MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

ist DS focus confirmation "problem" (or is it norm
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

I owned a * ist D for a short time and liked it so much. The balance, weight and ergonomics were great. The picture quality was good. The viewfinder is clear. And I liked the colour balance out of the camera. The only downside was with manual lenses there was no focus confirmation. I was using M42 lenses – my preferred mount – and, because my eyesight is getting old, getting a too high % of OOF shots. I don’t shoot moving images by the way. I started using an LX3. I said if I bought another DSLR it would be the ist DS version as this has focus confirmation.

Well last week I bought one and it’s as good as the D. But the focus confirmation (FC) has been a big disappointment. I’m using 2 lenses with the official Pentax adapter: the Helios 44M and Super Paragon 24mm. But the FC can’t be trusted. I don’t know what its accuracy rate is but definitely less than 50%. Is this normal? My aging eyes are more accurate. The beep and focus confirmation light comes on and the focus is in the right ballpark but inaccurate enough to be unusable. I’m talking about in good light as well. I was outdoors last week using aperture fully open and fast shutter speed. The FC was poor. My eyes got it right more. Later on in dimmer indoor light, aperture fully open still the FC still got it wrong and my eyes did more often too. But my eyes still did better than the FC.

My question: is this normal?

I’m now thinking I’ll have to buy AF lenses. I prefer M42 for various reasons: cost, history (I was brought up with them) and more. Or sell and go back to the LX3.


Reply

On Pentax, focus confirmation seems to be more accurate when you are focusing FROM infinity (confirmed on istds2 and K200d)


Reply

The D has focus confirmation too, same as the DS. Just put a piece of aluminum foil on the rightmost contact when you screw on the lens.


Reply

@Jieffe: now we might be onto something here. I shot off 6 quick shots when I got in. Set focus to infinity first, half pressed photo button and held it then turned focus ring away from infinity until confirmation light came on. 4 in focus, 2 not (my fault). Came back alter shot another 6. Same results. Then shot 20 in quick succession. All in focus bar a couple (my fault again. Too low light). So I'm happy. I'm pretty stoked with the DS.

I'll have more time later in week. I used Super Paragon today. I'll try Helios next. Thanks v much.

@ludoo: I thought it was ist DL onwards only that did the foil trick. Never mind. Too late now.


Reply

Are you certain the istD does not have focus confirm? I have one.. and mine does?

Doug

PS I think the setting was deep in a menu somewhere?

cheesegears wrote:
I owned a * ist D for a short time and liked it so much. The balance, weight and ergonomics were great. The picture quality was good. The viewfinder is clear. And I liked the colour balance out of the camera. The only downside was with manual lenses there was no focus confirmation. I was using M42 lenses – my preferred mount – and, because my eyesight is getting old, getting a too high % of OOF shots. I don’t shoot moving images by the way. I started using an LX3. I said if I bought another DSLR it would be the ist DS version as this has focus confirmation.

Well last week I bought one and it’s as good as the D. But the focus confirmation (FC) has been a big disappointment. I’m using 2 lenses with the official Pentax adapter: the Helios 44M and Super Paragon 24mm. But the FC can’t be trusted. I don’t know what its accuracy rate is but definitely less than 50%. Is this normal? My aging eyes are more accurate. The beep and focus confirmation light comes on and the focus is in the right ballpark but inaccurate enough to be unusable. I’m talking about in good light as well. I was outdoors last week using aperture fully open and fast shutter speed. The FC was poor. My eyes got it right more. Later on in dimmer indoor light, aperture fully open still the FC still got it wrong and my eyes did more often too. But my eyes still did better than the FC.

My question: is this normal?

I’m now thinking I’ll have to buy AF lenses. I prefer M42 for various reasons: cost, history (I was brought up with them) and more. Or sell and go back to the LX3.


Reply

nemesis101 wrote:
Are you certain the istD does not have focus confirm? I have one.. and mine does?

Doug

PS I think the setting was deep in a menu somewhere?

cheesegears wrote:
I owned a * ist D for a short time and liked it so much. The balance, weight and ergonomics were great. The picture quality was good. The viewfinder is clear. And I liked the colour balance out of the camera. The only downside was with manual lenses there was no focus confirmation. I was using M42 lenses – my preferred mount – and, because my eyesight is getting old, getting a too high % of OOF shots. I don’t shoot moving images by the way. I started using an LX3. I said if I bought another DSLR it would be the ist DS version as this has focus confirmation.

Well last week I bought one and it’s as good as the D. But the focus confirmation (FC) has been a big disappointment. I’m using 2 lenses with the official Pentax adapter: the Helios 44M and Super Paragon 24mm. But the FC can’t be trusted. I don’t know what its accuracy rate is but definitely less than 50%. Is this normal? My aging eyes are more accurate. The beep and focus confirmation light comes on and the focus is in the right ballpark but inaccurate enough to be unusable. I’m talking about in good light as well. I was outdoors last week using aperture fully open and fast shutter speed. The FC was poor. My eyes got it right more. Later on in dimmer indoor light, aperture fully open still the FC still got it wrong and my eyes did more often too. But my eyes still did better than the FC.

My question: is this normal?

I’m now thinking I’ll have to buy AF lenses. I prefer M42 for various reasons: cost, history (I was brought up with them) and more. Or sell and go back to the LX3.


@Doug:Everything I read, including on here, said no. Not with M42's anyway. You had to do the foil trick. And I'm not sure even the D did that. It seemed to vary across models and lenses even. It doesn't matter for me now although it may be relevant to someone else.

@everyone:I'll report back later in week about my further DS experimenting. Let me just say now I love the colours out of the DS. I've the 18-55mm kit lens as well as the 2 M42's I mentioned. I like accurate colours and the Pentax delivers. Coming from the LX3 (that puts a yellow/orange cast on every non daylight shot, puts a layer of salmon pink on skin tones and can't reproduce the colour yellow to brown range properly even with v2.0 software) it's a delight.

I also have RSI in my dominant right hand/wrist/arm. Some things are impossible/very hard to hold others far easier. The Pentax is at the far easier end of the spectrum. It took about 40 mins of almost non stop grip fo my fingers to start paining. Normally I wouldn't abuse my hand like that but I'd just got the camera. 40 mins is a huge amount of time for me. Some things are so heavy/badly weighted etc I can't hold them even 1 minute but not the DS. I love the camera.


Reply

cheesegears wrote:
I also have RSI in my dominant right hand/wrist/arm. Some things are impossible/very hard to hold others far easier. The Pentax is at the far easier end of the spectrum. It took about 40 mins of almost non stop grip fo my fingers to start paining. Normally I wouldn't abuse my hand like that but I'd just got the camera. 40 mins is a huge amount of time for me. Some things are so heavy/badly weighted etc I can't hold them even 1 minute but not the DS. I love the camera.


Yes, the D, DS and probably also the new KX are wonderful: small, light, and they seem to adapt to your hand. My favourite way of carrying my D is to wrap the strap around my right hand, and have the camera hanging by my fingers. I can carry it around all day like this. The only problem is if I have to fetch the keys from my right pants pocket. Smile


Reply

ludoo wrote:
cheesegears wrote:
I also have RSI in my dominant right hand/wrist/arm. Some things are impossible/very hard to hold others far easier. The Pentax is at the far easier end of the spectrum. It took about 40 mins of almost non stop grip fo my fingers to start paining. Normally I wouldn't abuse my hand like that but I'd just got the camera. 40 mins is a huge amount of time for me. Some things are so heavy/badly weighted etc I can't hold them even 1 minute but not the DS. I love the camera.


Yes, the D, DS and probably also the new KX are wonderful: small, light, and they seem to adapt to your hand. My favourite way of carrying my D is to wrap the strap around my right hand, and have the camera hanging by my fingers. I can carry it around all day like this. The only problem is if I have to fetch the keys from my right pants pocket. Smile


I've not attached the strap yet. I have several of those wrist straps that screw into the camera tripod thread, from my 8mm days. It means the camera can hang from my wrist with only the lightest of right hand grips. Or I can even use the strap on my left hand with a full grip. Either way my hands don't take anywhere near the full weight.

The other thing I like about the ist ds is when your fingers settle on the grip your index finger automatically falls on the shutter button and your thumb on the wheel on the back. This is very ergonomic and Pentax should be praised.

I had less success using focus confirmation on the helios 44m, though. Used same technique as with the super paragon but you can go straight past point of focus without the confirmation light coming on or beep going off. I sometimes had to turn the focus ring back in opposite direction (knowing full well I'd passed focus point) towards infinity and then I'd get confirmation sometimes. I stress the sometimes. This was in good light. The success rate was very low. I was at it for ages getting sadder and sadder. The success rate was close to 100% with my eyes. They're fine in good light. But the slightest drop in good light and I start struggling.

So, I've had mixed results. I've put the 18-55mm AF back on. But I've an Industar 50mm on the way. We'll see what this one does as regards focus confirmation. I'll post then.


Reply

Quote:
I've not attached the strap yet. I have several of those wrist straps that screw into the camera tripod thread, from my 8mm days. It means the camera can hang from my wrist with only the lightest of right hand grips. Or I can even use the strap on my left hand with a full grip. Either way my hands don't take anywhere near the full weight.

The other thing I like about the ist ds is when your fingers settle on the grip your index finger automatically falls on the shutter button and your thumb on the wheel on the back. This is very ergonomic and Pentax should be praised.

I had less success using focus confirmation on the helios 44m, though. Used same technique as with the super paragon but you can go straight past point of focus without the confirmation light coming on or beep going off. I sometimes had to turn the focus ring back in opposite direction (knowing full well I'd passed focus point) towards infinity and then I'd get confirmation sometimes. I stress the sometimes. This was in good light. The success rate was very low. I was at it for ages getting sadder and sadder. The success rate was close to 100% with my eyes. They're fine in good light. But the slightest drop in good light and I start struggling.

So, I've had mixed results. I've put the 18-55mm AF back on. But I've an Industar 50mm on the way. We'll see what this one does as regards focus confirmation. I'll post then.


Industar came yesterday. Off with the 18-55, on with the m42 adapter (again! I hate all this on and off business). I got lucky with the Industar. Just took an ebay risk on one attached to a zenit 12 (I think). Didn't even ask about lens condition. Daft. It went for 99p. Plus a whopping £7+ postage. I said just send lens and got post down to £2+.

I was lucky: the lens is unmarked. I knew it was small but it's the first time I've seen it in real life. I laughed when I put it on the ist ds. It was dead easy to focus. It's just obvious, in good light - and even lessening light - where the focus point is. And you don't have to move the barrel that much. I then tried focus confirmation and it was mostly a success. This is currently my favourite even though I've only had it 2 days. I'll be out tomorrow testing it more.