About PL Filter

[djmike]

I won one Nikkor 35-105/3.5~4.5 Zoom Macro version with Hoya PL filter. Here are two shots as comparison.

Nikon FM2 + Nikkor Zoom + PL + Reala ISO100 (resize only); under macro


Canon 400D + CZJ Flektogon 35/2.4 MC + CPL (resize only)


I need comment from these two whether saturation on PL with Nikkor Zoom is too much? And do you use PL filter frequently with sunny day?
Thanks, Mike

[eeyore_nl]

I only use a polarizer for landscape shots, but yours seems to give a strong hue to the images.

Can I say that I am extremely jealous at your weather?

[djmike]

Eeyore_nl, I think you're right. I shall remove PL next time.
ps: That's about 2 weeks ago. Yep, it's a great sunny day.

[Scoo]

Reala scan vs. digital (could you get an Nikon -> EOS adapter and try with identical settings)?


EDIT: oh, and are these different polarizers on different days?