MFlenses - A new life in a digital age
MFLenses 2026

Manual Focus Lenses Forum

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.

Explore the world of vintage lenses through repair notes, real test shots, and detailed archive threads packed with images.
Spotlight

Featured partner placement for the forum front page.

Praktica/Primoplan on eBay
View previous topic :: View next topic  


Reply

Hi All,

If my aging eyes are working properly, that's a 58/1.9 Primoplan on this Praktica.

Click here to see on Ebay

Jon

Not a lens I often see attached to one of these eBay specials, and it's not called out by name in the listing - so maybe it will go fairly cheap. I don't need a second example, so maybe someone here can grab it at a decent price.

(No affiliation with the seller, etc.)

Cheers,

Jon

(Edited to use the proper tags - sorry!)


Last edited by Univer on Fri Aug 21, 2009 9:02 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

Hey , please include item number here between Ebay brackets

[ebay]item number...[/ebay]


Reply

Oops, sorry. You've got better tags than the other boards I hang out on! Appropriately edited.

Jon


Reply

Univer wrote:
Oops, sorry. You've got better tags than the other boards I hang out on! Appropriately edited.

Jon



Thanks Jon!This is own development Wink


Reply

So, what's the deal with the Primoplan being suddenly so desirable and expensive?


Reply

Arkku wrote:
So, what's the deal with the Primoplan being suddenly so desirable and expensive?


It's silver and looks sexy Laughing


Reply

Shrek wrote:
Arkku wrote:
So, what's the deal with the Primoplan being suddenly so desirable and expensive?


It's silver and looks sexy Laughing


Good lens and not expensive.


Reply

Attila wrote:
Shrek wrote:

It's silver and looks sexy :lol:


Good lens and not expensive.


I think Shrek is probably right about the real reason (silver). It would be nice if it weren't expensive, but lately it seems that one of these always costs in excess of $100 (although in the auction linked here the buyer did get a camera body “for free”).

I do have one of the M42-mount Primoplan 58mm f/1.9's myself, and although it is rather sexy in silver, I don't think it's worth quite this much. (Bought mine with fungus for spare change a couple of years ago and cleaned it up.)


Reply

Arkku wrote:
Attila wrote:
Shrek wrote:

It's silver and looks sexy Laughing


Good lens and not expensive.


I think Shrek is probably right about the real reason (silver). It would be nice if it weren't expensive, but lately it seems that one of these always costs in excess of $100 (although in the auction linked here the buyer did get a camera body “for free”).

I do have one of the M42-mount Primoplan 58mm f/1.9's myself, and although it is rather sexy in silver, I don't think it's worth quite this much. (Bought mine with fungus for spare change a couple of years ago and cleaned it up.)


Silver not enough to rise it's price, like silver Tessar not fetch this price.

Primoplan is more rare and better too my copy is a good performer really.


Reply

here are the reasons:
  • unique optical desing (5/4 triplet-based derivate), probably the only 50mm SLR (DSLR compatible) lens based on this design
  • unique bokeh - all Primoplans has very specific and nice bokeh, which is impossible to find on other lenses
  • round aperture - many blades, which are rounder than on Zeiss lenses
  • excellent for portrait and retro fotography
  • extremely low axial (bokeh) CA - I have never found a <f/2 lens, which has so low axial CA

Primplan 58/1.9 has sharp center, while corners are softer, but that doesn't reduce bokeh or portrait usability. Low CA ensures bokeh without color artifacting. There are two versions of this lens - 1. early (full manual aperture) - I suggest a hood for this lens, pre-war version is uncoated, post war has coating - and 2. late (pre-set) model, which has the front element embedded quite deeply in the body, so hood isn't necessary. Late model is always coated.


Reply

Attila wrote:

Silver not enough to rise it's price, like silver Tessar not fetch this price.

Primoplan is more rare and better too my copy is a good performer really.


Well, actually, silver* is enough: there's a recent auction in the completed listings of eBay showing a silver M42 Tessar 50mm f/2.8 going for $102.50, with 23 bids. This is not just a one-time anomaly, a couple of weeks back another one went for $73 (not as high, but still very expensive for a Tessar). Meanwhile the non-silver Tessars, especially the unwanted zebra version, typically go for a third of that or less.


Meanwhile I do agree that the Primoplan is better and has many interesting qualities, but I'm still amazed at its current price. Makes me think I should perhaps sell my own and profit, but I can't since it makes such a good match with old-style M42 film bodies. =)


* I do realise the silver version is also more rare, and obviously that has an effect because people wanting the silver version have less lenses to compete for, but that requires people who really want the silver version (more than the cheaper non-silver) for some reason, be it the colour or (relative) rarity itself.


Last edited by Arkku on Sat Aug 22, 2009 12:50 pm; edited 1 time in total


Reply

Arkku wrote:
Attila wrote:

Silver not enough to rise it's price, like silver Tessar not fetch this price.

Primoplan is more rare and better too my copy is a good performer really.


Well, actually, silver is enough: there's a recent auction in the completed listings of eBay showing a silver M42 Tessar 50mm f/2.8 going for $102.50, with 23 bids. This is not just a one-time anomaly, a couple of weeks back another one went for $73 (not as high, but still very expensive for a Tessar). Meanwhile the non-silver Tessars, especially the unwanted zebra version, typically go for a third of that or less.


Meanwhile I do agree that the Primoplan is better and has many interesting qualities, but I'm still amazed at its current price. Makes me think I should perhaps sell my own and profit, but I can't since it makes such a good match with old-style M42 film bodies. =)



Shocked real surprise


Reply

I think that it depends on huge number of buyers desire to get something. I remember in 2007 close to fall the prices for one Nikon's body raised rapidly and for good Nikon EM body only it was necessary to pay $70 -$80. This is a very good camera but what is average price for this camera now? I have, let me say - perfect copy of primoplan, which is better then my 2 biotars, but more then $100? Then I prefer to pay $50+ for good copy of aluminum body Helios 44 with SN started with two "zeros". Smile