| Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen |
| Autor |
Nachricht |
Phalbert
 Anmeldungsdatum: 17.05.2009 Beiträge: 420 Wohnort: Namibia
|
 Verfasst am: Mi Dez 30, 2020 4:01 pm Titel: Zeiss CY T* 70-210/3,5 vs 80-200/4 worth price difference ? |
|
 Verfasst am: Mi Dez 30, 2020 4:01 pm Titel: Zeiss CY T* 70-210/3,5 vs 80-200/4 worth price difference ? |
|
|
Phalbert wrote:
Hi folks. The question is in the subject. It seems that both lenses are very good and I do have the 80-200 (rather happy with it). But the 70-210 is worth twice tbe money if I believe the quick check I did on ebay. It's quite bigger, much heavier, and also a bit faster. Has anyone had the opportunity to use both and tell us if the differences are "significant" ? I'm especially interested in the performance wide open. Thanks a lot. _________________ My wishlist: Titan or Idaho 135/1,8 Nikon Df Nikkor 105/1,8 35/1,4 85/1,4
Soligor 17/4 Komura 28/3,5 Komura 24/4
Sigma 400/5,6 mirror Tamron 350/5,6 mirror
My dream lenses: Zuiko 180/2 Prototype Zuiko 85/1,4
Zeiss CY: 55/1,2 85/1,2
Astro Berlin 250/2 Canon EF 50/1,0 85/1,2
Nikkor 105/1,4 28/1,4
My stolen stuff: Zuiko 24/2 #106874; Zuiko 35-80/2,8 #102180; Zuiko 35/2 #119168; Zuiko 90/2 macro #102858; Zuiko x1,4 converter #102019; Tamron 17/3,5 #400567; Tamron 400/4 #80407; Soligor 135/2 #17506600 Sigma 28/1,8 #1001124 |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
Phalbert
 Anmeldungsdatum: 17.05.2009 Beiträge: 420 Wohnort: Namibia
|
 Verfasst am: Mi Dez 30, 2020 4:05 pm Titel: |
|
 Verfasst am: Mi Dez 30, 2020 4:05 pm Titel: |
|
|
Phalbert wrote:
O ja. I forgot. It looks like the tamron 70-210 f3,5 (19AH) might be an option too (also highly regarded). If anyone has an experience compared to one of the others... Thanks. _________________ My wishlist: Titan or Idaho 135/1,8 Nikon Df Nikkor 105/1,8 35/1,4 85/1,4
Soligor 17/4 Komura 28/3,5 Komura 24/4
Sigma 400/5,6 mirror Tamron 350/5,6 mirror
My dream lenses: Zuiko 180/2 Prototype Zuiko 85/1,4
Zeiss CY: 55/1,2 85/1,2
Astro Berlin 250/2 Canon EF 50/1,0 85/1,2
Nikkor 105/1,4 28/1,4
My stolen stuff: Zuiko 24/2 #106874; Zuiko 35-80/2,8 #102180; Zuiko 35/2 #119168; Zuiko 90/2 macro #102858; Zuiko x1,4 converter #102019; Tamron 17/3,5 #400567; Tamron 400/4 #80407; Soligor 135/2 #17506600 Sigma 28/1,8 #1001124 |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
stevemark
 Anmeldungsdatum: 29.04.2011 Beiträge: 5509 Wohnort: Switzerland
|
 Verfasst am: Mi Dez 30, 2020 10:40 pm Titel: |
|
 Verfasst am: Mi Dez 30, 2020 10:40 pm Titel: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| Phalbert hat folgendes geschrieben:: |
| O ja. I forgot. It looks like the tamron 70-210 f3,5 (19AH) might be an option too (also highly regarded). If anyone has an experience compared to one of the others... Thanks. |
I happen to have all three lenses mentioned. My sample of the Tamron 70-210 f3,5 (19AH), while looking pristine, is underwhelming and probably a lemon (certainly not what I would expect after reading the adaptall2.com review).
Back to the Zeiss lenses - the Vario Sonnar CY 3.5/70-210mm is one of the few CY lenses exclusively made in Germany (along with the 3.5/15, the 2.8/16 Fisheye, the 2.8/35 Shift and the 2.8/300 APO).
The 3.5/70-210mm is huge and heavy (1185 g vs the 720 g of the Vario-Sonnar 4/80-200). Both are "pumper-zooms", the 3.5/70-210mm is about 10 mm longer than the 4/80-200mm.
left: Contax RTS with Zeiss Vario-Sonnar 3.5/70-210mm; right: Contax RTS II with Vario-Sonnar 4/80-200mm
The 4/80-200 focuses to 1 m, the 3.5/70-210mm only to 1.8 m. The Vario-Sonnar 3.5/70-210mm, however, has the craziest macro mode of any zomm I know: If you set the zoom / focus ring to "70mm" and "1.8m" and engage the macro modus, you get about 1:1.2 (!), but your object will be just a few mm away from the front lens (!!). Chose yourself what you need ...
Now the most important thing - performance in the infinity range. I have compared the two Zeiss zooms side-by-side on 24 MP FF, and they basically have the same (excellent) performance. Most other 80-200/70-210 zooms from the 1975-1985 time frame have slightly or visibly unsharp corners wide open (e. g. Canon 4/80-200mm L, the Konica AR 4/80-200mm UC, the Minolta/Leica 4/70-210mm, the Nikkor AiS 4.5/80-200 and 4/80-200, the Pentax-A 4/70-210, and the Yashica 4/80-200) ; the two Zeiss zooms haven't. They have, however, not really less lateral CAs than the other zooms mentioned. In fact, the Canon 80-200L looks cleaner at 200mm/f11 than the Zeiss 4/80-200mm (and the Minolta/Sony 2.8/70-200mm APO G looks cleaner and sharper than all zooms mentioned here, just to put it in perspective).
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
Phalbert
 Anmeldungsdatum: 17.05.2009 Beiträge: 420 Wohnort: Namibia
|
 Verfasst am: Do Dez 31, 2020 9:51 am Titel: |
|
 Verfasst am: Do Dez 31, 2020 9:51 am Titel: |
|
|
Phalbert wrote:
Wow ! Steve, thanks a lot for a great input. Exactly what I've been looking for, and a very nice pic is a bonus. Thanks again.  _________________ My wishlist: Titan or Idaho 135/1,8 Nikon Df Nikkor 105/1,8 35/1,4 85/1,4
Soligor 17/4 Komura 28/3,5 Komura 24/4
Sigma 400/5,6 mirror Tamron 350/5,6 mirror
My dream lenses: Zuiko 180/2 Prototype Zuiko 85/1,4
Zeiss CY: 55/1,2 85/1,2
Astro Berlin 250/2 Canon EF 50/1,0 85/1,2
Nikkor 105/1,4 28/1,4
My stolen stuff: Zuiko 24/2 #106874; Zuiko 35-80/2,8 #102180; Zuiko 35/2 #119168; Zuiko 90/2 macro #102858; Zuiko x1,4 converter #102019; Tamron 17/3,5 #400567; Tamron 400/4 #80407; Soligor 135/2 #17506600 Sigma 28/1,8 #1001124 |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
Alsatian2017
 Anmeldungsdatum: 05.03.2018 Beiträge: 293
|
 Verfasst am: Do Dez 31, 2020 11:11 am Titel: |
|
 Verfasst am: Do Dez 31, 2020 11:11 am Titel: |
|
|
Alsatian2017 wrote:
| Phalbert hat folgendes geschrieben:: |
Wow ! Steve, thanks a lot for a great input. Exactly what I've been looking for, and a very nice pic is a bonus. Thanks again.  |
Hello, I agree with Steve's judgement of the Tamron 19AH - the two samples i've gotten up to now have been quite good but far from being the "best 70-210 lenses ever built" as claimed by the writer of Adaptall.org. So, this statement seems to be largely overblown and mainly based on the (most likely) limited experience and means of comparison of the writer mentioned above.
BTW, the German journalist Walter E. Schön did a very thorough test of the 33 80-200 something zoom lenses available in spring 1983 and the behemoth Zeiss Vario-Sonnar 70-210 mm f/3.5 was one of the tested lenses. While the tested sample gave very good results in the IQ department (very good resolution and contrast even in the "macro" range), it couldn't fetch good marks in handling due to its enormous size and weight. In the same test, the MD 75-200 f/4,5 ranked first, followed by the Leitz clone, Nikkor 80-200 mm f/4, Canon FD 80-200 mm f/4, Mamiya E 80-200 mm f/3.8, Nikon Series E 70-210 mm f/4, Canon FD 70-210 mm f/4 and Fuji Fujinar-X 80-200 mm f/3,8 lenses.
The Canon FD 80-200 f/4 L and Zeiss Vario-Sonnar 80-200 mm f/4 lenses are more recent and better than the lenses mentioned above, not only in terms of IQ but in practical terms as well (size, weight, MFD, etc.). While Steve obviously got a sub-standard sample of the 80-200 L with mediocre corner sharpness, my own sample is much better and up to the reputation of this lens (5 Stars in Chasseur d'images).
Greetings from Alsace
Volker |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
stevemark
 Anmeldungsdatum: 29.04.2011 Beiträge: 5509 Wohnort: Switzerland
|
 Verfasst am: Do Dez 31, 2020 8:31 pm Titel: |
|
 Verfasst am: Do Dez 31, 2020 8:31 pm Titel: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| Alsatian2017 hat folgendes geschrieben:: |
While Steve obviously got a sub-standard sample of the 80-200 L with mediocre corner sharpness, my own sample is much better and up to the reputation of this lens (5 Stars in Chasseur d'images).
|
We still have to sort out that! Your crops published here a while ago were inconclusive (certainly not much better than mine). I suggest you to take a simple landscape image with a diagonal horizon, at 4/80mm and at 4/200mm. Then I'll look for a similar landscape and light situation, and do the same. That should allow some more or less reliable conclusions.
In addition, some years ago, I did compare my nFD 80-200L with a brand new EF 4/70-200L (probably the II version), and that one too wasn't much better than my nFD.
I had similar (although more severe) problems with my nFD 5.6/100-300L. Some weeks ago I got a second copy of the nFD 100-300L. Comparing these two pristine looking copies resulted in some differences - one being better at 100mm, the other being better at 300mm. The differences weren't dramatic, but visible.
S _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
Alsatian2017
 Anmeldungsdatum: 05.03.2018 Beiträge: 293
|
 Verfasst am: Fr Jan 01, 2021 8:42 am Titel: |
|
 Verfasst am: Fr Jan 01, 2021 8:42 am Titel: |
|
|
Alsatian2017 wrote:
| stevemark hat folgendes geschrieben:: |
| Alsatian2017 hat folgendes geschrieben:: |
While Steve obviously got a sub-standard sample of the 80-200 L with mediocre corner sharpness, my own sample is much better and up to the reputation of this lens (5 Stars in Chasseur d'images).
|
We still have to sort out that! Your crops published here a while ago were inconclusive (certainly not much better than mine). I suggest you to take a simple landscape image with a diagonal horizon, at 4/80mm and at 4/200mm. Then I'll look for a similar landscape and light situation, and do the same. That should allow some more or less reliable conclusions.
In addition, some years ago, I did compare my nFD 80-200L with a brand new EF 4/70-200L (probably the II version), and that one too wasn't much better than my nFD.
I had similar (although more severe) problems with my nFD 5.6/100-300L. Some weeks ago I got a second copy of the nFD 100-300L. Comparing these two pristine looking copies resulted in some differences - one being better at 100mm, the other being better at 300mm. The differences weren't dramatic, but visible.
S |
Hello Steve,
I'll try to do that, recently the weather around here has been grey and/or foggy, far from perfect for test pictures. Which EF 70-200 f/4 did you try out, with or without IS, first or second IS version? I still have a rather good copy of the very first version (plain, without IS), so I could compare it as well.
I wish you a happy new year
Volker |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
stevemark
 Anmeldungsdatum: 29.04.2011 Beiträge: 5509 Wohnort: Switzerland
|
 Verfasst am: Fr Jan 01, 2021 1:25 pm Titel: |
|
 Verfasst am: Fr Jan 01, 2021 1:25 pm Titel: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
| Alsatian2017 hat folgendes geschrieben:: |
Hello Steve,
I'll try to do that, recently the weather around here has been grey and/or foggy, far from perfect for test pictures. |
Same here, so no need to hurry. Don't get me wrong - I'm not claiming that your copy is as "bad" as mine; I'm just curious to see how yours really performs. Sadly the nFD 4/80-200L is quite scarce here ... otherwise I would have gotten & tried a second copy myself.
| Alsatian2017 hat folgendes geschrieben:: |
Which EF 70-200 f/4 did you try out, with or without IS, first or second IS version?
|
It was around 2015 or 2016, at a local (Zürich) photography equipment fair. The Canon people gave me the current version, I went outside and did compare the two samples. It's (i. e. the EF 4/70-200) results were slightly better, but certainly not worth to spend so much money, especially since I mainly use the SAL 2.8/70-200 G.
| Alsatian2017 hat folgendes geschrieben:: |
I wish you a happy new year
Volker |
Thanks !! _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
stevemark
 Anmeldungsdatum: 29.04.2011 Beiträge: 5509 Wohnort: Switzerland
|
 Verfasst am: Di Jan 09, 2024 7:47 pm Titel: |
|
 Verfasst am: Di Jan 09, 2024 7:47 pm Titel: |
|
|
stevemark wrote:
There's a nice looking Zeiss Vario-Sonnar CY 4/80-200mm available at a local photo store.
CHF 100.-- plus postage => PM me if interested.
Equally nice Zeiss Distagon CY 2.8/28mm and Planar CY 1.4/50mm also available, CHF 100.-- each.
S
Postage:
* CHF 25.-- to European countries, including tracking
* CHF 32.-- to all other countries, including tracking _________________ www.artaphot.ch |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
pleto
Anmeldungsdatum: 18.10.2019 Beiträge: 45
|
 Verfasst am: Fr Jan 12, 2024 3:25 pm Titel: |
|
 Verfasst am: Fr Jan 12, 2024 3:25 pm Titel: |
|
|
pleto wrote:
http://www.marcocavina.com/articoli_fotografici/Zeiss_varioSonnar_70-210/00_pag.htm
Marco Cavina wrote an extended history of the two lenses.
The 80-200 Is the last incarnation of a family of Zeiss zooms.
Its designer would then go to work at Leitz.
It Is better and lighter than the 70-210.
Use a translator. Good in-depth article |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
Doc Sharptail
 Anmeldungsdatum: 23.11.2020 Beiträge: 1504 Wohnort: Winnipeg Canada
|
 Verfasst am: Fr Jan 12, 2024 4:27 pm Titel: |
|
 Verfasst am: Fr Jan 12, 2024 4:27 pm Titel: |
|
|
Doc Sharptail wrote:
Reading that about the Tamron 19-AH is a bit of a (not unexpected) let down for me.
There's a 103-A sitting on the desk beside me as I type this- a dust covered bit of a gem that nobody wanted and I got out of a photo shop's junk bin for the princely sum of $5.00. While not an earth shatteringly fantastic lens, it seems to be at least competent in most image making situations, provided I can stop down a click or two.
Usually with Tamron, reading on-line user reviews will help with the decision making process. I view the Adaptall site as only a basic starting point these days.
-D.S. _________________
D-810, F2, FTN, FT-3 in Black
35mm f2 O.C. nikkor
50 f2 H nikkor, 50 f2 H.C. nikkor, 50 f 1.4 AI-s, 135 f3.5 Q,
50 f2 K nikkor 2x, 28-85mm f3.5-4.5 A/I-s, 35-105 3.5-4.5 A/I-s, 200mm f4 Micro A/I, partial list.
"Ain't no half-way" -S.R.V.
"Oh Yeah... Alright" -Paul Simon |
|
| Nach oben |
|
 |
|
|
|
Du kannst keine Beiträge in dieses Forum schreiben. Du kannst auf Beiträge in diesem Forum nicht antworten. Du kannst deine Beiträge in diesem Forum nicht bearbeiten. Du kannst deine Beiträge in diesem Forum nicht löschen. Du kannst an Umfragen in diesem Forum nicht mitmachen.
|