lens forum? pull the other one Razz

$675 is cheap. but $400 bucks is cheaper Razz I'm not sure if its our collectively constructed stupid attitude of sporting the underdog. , but the Kr Rocks Razz