MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Canon 10D or Pentax K10D ???
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Goodmorning everybody ,
I own a Canon Eos 40D and some manual lenses ( mostly m42 ) .
I was considering of buying a second camera to use during `special` missions ( beach etc ) . I recently saw two adds about a Canon 10D and a Pentax K10D .
Tha Canon comes with the original grip and 3 batteries and it has about 10k shots . ( cost 100 euros )
The Pentax comes with battery and the owner is honest enough to say that he has done some modifications that he reversed . If you are interested i can tell you what he did . ( cost 80 euros ) .
I m thinking that Canon can use more mf lenses but Pentax is weather sealed newer model , more mps but i m reading here that it is a bit hard to get an evaluation on exposure more or less totaly unpredictable . Also the seller of the Pentax told my that he found it difficult to focus accuratelly ( but he said that for all digital slrs because they are made to be used with af lenses ) .
So what is your opinion ? Go for one of the 2 or just wait for a better deal ?

Kind Regards ,

Panos .


Reply

Hi,
the Pentax has simply the better digital sensor - giving much better images.
The sealed body may be interesting for your puposes too.

As for the AF:
In really low light it has some problems - that's right.
In pretty good light there are no problems (except continous AF - that is really not the strength of Pentax).
I don't know if the "old" 10D is that better - the 40D is again a much better AF-generation!

As for exposure and WB:
There are some problems with situations with different souces of light (daylight, lamps ...) and there are some lenses well known for exposure problems (that means that you have to use exposure compensation for example with the 16-45).

The best way is perhaps the 18-55 WR (!) lens that sealed too and pretty cheap.

The 10D has the same mount and ergonomics like your 40D...

So: What lenses do you want to use with this 2nd dslr? That may be the main question.


Reply

Pentax is definitely overlall more modern camera. And don't forget in body stabilization, which works with all lenses (even old MF). Sometimes it's very handy.


Reply

Pentax also has a much larger viewfinder: the crop factor is less (1.5x vs 1.6x), and magnification is 0.95x vs 0.88x.

For focusing with manual lenses, the only way to reliably focus on modern cameras is to replace the focusing screen with one made for mf lenses. On Pentax cameras it's really easy to do, and there's plenty of third party screens from 20$ up. If you use it with af lenses instead, I seem to remember that exposure is better if you swap the original screen with one from the istD/Ds cameras.

The K10D for 80€ is a great bargain, if you pass on it send me a PM. Smile


Reply

Goodmorning my friends ,
thank all of you for your interest . The camera will be used with mf lenses .
I dont intend to buy any more af lenses at the moment at least .
So about the exposure how does the K10D works ? Do i under(or over )expose a bit at all times or it is indeed totaly unpredictable ?


Reply

panos wrote:
So about the exposure how does the K10D works ? Do i under(or over )expose a bit at all times or it is indeed totaly unpredictable ?


My Kx had a large difference in exposure with M42 lenses, which decreased when stopping down. But it's easy to check the histogram and adjust. One way to improve accuracy was to short the last contact on the camera mount, to simulate the use of a Pentax K lens. Check pentaxforums.com there's plenty of threads on this subject.


Reply

Canon takes C/Y .. but you wouldn't take your Distagon to the beach anyways .. Wink


Reply

kansalliskala wrote:
Canon takes C/Y .. but you wouldn't take your Distagon to the beach anyways .. Wink


I wish i had some my friend but they are to expensive for me at the moment .
Althow i would take them to the beach with my 40D for a special occasion ( such as a great landscape or a great sunset ) .
What s the point of having some good tools that provide fun for your hobby and not using them ?

And a question whats the difference between these screens ???
http://shop.ebay.com/i.html?_nkw=istd+screen&_sacat=0&_odkw=m42+to+pk&_osacat=0&_trksid=p3286.c0.m270.l1313

Thanks .

Panos .


Reply

panos wrote:

So about the exposure how does the K10D works ? Do i under(or over )expose a bit at all times or it is indeed totaly unpredictable ?


I do not own the K10D but the earlier *istDs and the later K-x:
the *istDs is metering M42 lenses rather well using A mode, but that does not seem to be true anymore with all the later Pentax models.
On my K-x I have to use M mode and press the 'green button' to measure, one more step to do, but even more accurate than A mode on *istDs.

I don't know how accurate the K10D measures M42 lenses, but think it's not that bad at all, anyway I am quite certain that best will be using M mode and pressing green button to measure


Reply

Having gone from a 300D (10D's brother) to the K10D, the K10D is superior for manual lens use in every way Cool

I use an OEM Pentax *ist LI-60 screen, and I've never used a cheap split screen...mostly since I don't want to deal with possible spacing issues. I hate grid lines so I went with the gun sight-like screen Laughing



Reply

I can't comment on the Canon, except that it can use more lenses. How *well* it uses them is something else. Wink I have the K20D and have studied the K10D a bit. Here is what I think I know:

Pros: This semi-prosumer camera has great controls. Weather sealing is great, even with non-WR lenses. Tethering can be useful for some applications. IBIS / SR (shake reduction) makes a BIG difference, and works with ANY lens. CIF (catch-in-focus aka trap-focus) is also great; I greatly depend on CIF, as my old eyeballs are delaminating. (Split-focus screens are best with well-lit contrasty subjects.) The K10D's sensor is highly regarded for rendering at low ISO.

Cons: Slow AF, and noisy high-ISO performance. The K10D is NOT for low-ambient-light action shooting!

If I were looking for reasonable backup bodies to my K20D, I would choose the Pentax Kr for high-ISO performance, and the K10D for low-ISO rendering. And with simple minimal surgery, I can adapt C/Y and OM and Exakta lenses to the PK mounts.