MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

camera body IS and zoom lenses-opinions sought
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

most cameras that have in body stabilization also have corresponding in cam settings to optimize this function for prime lense. so you change the settings to accomodate each of the prime focal legnths. setting up incorrectly, say cam at 35mm for an 85mm lens, will adversely effect performance.

by definition zooms have varying focal legnths, so they cannot be coordinated with IS camera settings. so what do members do in this situation: set cam for the highest FL where cam shake is more of a problem? set cam at midpoint between smallest and largest FL? turn off in cam IS altogether?

very interested in member thoughts!


Reply

I set the camera (Pentax K200D) to the longest focal length and turn it off for the shorter lengths. If I am doing low-light and am using shutter speeds less than the reciprocal of the focal length, then I will set the camera to the correct focal length, this only takes a few seconds.


Reply

I set it roughly to 2/3rds of the zoom range, or to the most likely focal length I reckon to be using. I have not verified how much sense the 2/3rds setting makes, but I reckon it might be a rational solution


Reply

Someone at PentaxForums posted this algorithm, where MIN is the minimum focal length and MAX is the maximum:

(2 * MIN * MAX) / (MIN + MAX)

Thus I should tell the SR (shake reduction) 'bot these numbers for these lenses:

35-80 ===> 49mm
35-135 ==> 56mm
55-135 ==> 78mm
60-300 ==> 100mm
70-210 ==> 105mm
80-200 ==> 114mm

I should tape those numbers to those lenses, eh? Of course the SR 'bot isn't quite so precise, so I would actually enter the closest approximation.

In practice, I may use a manual zoom only zoomed far in or out, and I will enter the exact focal length. Or I will pretend I am using a slow zoom in good light on a film SLR, and I will turn SR off and shoot with a shutter speed faster than 1/(2*FL). Or I will turn SR off and depend on a tripod. Whatever works, eh?


Reply

how interesting! on what is the algorithm based?

theres a formula for everything!

great info, thanks.

my original question presupposed that there wasnt time to constantly adjust IS settings, such as in street photogs, or parties etc, where zooms cam come in handy. so this chart is perfect for my orig purpose of one setting, forget it, shoot!

i think that you have also hit onsomething, whichis why is IS necessary at all when shooting at high shutter speeds? indeed, i wonder if IS ay high shutter speeds can be harmful to the shot, as it is when using a tripod?

any thoughts anyone?


Reply

rbelyell wrote:
how interesting! on what is the algorithm based?


I haven't seen the original source but it appears to be based on the averaging of shutter speeds.

Suppose that you have a zoom with minimum focal length FLMIN and maximum focal length FLMAX. And suppose that your normal practice is to shoot at a shutter speed SS = 1/F where SS is in seconds and the focal length of the lens, F, is in mm. Then...

SSMIN = 1/FLMIN

SSMAX = 1/FLMAX

The average shutter speed, SSAV is ..

SSAV = (SSMIN + SSMAX)/2

SSAV = (1/FLMIN + 1/FLMAX)/2

SSAV =(FLMAX + FLMIN)/(2*FLMIN*FLMAX)

We can now convert the average shutter speed, SSAV, into an average focal length, FLAV, by ...

FLAV = 1/SSAV, whence ...

FLAV = (2*FLMIN*FLMAX)/(FLMIN+FLMAX)

EDIT : Shutter speed is really a "time" since it's measured in seconds, but the term is commonly used.


Last edited by sichko on Mon May 16, 2011 9:22 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

awesome john, thank you!

waddya' think about IS adversly effecting IQ at high shutter speeds?


Reply

I've never shot with a camera with in-body IS. I shoot Nikon which uses VR (Vibration Reduction) in its lenses. I find it difficult to shoot handheld with FLs longer than about 100 - 120 mm without using VR. Its not simply the stabilisation during the exposure that matters. It's actually holding the subject in the frame without any "jitter". So I tend to use VR even on very bright sunny days when I can use a fast shutter speed. I'm not sure if this is a good or bad thing.


Reply

rbelyell wrote:
waddya' think about IS adversly effecting IQ at high shutter speeds?

Over on PentaxForums last year, Falk Lumo did thorough tests of various lenses on Pentax SR systems. IIRC he showed that SR has good effect on short FL's and great effect on longer FL's, at slow-to-moderate shutter speeds, and has NO negative effects at faster shutter speeds. SR gave a typical effective gain of 1.5-3 f-stops at speeds slower than 1/FL, something like that. And that was with the old SR. I've read the gain with the K5 is more like 2-4 f-stops.

Ansel Adams wrote in The Camera that he tried following the 1/FL shutter rule with a 35mm FF camera with a 50mm lens -- hold it steady and shoot at 1/50. He couldn't get sharp shots. He DIDN'T get sharp shots till he sped up to 1/250.

So the rule for handheld sharpness would be 1 / (5*FL). What, only shoot a 100mm at 1/500 or faster? Argh! But if the old SR might give an average of 2 f-stops gain, then we can drop that speed about 2 stops, to 1/125... or 1/100, which follows the old 1/FL rule! (There's also a little gain by the dSLR having a smaller sensor frame, which figures in here.)

Conclusion: If you want sharper pictures, leave SR on, except when shooting very close (macros etc) or on a tripod or timer.


Reply

rico thanks so much for such valuable info! wow, i alwaysfollowed (ormore accurately, knew about but constantly disregarded!) the 1/fl rule, and so to find its more like 5/fl is truly interesting and incredibly valuable! i wish we could post yoyr post in a place where everyone could see it...maybe i'll email attila on it.


Reply

Oh, I've mentioned 1/5FL before. Remember that it's a rule for handheld small-camera sharpness TO ANSEL ADAMS' STANDARD! It also translates as: Use the fastest shutter speed and the lowest ISO that you can. But 1/5FL is for slow pictorial shots. With humans and action, the rule is more like: Do whatever is necessary to get the shot.

So for 'scapes and details and shots of stuff that isn't moving around, a tripod or fast shutter speed, with lowest ISO and a "sweet-spot" aperture setting for DOF, gives sharp pictures. For humans and action, SR and 1/FL and a wide aperture and floating ISO gives dramatic pictures. Do whatever it takes. Any shot you get is better than any shot you don't get.