MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Adapter-Exposure Issue... I'm going mad!
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

could someone of you explain that?:

today i used an unchiped adapter for the first time. i used it with my 1,8/50 pancolar on my eos30.

m42-eos (unchiped)
when i put the lens (wide open) to the camera, the display shows "00" for aperture. in my test setup (constant light) the camera sets the shutter to 1/500s.

m42-eos (chipped)
when i put the lens (wide open) to the camera, the display shws "1,8" for aperure (as expected... caus the chip is set to 1,8). in the same test setup (constant light) the camera sets the shutter to 1/90s.

this would mean that the same object (with same light) would be underexposured 2 1/2 stops with the unchipped adapter in relation to the chipped adapter. am i right? or am i missing something?

when i look at the different aperture settings shown by the camera, that would make sense to me.


Reply

If you mount the non-chip adapter, the camera has no idea what setting to use for the shutter speed since it appears that there is no EF lens mounted. You should use an external light meter and set the camera to M or use either Av or Tv.

When you mount the chipped adapter, in your case, the camera believes there is an f1.8 lens mounted and adjusts accordingly - with no regard to the actual f stop the lens is set to physically. The only reason at this point to having the chip is to activate the little green focus indicator. Setting the chip to a new f setting is usually needed. The default f1.8 would be good possibly for an f1.4 lens.

I usually set the chips to f2.8 through f5.6 depending on the lenses largest opening. For example, the f2.8 chip setting is good for an f1.8 lens with settings from 1.8 to 3.5. When shooting RAW this gives me a nice range of acceptable physical f settings to use - it can be stretched either way a bit more of course with the loss of exposure quality. As you can see, if you have, for example, three lenses you use a lot, having three adapters, each set to each lenses characteristics is the way to go. This way you leave the adapter on the lenses. That is the way I have done it.

I hope this helps a bit. The chipped adapters are nice when set up. The descriptions would usually lead one to believe they are a cure all for MF shooters out of the box and is not so.


Last edited by greg on Wed Sep 16, 2009 2:58 pm; edited 2 times in total


Reply

thank you for your fast reply.

most of what you say was also clear before. but i couldn't believe that people that are using unchipped adapters allways have to use external light meter! is that right?

why is a chip set to 1.8 good for a 1.4 lens? does it have something to do with that inexplicable issue here:
http://forum.mflenses.com/metering-with-mf-stop-down-lenses-on-canon-dslrs-t18126.html


Reply

supahmario wrote:
thank you for your fast reply.

most of what you say was also clear before. but i couldn't believe that people that are using unchipped adapters allways have to use external light meter! is that right? - +++ I have adjusted my post above regarding this+++++Greg

why is a chip set to 1.8 good for a 1.4 lens? does it have something to do with that inexplicable issue here:
http://forum.mflenses.com/metering-with-mf-stop-down-lenses-on-canon-dslrs-t18126.html


If the camera uses the setting of f1.8 for exposure with an f1.4 lens, you can can get good RAW exposure results when the lens is manually adjusted from wide open down to 2.8 when using Av mode. If you set the chip to 2.8 with a 1.4 lens you MIGHT be able to squeak by from wide open to 3.5 in RAW.

Yes, the thread does deal with this. I have tried to boil it down to a simple explanation without theory getting in the way. Very Happy Very Happy


Reply

Now, I am confused.

My EOS 350D and my 40D meter exactly the same no matter if I use a chipped or non-chipped adapter.

Wide open the metering is spot on, the more I stop down the more the meter overexposes. This is typical behaviour for EOS meters.


Reply

LucisPictor wrote:
Now, I am confused.

My EOS 350D and my 40D meter exactly the same no matter if I use a chipped or non-chipped adapter.

Wide open the metering is spot on, the more I stop down the more the meter overexposes. This is typical behaviour for EOS meters.


yes that's exactly my confusion!
can anybody explain that?

i also thought it could have something to do with my eos30.
some chipped adapters dont work with eos30/33. perhaps there's something special with the camera!?

and to bring up some more confusion:
one month ago i shot with my sonnar on bellows with the non-chipped adapter. and the results didn't show any special exposure issues.
(btw: the image in my new avatar is from one of these macro-shots)


Reply

i found this
http://www.troeszter.net/ZenitarPage.htm

it's written in german. this guy points out that his eos30 underexposures up to 4 stops with unchipped adapter! but he doesn't provide an explanation! Evil or Very Mad


Reply

I'm confused too. Without chip my 350D won't select correct shutter speed in P mode, seems random, like greg wrote. I wrote that in forum a while ago and many responded "it does too!" I was newbe then so I just shut up. Wink

In Manual mode I use meter in viewfinder to dial correct shutter speed; external meter not necessary.

I haven't checked, maybe LucisPictor's and other's 350D has different firmware version? (earlier or later I don't know) Or is non-US model? (mine is US)

With 55/1.8 chip metering is off same as LucisPictor, seems good with lenses f/2.8 or faster and overexposes more and more as stop down increases.

I had wondered if different chip settings might help, but never got around to getting programmable chip; thanks greg for confirming! (pun intended Smile)


Reply

I can't help out with particular problems on these models. My only usage is with my XTi. One thought only - are you all shooting raw or JPG? The little guy inside Canon cameras does very strange things in JPG mode when he is faced with strange settings. I have images taken 1/2 hour after sunset where everything looks like it was done in late afternoon. The firmware does strange things with JPG. RAW is left alone.

My 'thing' is street shooting where I have to be unintrusive. (sp?) I usually use a Peleng 3.5/8 fisheye or the MEYER LYDITH 3.5/30. I have the adapters set at 5.6 and shoot in RAW only. That way I can see how I am doing on exposure since the RAW image will show very bright or dark if I am waaay off on the aperture setting in a given situation. If I shot JPG and RAW, the JPG is shown in the viewer and as I mentioned above- is not a true representation of what is actually going on. Normally I can shoot from wide open down to 11 with either lens and have a recoverable image. I set the lens at hyperfocal, turn on the secondary trigger on the grip battery pack and shoot away from the hip. It appears that since I trigger it at the bottom of the camera that I am just walking along and supporting the camera from swinging. In city settings the background noise covers the mirror slap.


Last edited by greg on Thu Sep 17, 2009 3:23 am; edited 1 time in total


Reply

Ah, another possible factor. I shoot RAW exclusively. Another factor you just made me think of may be using AWB, which I do most of the time.

My 5D (V1) acts same as my 350D did, random shutter speed in P without chip, and okay speeds with lenses 2.8 and faster, but overexposure stopped down using 55/1.8 chip.

I have no problems; have learned to work around it all. Sure would be nice to nail all the whys and wherefors for everybody though...


Reply

Yes, that might have a bearing. I never us AWB as I don't trust that guy inside the camera to know what is going on.

http://topdeadcenter.wordpress.com/new-york-city-daytrips/nyc-day-trip-04-25-2009-part-2/

Above is a link using the Lydith and XTi with the method I mentioned in the above post

http://topdeadcenter.wordpress.com/new-york-city-daytrips/nyc-day-trip-04-25-2009/

Above are the Peleng shots. Some shot inside a subway station - not the best lighting in the world.

Please excuse if the focus is not dead perfect as I use the hyperfocal settings.

So, by re-setting the adapter to a midrange of the settings you expect to use, the adapter works very well. In a very,very,very large percentage of my shots I use the Av mode. If I want to play with fast moving stuff or want motion blur I will go to Tv. I never use P or M and can't offer any help/opinion on how they work with the adapters.


Reply

LucisPictor wrote:
Now, I am confused.

My EOS 350D and my 40D meter exactly the same no matter if I use a chipped or non-chipped adapter.

Wide open the metering is spot on, the more I stop down the more the meter overexposes. This is typical behaviour for EOS meters.


I don't think that is the case. I think the exposure variation depends on the lens, with many of them having the best reading in the f5.6 -f11 range, when set on AV. Maybe this is something to do with how the overall illumination of the frame compares with the illumination of the metered area. If so, the metering mode would be important.

In any case, it is necessary to keep an eye on the histogram to ensure correct exposure.

Maybe it is worth reposting the test I did a few days ago with my 5DII on AV using evaluative metering with a bunch of different lenses and (except in one case) unchipped adapters.

Biometar 80/2.6, under-exposes by about a stop at f2.8, gradually improves until it is accurate at f5.6, over-exposes very slightly at f8 and then is right at f11 and under-exposing by about a stop by the time it gets to f22.

Leica Summicron-90 performs well from f2 to f5.6 and then tails off to being about two stops underexposed at f22.

The Zeiss Flektogon 20/2.8 is half a stop under at f2.8, improves to about f5.6 goes slightly over at f8 and is then back down to one stop below at f22.

The Biometar 120/2.8 is about 1/3 of a stop under at f2.8, and declines steadily to -2.5 stops at f22.

The Zeiss Triotar 135/4 (my only chipped adapter) is about a stop under at f4, improves to correct exposure at f8 and then declines to 2 stops under at f45.

The Micro-Nikkor 55/3.5 is consistently within half a stop from f3.5 to f16, then drops to -2 by f22

With rare exceptions, it seems that the reading is close enough at between f5.6 and f11 for it not to matter much. The worst under-exposure comes at f14 to f22.

By comparison with the manual lenses, the Canon 24-70 f2.8 metered correctly at all apertures. Of course, the lens and the meter were designed for each other.


Reply

LucisPictor wrote:
Now, I am confused.

My EOS 350D and my 40D meter exactly the same no matter if I use a chipped or non-chipped adapter.

Wide open the metering is spot on, the more I stop down the more the meter overexposes. This is typical behaviour for EOS meters.


carsten, what aperture setting does your camera show when you use unchipped adapters?


Reply

My 1DsMKIII shows also "00" with an unchipped adapter


Reply

Rolf wrote:
My 1DsMKIII shows also "00" with an unchipped adapter


and do you have (with same light) the same or different shutter speeds in AV mode using unchipped and chipped adapters in comparison?


Reply

supahmario wrote:
Rolf wrote:
My 1DsMKIII shows also "00" with an unchipped adapter


and do you have (with same light) the same or different shutter speeds in AV mode using unchipped and chipped adapters in comparison?


No, I have different.

I tested it here at my desk
unchipped (always 00 ) shutter speed 1/80
chipped (shows 2.0) shutter speed 1/100


Reply

Rolf wrote:
supahmario wrote:
Rolf wrote:
My 1DsMKIII shows also "00" with an unchipped adapter


and do you have (with same light) the same or different shutter speeds in AV mode using unchipped and chipped adapters in comparison?


No, I have different.

I tested it here at my desk
unchipped (always 00 ) shutter speed 1/80
chipped (shows 2.0) shutter speed 1/100


but that's just a small difference. but why does my eos30 show such a big difference? can anybody explain that?


Reply

jippie...

i found something!
http://photonotes.org/articles/eos-manual-lenses/#new

so... i have to overexposure 3 stops! i am SOOO happy to know, that it is a known issue! nothing is more frustrating to me, than being not able to understand a topic! now i have settled down.

so now we know: it's a special eos30 issue!