MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Nikon Coolscan V Test Images (Scroll Down for Variations)
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Okay, I put a box of slides next to me here, and picked out the first slide
that looks like good color AND in-focus on the lightbox.

My "testing" will be done with pretty much random picks as far as the slides go.

I'm not looking for award-winning slides Laughing , just slides that seem to have
decent focus and color.

Lens was Pentax Super Tak 55/1.8

This was scanned with the following setting:
Resolution - 2400
Unsharp Mask - Low
Digital Ice - On/Normal

My comments:
Color rendition is actually pretty good, compared to the lightbox.
Focus is essentially as good as the original slide.
A tiny bit of noise is detectable, which might go away with higher resolution scans.
Digital Ice missed a dust spot (the blurred flower on the left side).
The Unsharp Mask setting does not seem too aggressive, which is a good thing to me.

Not sure what I would do in Photoshop, if anything. Of course, clone out the dust spot,
and perhaps try some additional Unsharp Mask, especially if it was going to be a print.




Last edited by Laurence on Wed Jan 11, 2012 1:45 am; edited 2 times in total


Reply

Sharpness is the biggest thing that lets down most scanners I have read reviews of. The Coolscan has a reputation for being excellent in that regard, and certainly your test confirms that Cool


Reply

GrahamNR17 wrote:
Sharpness is the biggest thing that lets down most scanners I have read reviews of. The Coolscan has a reputation for being excellent in that regard, and certainly your test confirms that Cool


Orio's sharpening add on (action) for Photoshop is very good and I always use it at microcontrast setting 1 or 2.


Reply

GrahamNR17 wrote:
Sharpness is the biggest thing that lets down most scanners I have read reviews of. The Coolscan has a reputation for being excellent in that regard, and certainly your test confirms that Cool


I think I remember also reading about sharpness being a let-down for scanners.

I see a slide here of a very white Hyacinth. I think I'll scan it without the in-scanner sharpening and
see how it looks.

All these boxes of slides....probably over 500 boxes... Shocked Shocked Shocked Shoot, I could have
just bought a whole system of Pentax 645D stuff for all that money....


Reply

Excalibur wrote:
GrahamNR17 wrote:
Sharpness is the biggest thing that lets down most scanners I have read reviews of. The Coolscan has a reputation for being excellent in that regard, and certainly your test confirms that Cool


Orio's sharpening add on (action) for Photoshop is very good and I always use it at microcontrast setting 1 or 2.


Wow, THANKS for the tip! Hey Orio! Are you there? How about me getting that add-on action? Laughing


Reply

Here's the quick scan of the white hyacinth. No sharpening, no nothing.

Thought it would be a good test of variation in white colors.

I have to say it looks much like the slide to me.

I see at least ONE very good thing with this scanner - FAST! I didn't have time
to even drink some water, and the scan was done. Shocked

Resolution: 1200dpi (fooling around with different resolution settings while I'm doing these).

Lens: Super Tak 55/1.8 with +2 diopter closeup filter on front of lens. (All of my slides have
a bunch of lens and exposure info scribbled on the borders - it comes in handy later).

A bit of sharpening wouldn't have hurt. It's a tiny bit soft out of the scanner, but definitely acceptable.



Reply

I found the drivers for Window Vista. My "main" computer is running Vista, and it has a Spyder-
calibrated 24 inch monitor, so I'll try to install on that computer later.


Reply

Orio's sharpening and I don't know if you agree with the new colour but the shot has a colour cast on my monitor and I removed some of it Question



Reply

The hyacinth scan sells it for me. Superb Cool


Reply

Laurence wrote:
Excalibur wrote:
GrahamNR17 wrote:
Sharpness is the biggest thing that lets down most scanners I have read reviews of. The Coolscan has a reputation for being excellent in that regard, and certainly your test confirms that Cool


Orio's sharpening add on (action) for Photoshop is very good and I always use it at microcontrast setting 1 or 2.


Wow, THANKS for the tip! Hey Orio! Are you there? How about me getting that add-on action? Laughing



http://forum.mflenses.com/free-zeissifiers-actions-t20729,highlight,%2Bactions.html


Reply

Excalibur wrote: Orio's sharpening and I don't know if you agree with the new colour but the shot has a colour cast on my monitor and I removed some of it

I think you hit it on the head. NICE job on the coloring. I thought there was a small magenta
color cast on this (uncalibrated) monitor. Perhaps from the Velvia, as I have heard that Velvia
can go a bit magenta in a scan.

The sharpening is just right- not too much, not too little. I love it when forum members try to
make changes to images, so that I can see what's on their minds regarding an image. That's
one great thing about this forum.

And, thank for the link!


Reply

GrahamNR17 wrote:
The hyacinth scan sells it for me. Superb Cool


Yeah, but remember this was an "easier" scan than others might be. Smile


Reply

Camellia
Super Tak 55/1.8

Without Digital GEM or Digital DEE:






WITH Digital GEM and Digital DEE:
Digital GEM is a technology that was developed by a company called Applied Science Fiction. The GEM acronym actually stands for Grain Equalization & Management. What DIGITAL GEM does is that it analyzes a film's grain pattern, extracts all data that is related to image quality, color and sharpness, and removes the grain from the scanned image. This results in dramatically improved images. This is essentially the equivalent of noise reduction in digital images.

Nikon's unique tool Digital DEE can save considerable image editing time for work that has been traditionally done with curves and levels. DEE is available in Nikon Capture and Nikon Scan 4 (LS-9000, LS-5000, LS-50 only) correcting for under and overexposure and revealing detail in shadow and highlight areas without affecting colour balance. It works on file types supported by both Nikon applications however DEE will not work on images taken with other manufacturers digital cameras. The algorithm used is slightly different in either application allowing for the differences in film and digital image sources, however the operation is the same as explained below. Using a complicated processing algorithm backlit subjects, shaded areas of images and overexposure of brightly lit areas is easily corrected.



Reply

No manipulations. Straight out of scanner. This was my version of a "test" for picking up details.
Also, to see how the corners look. I honestly think it's doing a pretty good job. I will "take back"
my earlier statement that the V700 produces a better scan.

I'm leaning toward scanning images without manipulations from the scanner. Then, post-process
in Photoshop. Of course, that could change as I go forward.

Scanning without manipulations is very fast. Maybe 15 seconds or so at 2400dpi. About 35 seconds
at 4000dpi.

Tamron 70-210 Model 46A (not an SP lens)



Reply

The Nikon is working great laurence. I'm anxious to see a lot more from it. I bet you had a big smile on your face when you saw the scans.

The white hyacinth is fantastic, especially with the sharpening.


Reply

I'm really liking the 2nd version of the pink rhodie (?). You have a potent combo with that software!


Reply

Well, I got curious about all the image manipulation going on here, especially reading about Orio's PS actions. So I tried my hand at the hyacinth as well. Fair warning -- the only sort of calibration I've done with my monitor is using sofware to do it -- I don't have an external device. However, what I see on my monitor is what I see in my slides, color-wise, so I think it's pretty close.

I used Paint Shop Pro X4 for the small amount of image editing I did. A bit of high pass sharpening, a very small amount of noise reduction, and a touch of color correction.

To me, Laurence's image has too much magenta and even Excalibur's still has a fair residual amount. This is what I came up with:


Larry, I'm waiting for you to come up with a critically sharp slide, scan it at 4000ppi, then do the same with your V700. And then come back here and show us 100% crops from each. I'm sure the difference will be considerable. Web resolutions being what they are, 1200 ppi and 2400 ppi scans, while fairly low-res for sending output to a printer for example, are too big for forum displays. And the reduced images of these scans can't show us the maximum capability of the scanner. Only way I know how to do that on the web is to show 100% crops of scans. So, I'm looking forward to seeing a 100% crop of one of the LS V 4000 ppi scans compared to a 4800 ppi scan from your Epson V700, downsized so it's the same size as the Nikon's. Now, that will be interesting.


Last edited by cooltouch on Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:39 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

Laurence , congrats for your scanner .
What soft do you use for the scanner? Nikon's, Silverfast,or Vuescan? What film is it ?


Reply

Schnauzer wrote:
The Nikon is working great laurence. I'm anxious to see a lot more from it. I bet you had a big smile on your face when you saw the scans.

The white hyacinth is fantastic, especially with the sharpening.


Well, it's certainly doing better than anticipated, especially not knowing much about all the tweaks yet. I'm just
"shooting from the hip". Yeah, the hyacinth with the sharpening action looks damn good.


Reply

Katastrofo wrote:
I'm really liking the 2nd version of the pink rhodie (?). You have a potent combo with that software!


I was shocked at the difference between the scans, that's for sure. Shocked


Reply

GREAT post Michael! I TRULY like what you did with the hyacinth, and love that you gave a good
explanation of your methodology. THANK YOU for that. I was saying earlier how this kind of response
from forum members really is a great "hands on" look at making an image better. Highly appreciated,
and ANYONE may do ANYTHING to my posts as far as I'm concerned. My posts aren't here for an "ego
show", they are to help me and others understand how images can be improved.

GREAT idea on the comparison scans! That WILL be done very soon. I am happy to get some direction
on a good way to go about it, so thanks once again. Smile


Reply

yinyangbt wrote:
Laurence , congrats for your scanner .
What soft do you use for the scanner? Nikon's, Silverfast,or Vuescan? What film is it ?


The scanner isn't mine to keep yet, although if I end up feeling it's really worth keeping, I'll
certainly make an offer to the kind friend who is letting me try it out.

Just using Nikon's software. To me, it's very well laid out. I've heard others say they like the other
software types, but gosh, this one is working and I am learning from its very nice intuitive layout.

My slides (all zillion boxes of them) are either Provia or Velvia.


Reply

Laurence wrote:
yinyangbt wrote:
Laurence , congrats for your scanner .
What soft do you use for the scanner? Nikon's, Silverfast,or Vuescan? What film is it ?


The scanner isn't mine to keep yet, although if I end up feeling it's really worth keeping, I'll
certainly make an offer to the kind friend who is letting me try it out.

Just using Nikon's software. To me, it's very well laid out. I've heard others say they like the other
software types, but gosh, this one is working and I am learning from its very nice intuitive layout.

My slides (all zillion boxes of them) are either Provia or Velvia.

Have to use the apropriate setting for the specific film (color pattern) wich the software is equipped with. I'd try it also with a Viewscan demo and also with the Silverfast dedicated for Nikon in demo before making a definitive decision. I think you can get wonderful scans with this unit .Remains to see wich soft gives for you the best results.

http://www.silverfast.com/get_demo/en.html

http://www.hamrick.com/ (for Viewscan)


Reply

Hey Teo, THANKS for the links. I'll certainly try them, especially if one or both of them have
a specific setting for Velvia or Provia. So far, I like Nikon's GEM and DEE settings, which
automatically do a "levels" and "curves" adjustment to average out the darkest blacks and
the blown-out highlights, and comes up with a middle value. Great algorithms. Shocked These
middle values don't affect the color, which is really nice. Well, at least they don't affect the
color TONE - they do affect the intensity of light on the colors - so the COLOR SHADE is not
changed, just the amount of illumination.