MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

5D Mk II w/ Tokina 90 2.5 - Macro Vignetting
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Hi there,

Rather new to manual focus lenses on digital bodies so hoping for some direction. Recently purchased a Fotodiox MD/MC to EOS adapter with the AF confirmation dandelion chip to use with my Tokina 90mm 2.5 macro on the 5d mkii. While the 5d is a full frame camera I was expecting vignetting, but not to such a degree... after a little research on the fotodiox website, I found instructions for removing the magnifying glass in the adapter when in use with macro lenses (which allows for focusing to infinity with other lenses.) I was hoping after removing this glass that there would be a little change but there wasn't.

When shooting wide open, vignetting is so severe it looks as if the image was taken in a tunnel, and the usable portion of the photo is a circle.

For starters, I just want to verify if this is what is supposed to happen with this combination of lens/adapter/camera, or if I am doing something wrong. Thanks.


Reply

Anyone? Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.


Reply

Could you perhaps upload a sample shot, a picture of the lens and the adapter you're using?


Reply

Sample shots.
I never heard of a 90mm vignetting. But I might be wrong.


Reply

I would say that you´re right with your guess - the vignetting is most likely caused by adapter with correction lens for infinity focus.

Minolta MD/MC lenses have too short flange so it can´t be mounted on EOS without modification or adapter with lens for infinity focus.

If you´re into using manual lenses on EOS I would rather choose some other lensmaker than Minolta as you could use adapters without correction lens - f.e. Zeiss, Olympus OM, any M42, Nikkor etc


Reply

fuzzywuzzy wrote:
Could you perhaps upload a sample shot, a picture of the lens and the adapter you're using?


Unfortunately can't upload a sample picture now as I'm out of town, but it's this lens:

http://makingnottaking.blogspot.com/2010/05/tokina-90mm-f25-at-x-macro-bokina.html

And this adapter:

http://www.amazon.com/Fotodiox-Adapter-Dandelion-Confirmation-Minotal/dp/B003Y3EJM0/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1325208250&sr=8-1

As for what it looks like... it's just extreme vignetting. ~70% of the photo exists in practically a circle in the center of the frame, and all the corners are black. The wider the aperture, the less severe the vignetting. But a long exposure shot at f32 created miserable 'tunnel vision'. Even with the magnifying lens' in the adapter removed, still bad vignetting.

Thinking it has to do with the adapter for sure, but not sure if this may be remedied with another adapter or if I should just give up on MD mount lenses all together. Sucks, cause this one is a beauty in minty condition with its original case and 1:1 adapter.


Reply

Well, the good news is that the Tokina 90mm macro (aka "Bokina") is one of the best macro lenses ever. But the bad news is that you have one in Minolta MC/MD mount and you're trying to mount it on a 5D MkII. If I were in your shoes, I'd buy an SRT-101 (with mirror lock-up) for cheap just so I could mount the lens to a good camera so I could take good macro shots with it, although they'll be film shots, of course.

I have a similar problem with my FD lenses for use with my EOS DLSR. I have to use an FD-EOS adapter, but unlike you, I get no vignetting at all with the FD lenses I use. My EOS is an APS-C crop body, though, and not an FF like your 5D II. Does this add to the overall vignetting? I don't know, but I suspect not.

I would tend to blame the adapter. Do you have access to any other MC/MD mount lenses? Do you live in an area where there might be camera shops that stock used photo equipment or pawn shops that do, where you might could try out another MC/MD lens to find out for sure if it's the adapter or the lens?

I agree with berraneck -- there are several lens mounts that will work with the EOS mount without need for an adapter with a corrective optic. M42, Nikon F, and Pentax K are probably the most popular, but Olympus, and Contax/Yashica will also work. I think that Rollei and Konica might also, but they are more obscure, and I just don't know for sure.


Reply

You could try "freelensing", i.e. just hold the lens up to the camera and take a test shot of something very close. If there's no vignetting the adapter must be the culprit.


Reply

Removing the lens from inside the adapter left a hole. The hole is blocking some of the light from the rear of the lens. The hole is acting as a rear-of-lens mask. The hole causes the vignetting.

Choices are to enlarge the hole, or get adapter without lens inside.


Reply

It all depends on where the hole is located in the light path. If it's positioned in the light path such that it's blocking some of the rays, then yes you'll get vignetting. But if it's positioned in the path where, say, the rays are coming together toward a point of focus, having a smaller hole won't matter.


Reply

I am assuming the lens inside the adapter is positioned at the MD register distance -- is that incorrect?

Since the lens in the adapter is smaller diameter than the image circle, the hole must pass a vignette. (holes don't *block* light Laughing)


Reply

visualopsins wrote:
I am assuming the lens inside the adapter is positioned at the MD register distance -- is that incorrect?

Since the lens in the adapter is smaller diameter than the image circle, the hole must pass a vignette. (holes don't *block* light Laughing)


I would assume that the lens inside the adapter is positioned at the MD register distance...

Just to clarify: you believe the vignetting is occurring as a result of the smaller hole that holds the additional magnifying lenses - even if said lenses are removed?

So my options would be to purchase a different adapter without the smaller hole w/magnifying lenses and go without infinity focus OR to purchase the same lens in a different mount (preferably Nikon or Pentax) and have the ability to achieve infinity focus?


Reply

flite wrote:
visualopsins wrote:
I am assuming the lens inside the adapter is positioned at the MD register distance -- is that incorrect?

Since the lens in the adapter is smaller diameter than the image circle, the hole must pass a vignette. (holes don't *block* light Laughing)


I would assume that the lens inside the adapter is positioned at the MD register distance...

Just to clarify: you believe the vignetting is occurring as a result of the smaller hole that holds the additional magnifying lenses - even if said lenses are removed?

So my options would be to purchase a different adapter without the smaller hole w/magnifying lenses and go without infinity focus OR to purchase the same lens in a different mount (preferably Nikon or Pentax) and have the ability to achieve infinity focus?


- when said lenses are removed. That lens system should project an image circle without vignette. Without the lenses, the image circle is vignette to the diameter of the hole; the area around the hole masks part of the image circle projected onto the sensor.


Reply

Will report back once my adapter without magnifying glass arrives.


Reply

Vignetting problem solved! As predicted, it was indeed the portion of the adapter that holds the corrective glass in place which was causing the severe vignetting.

On a different note... this lens is fantastic! Too bad I had to give up infinity focus - this will absolutely suffice for strictly macro use though. Will keep my eye out for the same lens in another mount and sell this one on eventually. Thanks for the help guys!