MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

My Minolta Gallery.
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Well, the time has come.

Minolta XD7, MD 35-70 f3.5, Rossmann HR400.


Reply

I really like that, is this the lens that was also sold by Leica?


Reply

Like it


patrickh


Reply

Definitely worth a second look Smile


Reply

I don't know whether it's the film or you have done some PP on the image, but this brilliant lens is capable of better results than this IMO. Sorry! Sad


Reply

peterqd wrote:
I don't know whether it's the film or you have done some PP on the image, but this brilliant lens is capable of better results than this IMO. Sorry! Sad
I'm probably out of line here but i'm gonna say it anyway. Give the guy a break, say somthing positive at least and then mention the shortcomings. Jeez talk about cutting a guy in half with a machine gun and giving him a band aid.....


Reply

Iso 400, scanning is always serious issue, nice subject I like it.


Reply

I like it !
If you had posted in film gallery , there wouldn't be any rumors here ... Laughing .No joke , I really like the rendering and colors. The sharpness is good also when viewing after clicking the image. Keep on posting , I am interessed in Minolta lenses and cams (is it the Macro version ?). I am also thinking Id have to try this Rossman film .
Where is this shot taken ? seems to me the Astronomical clock in Prague ?


Reply

yes, it is prague astornomical clock: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prague_Astronomical_Clock


Reply

maxcastle wrote:
peterqd wrote:
I don't know whether it's the film or you have done some PP on the image, but this brilliant lens is capable of better results than this IMO. Sorry! Sad
I'm probably out of line here but i'm gonna say it anyway. Give the guy a break, say somthing positive at least and then mention the shortcomings. Jeez talk about cutting a guy in half with a machine gun and giving him a band aid.....

Sorry you feel that way. It wasn't meant to be unkind or to discourage the photographer, it was just my honest view, but maybe I was a bit blunt. I use this camera/lens combo too and in my opinion this picture doesn't do it justice, but it seems I'm in a minority of one!

OK - it's a very interesting subject and the exposure is spot-on, but for my taste the image is too grainy, which lessens the resolution, and the colours look unnatural - too much magenta. These both result from the choice of film.


Reply

I'm with Peter except that I'd say I think the subject is interesting, but not captured up to the photographer's full potential here. The off-angle in this shot is jarring to my eyes more so than the graininess. Also, I'm not a huge fan of this image's framing. It is exposed quite well and has a great DoF for the subject and perspective.


Reply

Bob van Sikorski wrote:
yes, it is prague astornomical clock: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prague_Astronomical_Clock


Nicest tower clock what I ever seen!


Reply

peterqd wrote:
maxcastle wrote:
peterqd wrote:
I don't know whether it's the film or you have done some PP on the image, but this brilliant lens is capable of better results than this IMO. Sorry! Sad
I'm probably out of line here but i'm gonna say it anyway. Give the guy a break, say somthing positive at least and then mention the shortcomings. Jeez talk about cutting a guy in half with a machine gun and giving him a band aid.....

Sorry you feel that way. It wasn't meant to be unkind or to discourage the photographer, it was just my honest view, but maybe I was a bit blunt. I use this camera/lens combo too and in my opinion this picture doesn't do it justice, but it seems I'm in a minority of one!

OK - it's a very interesting subject and the exposure is spot-on, but for my taste the image is too grainy, which lessens the resolution, and the colours look unnatural - too much magenta. These both result from the choice of film.
Hey peter, its all good, i didn't mean it personally, i was out of line to butt in, my apologies Smile To be in a minority of one doesn't make you mad or wrong.

Last edited by maxcastle on Sun Nov 04, 2012 10:01 am; edited 1 time in total


Reply

David wrote:
I'm with Peter except that I'd say I think the subject is interesting, but not captured up to the photographer's full potential here. The off-angle in this shot is jarring to my eyes more so than the graininess. Also, I'm not a huge fan of this image's framing. It is exposed quite well and has a great DoF for the subject and perspective.

I have to agree about framing and angle .


Reply

What is going on in this 100% crop? What has happened to the highlights? And look at the grain.
Is it a scan of a print possibly? Please help me out and explain why this is a quality image! Shocked


Reply

similar look to that , have my scans of highly underexposed images, i f i try to correct this in vuescan. doesnt work, grain becomes as much visible as in this pic. all in all, it is problem with digital corrections (photoshop cs6, because it is in exif?)


Reply

PErhaps to look for the POP!!! colors is not the same than look for the quality one.

Yes, the pop colors sell the image. The high plus contrast does the photo "modern", but not artistic one.

In this context, the image posted is a good one, modern, with supersaturated colors and high contrast. The photographer did what the consumers market said to us that it's a good photo.

Doesn't that to me. It's only a taste question, I should guess.