Asahi 135mm/2.5 + reversed doublet versus nikkor 105mm/4

[Rusty]

I am always delighted by the type of macro pruduced by the guys with the FZ50's and acromats
So i decided to do a little test and test my tak against a good macro lens
Both are good clean copies , images done on tripod with pop up flash in av mode at approx 1:2 enlargement (the max the nikkor kan do without tube
The doublet was from a old tokina zoom , fitted to a uv filter ring
I was surprised and redid the test , with the same result
On my monitor the tak wins !! What do you think ?

tak crop

nikkor crop

[sichko]

The "white" background in the Nikkor picture appears somewhat darker on my monitor.