MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Recommendation for a dSLR with good video for a beginner
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Hi Folks,

A good friend of mine is thinking of buying a dSLR with good video feature. I am lost here as I don't know a lot about video shooting. One model comes into mind though - Nikon's D5100.

Why? Well, it has excellent high ISO (so Auto ISO setting would be good for him) and from what I read very good HD video.

I was originally thinking of Sony NEX C3 or 5N, but he specifically request a machine that is more robust as it will used around young kids 2 and 4 yr old. They just broke his old Sony digital camcorder so I can sympathise with him.

Any other recommendations?

Thanks.


Reply

If I didn't read all of your post I'd say to get a nex 5n, there's nothing able to shoot such good footage without spending much more.
Sony a57 should perform quite similar to nex 5n in video recording - probably worse at high ISO.
a65 and a77 looked slightly better than that from the quick tests I could do, with a77 having the advantage of a rugged body (and a higher price, of course).
Then there are Canons, from 550d on, that are from acceptable to excellent (I'd choose canon for video only if I could afford a 5d mkII or a 7d, though).



The options are many, depending most on the price range.


Reply

im doing video's with a friend who uses the nikon d7000, i use the canon 60d, we shoot in 720p because 60D gives you 60fps that translates to slow mo but D7000 doesnt do 60fps only 30.

another thing we noticed is the video from the nikon gets Artifacts! like random pixels breaking up for a few seconds, you cant allow that to happen, but sometime you gotta use that scene with artifacts... this is the major issue in my view, you would go for something more solid and tested with video like the canon..

also the compatibility with a major chunk of MF lenses (that are really good for video) is a huge plus i think.

(but if i needed a camera for a photographer and AF lenses i would choose the d7000 no questions.)

hope this can help.


Reply

Clear recommendation for Sony A57
Great video (Full HD with 60FPS), great image quality (superior to Nikon D7000 or Canon 60D), large electronic viewfinder with live-view, fast AF, build in image stabilisation and useable AF in Video (Canon, Nikon, Pentax DSLRs and co don't have these little great features), you can use M42 lenses on it and so on. And it's cheaper than Nikon D7000 or Canon 60D --> more money to spend into a second lens.

If you wan't to buy a cheaper DSLR you should look after a Canon 1100D - of course only HDReady with 30FPS and not usable AF during video or image stabilisation but it's generally nothing wrong with the camera and you can get for around 420€

Don't buy a Nikon if you wan't to use manual lenses! They can be tricky!

Here's a nice list of the best system cameras below 1000€ (in German language though, but should be fairly easy to undersand anyway)
http://www.chip.de/bestenlisten/Bestenliste-DSLR-bis-1.000-Euro--index/detail/id/968/


Reply

I wouldn't say a NEX is any less robust than a DSLR. If there's any danger of the camera being damaged then an expensive one is probably not the way to go. My wife shoots quite acceptable videos on her little Canon IXUS P&S - something like that would be perfectly OK for this, unless of course your friend is into collecting lenses too. Smile


Reply

Another point for the nex5n is that it has the less evident rolling-shutter issues among all of the cmos cameras I tried (I couldn't run accurate tests for that, but I had this impression quite clear).
This is important, especially for a beginner-amateur that will not shoot only from tripods and may not be wanting to pay a lot of extra money for some kind of shoulder support/steady/rig/whatever.


Reply

Hi Folks,

Thanks for the feedback. In consider my friend is a total novice and the fact that he as a limited budget, I think The Nikon D3100 simply ticks all the boxes for picture IQ and AF capability for videos.

OK, there will be noise from the AF motor during video capture.
(See #1 video below for that horrid noise:
http://www.cameralabs.com/reviews/Nikon_D3100/video_review.shtml)

Personally, I don't see any issues with that. He is not an Artistic Director trying to shooting for Hollywood. So think it will be more than adequate for his needs.

Cheers!